300,000 Organic Farmers Sue Monsanto in Federal Court: Decision on March 31st to Go to Trial
Little did Willie Nelson know when he recorded “Crazy” years ago just how crazy it would become for our cherished family farmers in America. Nelson, President of Farm Aid, has recently called for the national Occupy movement to declare an “Occupy the Food System” action.
Nelson states, “Corporate control of our food system has led to the loss of millions of family farmers, destruction of our soil…”
Hundreds of citizens, (even including NYC chefs in their white chef hats) joined Occupy the Food System groups, ie Food Democracy Now, gathered outside the Federal Courts in Manhattan on January 31st, to support organic family farmers in their landmark lawsuit against Big Agribusiness giant Monsanto. (Organic Seed Growers & Trade Association v. Monsanto) Oral arguments were heard that day concerning the lawsuit by 83 plaintiffs representing over 300,000 organic farmers, organic seed growers, and organic seed businesses.
The lawsuit addresses the bizarre and shocking issue of Monsanto harassing and threatening organic farmers with lawsuits of “patent infringement” if any organic farmer ends up with any trace amount of GM seeds on their organic farmland.
Judge Naomi Buckwald heard the oral arguments on Monsanto’s Motion to Dismiss, and the legal team from Public Patent Foundation represented the rights of American organic farmers against Monsanto, maker of GM seeds, [and additionally, Agent Orange, dioxin, etc.]
After hearing the arguments, Judge Buckwald stated that on March 31st she will hand down her decision on whether the lawsuit will move forward to trial.
Not only does this lawsuit debate the issue of Monsanto potentially ruining the organic farmers’ pure seeds and crops with the introduction of Monsanto’s genetically modified (GM) seeds anywhere near the organic farms, but additionally any nearby GM fields can withstand Monsanto’s Roundup herbicides, thus possibly further contaminating the organic farms nearby if Roundup is used.
Of course, the organic farmers don’t want anything to do with that ole contaminated GM seed in the first place. In fact, that is why they are certified organic farmers. Hello? But now they have to worry about getting sued by the very monster they abhor, and even have to spend extra money and land (for buffers which only sometimes deter the contaminated seed from being swept by the wind into their crop land). At this point, they are even having to resort to not growing at all the following organic plants: soybeans, corn, cotton, sugar beets, and canola, …just to protect themselves from having any (unwanted) plant that Monsanto could possibly sue them over.
“Crazy, crazy for feeling so…..”
The farmers are suffering the threat of possible loss of Right Livelihood. They are creating good jobs for Americans, and supplying our purest foods. These organic farmers are bringing Americans healthy food so we can be a healthy Nation, instead of the undernourished and obese kids and adults that President Obama worries so much about us becoming.
So what was President Obama doing when he appointed Michael Taylor, a former VP of Monsanto, as Sr. Advisor to the Commissioner at the FDA? The FDA is responsible for “label requirements” and recently ruled under Michael Taylor’s time as FDA Food Czar that GMO products did not need to be labeled as such, even though national consumer groups loudly professed the public’s right to know what is genetically modified in the food system. Sadly to remember: President Obama promised in campaign speeches that he would “let folks know what foods are genetically modified.” These are the conflict of interests that lead to the 99% movement standing up for the family farmers.
Just look at the confusing headlines lately that revealed that mid-western farms of GM corn will be sprayed with 2,4-D toxins found in the deadly Agent Orange. Just refer to the previous lawsuits taken all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court by U.S. Veterans who tried to argue the dangers of Monsanto’s Agent Orange, and high rates of cancers in our soldiers who had to suffer the side effects from their wartime exposures in Vietnam.
In 1980 alone, when all this mess started with corporations wiping out the livelihoods of family farmers, the National Farm Medicine Center reported that 900 male farmers in the Upper Midwest committed suicide. That was nearly double the national average for white men. Even sadder is the fact that some of the farmers’ children also committed suicide. Studies show that when one generation of family farmers lose their farms, then the next generation usually can’t revive the family business and traditions later.
Jim Gerritsen, President of the Organic Seed Growers and Trade Association, has pointed out that there are 5th and 6th generation family farmers being pushed off their farms today, and because of a “climate of fear” (from possible lawsuits from Monsanto), they can’t grow some of the food they want to grow.
These farmers are the ones who have been able to survive the changes over the past twenty years by choosing to go into the budding niche of organic farming. Now look at what they have to deal with while trying to grow successful businesses: Monsanto’s threats.
Even organic dairy farmers have had to suffer lawsuits ( from Monsanto) when they labeled their organic milk “non-BGH” referring to Monsanto’s bovine growth hormone used by conventional dairies.
Consumers want organic food, and they want America’s pure food source to stay protected in America. Made in America, organically, is the way of the future, and family farmers and seed businesses should be free to maintain their high standards for organic foods. They deserve protection from Big Agribusiness’ dangerous seeds trespassing on their croplands, not to mention the use of pesticides and herbicides on GM crops. The organic industry has an “organic seal” which is also important to the success of family businesses, and even that stamp of quality is threatened by the spread of Monsanto’s GM seed contaminating their pure seed banks.
The Banking industry is also partly to blame. Years before the mortgages and home fiasco we have now, the farmers were the first to feel the squeeze. I interviewed Willie Nelson in the 1980’s, and he mentioned even then the high rates of farmer suicides, and that Farm Aid was receiving letters from family farmers saying the banks had “called in their loans”, even though “we had never missed a payment”. Was this just a veiled land grab for fertile lands, or to intentionally bankrupt independent family farmers?
It was so inspiring years ago when Michelle Obama planted an organic garden at the White House. It was a great precedent for the future, but what happened? It was ruined when they discovered sewer sludge from previous Administrations had contaminated their beautiful soil where the organic vegetables were planted. Just one small upset but it was remedied for future plantings. What about our whole country’s organic food supply being contaminated by previous Adminstrations’ bad choices? Why did they ever allow Monsanto to introduce genetically engineered seeds into our pure, organic, and heirloom stockpiles across America in the first place?
Recently, the Obama Administration, in an effort to boost food exports, signed joint agreements with agricultural biotechnology industry giants, including Monsanto, to remove the last barriers for the spread of more genetically modified crops.
But in this recent lawsuit filed by the Organic Seed Growers & Trade Association, it was argued that a previous contamination of a “genetically engineered variety of rice”, named Liberty Link 601, in 2006, before it was approved for human consumption, “extensively contaminated the commercial rice supply, resulting in multiple countries banning the import of U.S. rice.” The worldwide economic loss was “upward to $1.285 billion dollars” due to the presence of GMOs…
What are everyday Americans going to do to turn it around, to get rid of Monsanto’s genetically modified seeds and its dangerous threat to America’s heirloom and organic seed caches?
There is high rate of cancer in America, and eating healthier, especially organic foods, has been shown to have great benefits in beating cancer and other diseases. When we have Agribusiness threatening independent family farmers, which leads to the farmers feeling so scared that they don’t even plant their organic crops that Americans need, then perhaps we can all see what the 99% Occupy Movement is trying to say about their conflict of interest and seemingly abuse of powers.
Willie Nelson just released a new poem on You Tube: “We stand with Humanity, against the Insanity, We’re the ones we’ve been waiting for… We’re the Seeds and we’re the Core, We’re the ones we’ve been waiting for; We’re the ones with the 99%.”
Monsanto’s practices are a clear example of the wrong direction that the 99% want our country to go in. How about shining some light on Monsanto, and before it is too late, realize the dangers of genetically modified seeds which are contaminating the world’s food supply.
“Crazy, crazy for feeling so…… 99% .
CONNECT













169 comments on "300,000 Organic Farmers Sue Monsanto in Federal Court: Decision on March 31st to Go to Trial"
February 12, 2012 7:40pm
This is entirely false. People have been farming organically for 5,000 years. Food can be grown almost anywhere, on small plots, in containers, on rooftops, in greenhouses. If sustainable farming cannot support the population, then it is the population that must adapt.
February 12, 2012 7:35pm
Yes there has been testing done all over the world and all the results are the same, all the rats and other animals tested have died. There is also testing being done as we speak ,that for the most part are showing links to consumption and deadly diseases.. Just goggle it and also in most of the medical journals world wide..
February 12, 2012 7:09pm
If we irradiate food, we could eliminate many costs in its processing, making it, ostensibly, cheaper and more available to the hungry masses. Thus, it could be feces laden but safe to eat, vis a vis harmful organisms
Is this what we want/need for our species? Some, as in this dialogue, advocate in this direction.
Oh, I might mention, there IS a difference between farmers and agribusiness. And, too bad we can't use the food we use to make ethanol and feed the hungry.
February 12, 2012 7:09pm
GMO crops are not necessary to feed those 2 billions. Chemical fertilizers ~maybe~, pesticides ~maybe~, but not GMO's. The GMO's are relatively new in the feeding of billions, and mainly exist so that Monsanto can sell more RoundUp.I'm quite sure that in the absence of Monsanto and GMO's, those millions of family farmers and subsistence farmers around the world whose lives have been destroyed by Monsanto's political and environmental toxicity would be happy to feed those 2 billion people you seem to be so concerned about.There are a lot of wrongs in the world, and Monsanto being allowed to put patents on life forms is one of them. Another wrong is using massive political influence to destroy independent subsistence farming around the world, replacing it with toxic GMO/roundup farming and then claiming that to be indispensable to the nourishment of the human race.If your child's DNA was found to contain a gene that had been invented (discovered) by Monsanto, would you be ok paying a fine for the copyright infringement? Don't doubt for a second that as soon as they find a way, they'll try it. They do it with corn every day.
February 13, 2012 4:43am
Actually organic crops, the heirloom seeds passed down through generations, are much more sustainable and yield more for their effort than any GM crops has. In fact the GM crops fail especially in harsh conditions while the organic crops will thrive, thus feeding more people using a smaller area and without the contamination caused by the GM crops and the pesticides that they require.
February 12, 2012 7:04pm
March 31st....what perfect timing. That is the day of Cesar Chavez' birthday, a champion for the rights and health of agriculture workers. He advocated voice and nonviolence in his pursuit of fair treatment of workers. Let us all stand up, for the value of each person, their health, and what is right. Si, se puede!
February 12, 2012 6:33pm
Organic farming is great and all, but without genetically modified crops, 2 billion people would starve to death. There are a lot of wrongs in the world, but organic farming is a luxury among all the other things.
February 13, 2012 8:54pm
You are right. If we reverted to organic, many people would go hungry, because we have been painted into this corner by the food industry. Smaller farms have become non-existent, and there is no means by which to farm more efficiently. However, the food industry is complex, as how we export meats, grains and soy, import other grains and fish-the world cannot exist on organic food. BUT Monsanto et al have NO right to be de-regulated, as those who DO choose to farm organically should have crops protected from cross-contamination, and NO company should be forced to sell GMO (see Monsanto vs Whole Foods, Stonyfield). And Monsanto's making a KILLING selling GMO to the poor, the unwitting and the ignorant. It's not like they are gonna go broke following the rules- they should be held to standards.
February 13, 2012 4:14pm
No, organic farming is actually sustainable farming. GMOs require farmers to buy seed every year, destroying the thousands-year-old practice of saving seed from one year's crop to plant the next year. Please read http://www.rodaleinstitute.org/fst30years/yields to see that we've been swallowing the press releases from Monsanto et al. without examining the data.
Most (not all, but most) cases of starvation in the world are due to politics, not a people's inability to feed itself.
February 13, 2012 4:59am
Your premise is unfounded. The crops that people grew in the countries throughout the world for generations yielded much more than the GM crops have, and without the use of toxic, groundwater contaminating pesticides. People have problems with growing their foods due to wars in their local, due to the WTO where they have lost the ability to grow their crops and cheap imports have taken away their ability to make a living from being a farmer. Where there is a famine due to cimate change and lack of water, the oganic seeds of their forefathers still yield more than what the GM crops have, in fact the GM crops have failed. These GM crops also add to the problem of climate change due to their contamination of the soil through the use of pesticides. No where has GM crops fed 2 billion people, boy have you partook of the monsanto koolaid propaganda.
February 12, 2012 11:48pm
Cliff, there is little place for fact or truth in this forum. This audience is about as enlightened as born again evangelists.
Errrr Trevor that comment can certainly be classified as hypocritical. Don't point your finger because you have three pointing right back at you.
February 12, 2012 6:29pm
Has there been any testing to show that GM products are safe? That they should be in the food supply at all?
February 12, 2012 6:16pm
Wanna take bets as to who pays more taxes? 300,000 organic farmers probably put more into the tax coffers than Monsanto but Monsanto puts more money into the corrupted government officials. My piece of land has several years before I can call it organic due to previous owners using roundup on soybeans. There are no earthworms on my land, few if any beneficial organisms left. This part of the 99% supports anyone against Monsanto.
February 12, 2012 6:08pm
The terminator gene was discontinued some years ago. Sorry.
Even though something was discontinued doesn't mean that in the right conditions it can't grow and spread on its own.
February 13, 2012 4:16pm
It's nothing to do with a terminator gene. It's everything to do with Monsanto's contract with the farmer that he/she will not save seed harvested from one year's crop to plant the next year. Monsanto insists the farmer buy seed every year: this is counter to long time farming practice.
February 13, 2012 5:02am
You are wrong. Just ask an Indian farmer...you know in India. There are several less due to suicide because of the crop falure, the cost of the pesticide and the yearly cost of the seeds.
February 12, 2012 5:54pm
Let's not forget that in addition to suing organic farmers for not buying Monsanto's toxic contaminated seed, they've also made it illegal to clean seed. For centuries, farmers around the world collect seed from the previous crop, clean it and replant so they're not buying seed each year. This is a matter of survival in third world countries both to the farmers and the majority peasant population. Monsanto has forced them buy it's seed which comes equipped with a "terminator gene". No matter how prolific a crop may be, this suicide gene will never produce another crop. This is the most insidious conscious decision to starve millions of people to death. There is NO valid food shortage. It's by design, compliments of this company. I would live under a bridge before working for this company. They should all be in effing jail.
February 12, 2012 6:11pm
The terminator gene was discontinued many years ago and never put into production. Sorry.
February 13, 2012 5:03am
Who said this besides trevor?
February 12, 2012 5:20pm
The headless beast, Monsanto and all of it's agribusiness and related officers need be tried for genocide, market manipulation, criminal disregard for the environment, the economic destruction of farming and agricultural resources, just to start. Put them all on an island with only the seed and farming resources they supply to unwary farmers and starving countries in disaster. Let them see first hand the unsustainable nature of their actions. If they die from starvation, related complications of chemical and biological issues with their own products, their deaths will be by their own hand. Let their own hand be the executioner for such a blatant disregard for life, plant and animal, insect and human.
February 12, 2012 7:46pm
That also goes for BP with their oil spills and GE with their nuclear plants in Fukushima.
February 12, 2012 4:42pm
In a ethical society Monsanto's criminal behavior would be punished by the government of said society. Alas in the corrupted US system, government now works for criminal corporations like Monsanto. Watch the decision on this case favor the corrupt corporate interests of the criminal Monsanto corporation.
February 12, 2012 4:29pm
Why isn't monsanto suing Mexico, Latin America and other countries where their seeds are innocently going into fields?Because they can't that's why, in the USA frivolous lawsuits are the meal of the day.STOP Monsanto and their stupid ways.
February 14, 2012 9:43am
The 1% looks after the 1%
February 12, 2012 3:59pm
Mr Smythe,You need to go back and do more research. Not only is there a significant difference in nutritional quality, the addition of all the anti-everything that gm food is laced with, creates these new superbugs that are all the rage in hospitals now. These gm foods contaminate the human immune system making these new viral and bacterial strains all the more deadly and unstoppable. I hope you choke on a piece of gm corn you moron.
February 12, 2012 11:44pm
I am amazed at the level of bile and ignorance in most of these replies, especially this one by Spencer Bell. The superbugs you refer to are multiple antibiotic resistant strains that have evolved due to overuse of antibiotics in humans and farm animals. GM foods typically have a single gene introduced to render the plant herbicide-resistant, or pest resistant. No antibiotics are used on plants.
And, by the way, viruses are not affected by antibiotics. Comments like the one about gm food contamination of the immune system is incomprehensibly stupid.
>that have evolved due to overuse of antibiotics in humans and farm animals
Maybe if the animals that you faceless corporations mass-produce weren't raised in deplorable and disgusting conditions they wouldn't need to be pumped full of things to kill bacteria, e coli etc etc.
Everything you say is highly disputable and seems as though it's rehearsed.
February 13, 2012 5:14am
They,the GM crops, reduce our ability to resist infections by their inflamtory response by those that eat these products. There have been a huge increase of digestive tract problems since the introducton of these crops, and many cattle that have eaten the contaminated crops have died much earlier due to infections and mainly abdominal problems. GM crops have a decrease of nutritional elements than that of organic crops. Our immune system is strengthened by all what we eat, and it is this system that protects us from pathogens.
February 12, 2012 3:58pm
Here is a petition addressing this very issue. Find information about the petition on this video. Save Our Food - Save Our World http://youtu.be/Ro5K20uunIM
It will be good to know where the factories are located that produce this bile. Maybe occupy the factory sites
February 12, 2012 8:38pm
That's a great idea!!
February 14, 2012 10:48am
Good background: documentary 'David vs Monsanto' - the tale of the wonderful farmer, Percy Schmeiser, who stood up against Monsanto. enjoy and share widely.PEACE from British Columbia, Canada
http://filmmovienew.com/2011/12/30/watch-percy-schmeiser-david-versus-mo...
February 12, 2012 3:32pm
Monsanto is like a psychopath who rapes women, then sues for custody of the resultant child.
February 12, 2012 2:54pm
A major disaster just beginning to happen. We've already stepped off the cliff, we just haven't hit the ground yet.
February 12, 2012 2:54pm
Mr. Smythe, your ignorance is stunning.
February 12, 2012 3:20pm
Stunning? Really? Please do go on. Be more specific about my ignorance.
I would would be interested in references a bit more specific than "a bout 5 years ago I came across an article that specifically cited a study...".
It is important to realize that everything you eat has been genetically modified. The only unaltered food is the fingerling potato, which has been carried down by the Macah tribe in Washington state. The name 'heritage' applied to crops such as tomatoes is a misnomer. They are the result of selective breeding like all crops.
Comments like that of Ms Moser, using terms like toxic fertilizer, barren soil, bio-tech nutrients are simply wrong. GM crops are planted in the same soil as other crops.
Salvia's claim that GM foods lead to sterility, suppressed immune systems, birth defects, etc., are likewise completely false. Where does this information come from? As of several years ago, over a trillion meals had been consumed by humans without a single adverse event. This is larger than any clinical trial in history.
If you want a reference, read 'Mendel in the Kitchen' by Nina Federoff, a geneticist and member of the National Academy of Sciences. It's not for sissies.
Yeah... "AS OF SEVERAL YEARS AGO" being the keys words there, some diseases and side effects take longer than "SEVERAL YEARS" before human beings notice the symptoms. How much was this supposed clinical trial funded by Monsanto?
February 13, 2012 5:24am
GM crops are not just hybrids of the same organism or species, they are combined with animal, fish, and pesticide protectant organisims plus other combinations. Some continue to combine within our bodies to make toxins, without knowing the long range effects this will have. The BT toxin has been found in pregnant women and it crosses the placental barrier affecting the growing child...these are toxins.
February 12, 2012 2:49pm
Actually, about 5 years ago I came across an article that specifically cited a study showing that organically-produced fruits & vegetables do, indeed, contain more nutrients than conventionally-grown crops. Add to that the lack of toxic fertilizers & chemicals being used on the land, organic sounds healthier to me! Bear in mind, also, that Monsanto's system is to create a barren soil in which to grow crops that are fed a limited array of bio-tech-chosen nutrients, rather that the array of micronutrients that are available to them in a rich, fertile soil. Just as we are what we eat, so the plants are what they "eat".
February 12, 2012 2:37pm
It's been shown that feeding GM crops to assorted species, including hamsters, sheep and cattle, leads to sterility and suppressed immune systems in the males and still births or birth defects in offspring of females. There's reason to believe that GM foods might cause the same problems in humans.
http://www.responsibletechnology.org/
I've read this more than one place.
February 13, 2012 7:42pm
SALVIA you are so right about what you are saying, there are numerous studies proving that GM crops are damaging the health of the consumer. Recently was released a new study that documents very impressive the negative impact on health these crops are having on animals: http://www.biolsci.org/v05p0706.htm#headingA11 . I do not want to be a guinea pig to MONSANTOS shareholders!
February 12, 2012 3:43pm
Salvia, IMO, all of this is covertly deliberate. If there is the "end result" that these crops create birth defects & still-births in humans, and suppressed immune, and sterility ----- and this is known ----- there is only one possible deductive conclusion: this equals "C.O.N.T.R.O.L."
February 12, 2012 2:33pm
GM crops, fed to different species, including hamsters, sheep and cattle, have been shown to lead to sterility in males and stillbirths and birth defects of offspring of females. http://www.responsibletechnology.org/
February 12, 2012 2:25pm
The only thing that seems to flourish in this county is evil...like monsanto and walmart..and of course the American government...run by lying, greedy, two faced low life clowns, that we can't seem to get rid of.Look at the repulsive choices propped up by the 1%, for the rest of us to choose as president, congressmen and senators...we can't even vote them out of office...there isn't anyone better to replace them!Look at how they continually, little by little take away and infringe on our rights and freedoms...for our own good!Look at how they have allowed greedy corporations to destroyed our economy, with their assistance, and continue to neglect to do anything about it!!Our protest and complaints fall on deft ears....our concerns are ignored...Americans seem powerless to overcome their evil and greed
February 13, 2012 2:09pm
I feel the same way. I can't believe Romney is as popular as he is. He seems to me to be the epitome of evil and greed, yet he keeps winning his little victories. He'd be the worst thing to happen to this country in living memory - and Bush was horrific. Obama wasn't much better. It disgusts me. Not only does he obviously not care about anyone other than the stinking rich, but do people realize that mormons believe that unless you know the secret mormon handshake to give to the angels at the pearly gates, you won't get in to heaven? That their religion is based on some lunatic's rantings that were supposedly given to him by the voice of an angel who spoke to him out of a magic hat? That the mormons have to have a year's worth of food stored in their houses, so that if there's an apocalypse then the mormons will be the only ones to survive and they'll take over the earth? Do people really want a president like that?? He'll do more for Monsanto and the like than Obama ever did, and Obama is bloody awful.
February 12, 2012 5:29pm
Examine the platform of the Green Party; no corporate sponsors. www.gp.org
February 12, 2012 3:48pm
You are accurate that our complaints fall on "deft ears." I believe that you meant deaf -- but "deft" -- as in "very clever"! -- fits very aptly! Since these complaints fall on deft ears -- it is also time to begin to develop yet another constitutional amendment about soil, water, seeds, GMO -- these will be the first people to scream about "unnatural" in one context but then shove it down our throats (literally) in another context. Deaf. And Deft. And Daft.
February 12, 2012 2:06pm
@ Trevor Smythe: Your so called research defies logic, plants derive their components from the soil they grow in. The healthier the soil, the stronger the plant. Even medication destined to improve health has side effects, any chemical not meant for human consomption alters human health. Don't you realize that people are tired of being fed and told garbage?