America’s Leaders are Small, but Americans are Not
"We the people of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America."
What a paragraph! Whatever happened to that BIG idea of America — the creation of a society that embraces and fosters such egalitarian values as justice, tranquility, common effort, the welfare of all and liberty?
We know, of course, that our nation has never attained the fullness of this ideal, but over the decades, generation after generation has at least strived to get closer to it — and made impressive progress. But today, some 224 years after the penning of the preamble, America's corporate-financial-political establishment is insisting that it's no longer possible or even desirable to pursue those democratic ideals that make our country important — and make it work.
What's happened is that, from Wall Street to Washington, we now have too many 5-watt bulbs sitting in 100-watt sockets. As a result of our leaders' dimness, America's uniting and constructive ethic of "We're all in this together" and "Together we can" is being supplanted by a shriveled, dispiriting ethic that exalts plutocratic selfishness and scorns the public interest as intrusive, wasteful, ideologically impure and morally ruinous. They're pushing us toward a forbidding Kochian jungle in which there is no "we" — money rules, everyone's on their own, and such matters as justice, general welfare, tranquility and posterity are none of society's damned business.
So here we are, the wealthiest nation on earth, with massive needs and an industrious population eager to get working on those needs, yet our leaders throw up their hands and say, "No can do." Heavily financed political forces are rumbling throughout the country to crush the union movement, eliminate wage protections, privatize everything from schools to Social Security, kill poverty programs, un-regulate Wall Street, repeal environmental rules, suppress voter turnout, stack the courts, corporatize elections and delegitimize the democratic values expressed in the preamble.
They are dynamiting the underpinnings of the middle class and taking away the public tools that ordinary people must have to do the extraordinary things that truly make America great.
Our "leaders" have given up on greatness because there's no greatness in them.
However, there is hope in the people themselves. We see it in the ongoing Wisconsin rebellion that is rejecting the Koch-fueled autocracy of the imperious Gov. Scott Walker; in the 61 percent grass-roots victory in Ohio on Nov. 8 to throw out the repressive anti-labor law that the right-wing Gov. John Kasich arrogantly tried to hang around the people's neck; in the Occupy protest that is so big and so deeply felt by so many angry/hopeful people that even police sweeps cannot make it go away; and in still more uprisings that are coming — coming from such corners as frustrated jobseekers; tens of thousands of misused war veterans returning from the Mideast to mistreatment at home; hundreds of thousands of homeowners being mercilessly foreclosed on by bailed-out bankers; and others who're simply fed up with the corporados and political flim-flammers who're knocking ordinary Americans down and holding America back.
What we Americans have the most of is the very thing our failed leaders have the least of: bigness of spirit. They say "no," but we say "yes" — on everything from repairing and extending our nation's crumbling infrastructure (a 2009 poll even found that 74 percent of Republicans are willing to swallow a tax hike to get going on this) to reclaiming our democracy by banning corporate money from our elections (84 percent of Americans support a constitutional amendment to do it).
While it can be disheartening to see the smallness of those in power, don't let it get you down. Better that we turn their failure into our inspiration for more agitation. After all, they're the ones who're wrong — wrong about the can-do power of the people they pretend to lead, wrong about the depth of this nation's historic commitment to egalitarianism and the common good, wrong about what they think they can get away with.
As we head into the New Year, our task is to confront their pusillanimity — demand from every candidate for every office to explain why their vision is so myopic and why their idea of what Americans can do is so small.
CONNECT















26 comments on "America’s Leaders are Small, but Americans are Not"
urjubjg
December 26, 2011 8:02pm
Let that Revolution begin within me.
Let it be not about me.
Let me be for you as I need you to be for me.
Let me not blame anyone for that victimizes me.
Let it be not about me, poor me.
Let this Revolution begin with me.
lvh 12/11
December 16, 2011 11:02am
This great article reminds me of this quote:
"THE MODERN CONSERVATIVE IS ENGAGED IN ONE OF MAN'S OLDEST EXERCISES IN MORAL PHILOSOPHY; THAT IS, THE SEARCH FOR A SUPERIOR MORAL JUSTIFICATION FOR SELFISHNESS." -- JOHN KENNETH GALBRAITH
My hope for the holidays is that each conservative is visited by the Ghost of Christmas Future so they can see that their selfishness may in fact destabilize the country that brings them such a high standard of living. We are all in fact in this together, the Tiny Tims and the Scrooges alike!
December 15, 2011 8:30pm
Half of all evil around us stems from the greed for Power, Property, Pleasure…the Pride to flaunt them, and the Proper sense to conceal the moral faults employed to acquire them; our leaders have come to epitomize this half. The other half is just there, par excellence, because of our Prudery: we let them lead us by the nose.
December 15, 2011 1:23am
I can't help but wonder if this is right? Namely the thesis that the Leaders are dim. And if it is, how that comes to be. Let's assume it is the case then I'm led to suspect that the reason this comes to be is not a lack of bright (vs dim) leaders in the pool to select from, but in the system that selects those who trickle to the top. And if I were to assume that it's not true, namely that we do have bright leaders, then could it be that they are hamstrung by a system that holds them up mas puppets for the uninspiring heckling and dim party machines?
There is something to consider here. I'm of the view that the key to fixing all of this in the long term is exactly the same in a sense as what created the US constituion to begin with, namely significant electoral reform. A significant revision to the way in which our political system works. To make it significantly more representative of the people's wishes.
There have been many significant eviolutions, albveit slowly in this field across the world. The notable ones that I have witnessed in action are proportional representation (as it is in place in Tasmania) and direct democracy (as it is in place in Switzerland). Both are worthy of study by those who might lead and inspire change and should be manadatory subjects fo study almost before anyone can run for a seat in governernmet.
If I imagione a world in which, in order to represent the people you needed to have a certain degree of learning like this, it looks better. The devil being in the detail. I observe for example this is already the case. You cannot and will not rise to success in politics without much learning along the way. Alas it is learning about how the present party mill works and what you need to do to make an impact.l It contains no required learning on alternate systems and how the party mill might be changed rather than worshipped. But if you were to restructure the learning needs, who sets the elarnnig agenda, polices its implemetation?
We have a spearation of powers that dates back to the Greeks, the executive, the legilature and the judiciary which serves to answer questions of implementation like that. It is far from flawless, but the means exists for us to legislate learning requirments to stand for governement (legislature) and to police it (judiciary) free of the executives bias and influence. That is the legislature and judiciary can keep the executive honest, which was their intent.
Alas, the voting population poorly understands the options and the poor turnout at the polls reflects that. Reflecting again that minimum learning is already a requirment at some level for sensible governanance. But worse still the existing system allows the executive too much power over legislature, and the idealistic party platform machine too much control influence in the legislature.
Still, I suspect the real problem is not dim leaders, or even if its, chiefly still the need for significant electoral reform, to tune the system to achieve the outcomes the founding fathers sought! They had a shot and did much better at it thasn most, but it isn't perfect and hasn't evolved in the right directions over the generations since and is in need of a tune up.
December 15, 2011 8:57am
Perhaps the reason for all of this "dimness," is that the (big ego), is the "tail wagging the dog."
December 14, 2011 5:17pm
What ever happened to "Ask not what your country can do for you, but what you can do for your country?"? Why diminish the only hope you have now - supporting the leader you elected to lead? He is not the Wizard of Oz - which to me epitomizes the deeper fantastical nature of the American Dream, and that is to idolize and look for magic to be bestowed upon the believers just for believing that dreams come true. When the personal dream doesn't manifest as dreamed, the idol is destroyed. How about a new belief system? How about looking deeper? Into the mirror? And The Dream?
December 14, 2011 8:13pm
PS to lois v harrison:
In other words: If you want change, it MUST begin with you!
December 14, 2011 5:01pm
"A revolution is coming--a revolution which will be peaceful if we are wise enough; compassionate if we care enough; successful if we are fortunate enough--but a revolution which is coming whether we will it or not. We can affect its character, we cannot alter its inevitability." John F. Kennedy
I would have to say, it is here and it is now!
December 26, 2011 8:05pm
Let that Revolution begin within me.
Let it be not about me.
Let me be for you as I need you to be for me.
Let me not blame anyone for that victimizes me.
Let it be not about me, poor me.
Let this Revolution begin with me.
(Can we put some music to this, please?)
lvh 12/11
December 15, 2011 4:53am
I agree! Thank you Shirley...The most powerful force in the Universe is Unconditional Peace "expressing AS" a revolution!
December 14, 2011 9:08pm
A revolution is necessary and it has already begun. I myself am a member of the Thrive Movement. We have Occupy, We have the Coffee party. It has been proven to get the best results is to do it with a peaceful revolution without arms. We are mobilizing ... join us.
December 14, 2011 3:19pm
THANK YOU “THE NATION.”
Seriously, we do appreciate your work.
However, nothing is really improving.
We the people…are dying out here!
We first lost our jobs, then our savings, and now are losing our homes.
We cannot feed our families and keep them healthy and safe.
We have been hurt enough. Dialog, debate, discussion, compromise, education, peaceful protesting, and even voting, has NOT worked.
Sorry The Nation, as insightful as you are, we tired of just “reading” about the problems and waiting for Obama to wake up, or get some balls (duh).
Wall Street, the 1%, the Tea Party, and corporate fat cats have become a gang of bullies.
Their unlimited cash buys votes, corrupts, and overpowers any positive initiative.
You can never appease bullies. They want more, and more, and finally…everything.
You have to hurt a bully back…badly, so he fears YOU!
C’mon Americans, OWS, the 99%, middle class, and forgotten people...it’s time to get mean dog fighting mad! Passivity is NOT working! Are we sheep? Are we going to let these bullies continue to hurt our families? Are we supposed to just lie down and die?
Hell no! (Not loud enough) HELL NO!
So, Fox News, Wall Street, fat cats, right wing nuts…we will take your advice to develop clear demands, strategies, and new battle tactics against your continuing class warfare.
Are we still obscure?
IT’S TIME THE BULLIES…WERE BULLIED BACK !
V
December 14, 2011 9:10pm
Go to the Thrive Movement. We need to act fast and get as many people working to change this country. It is proven that peaceful revolutions are more successful.. Please join
December 14, 2011 3:02pm
We had two years of opportunity to show the world what a real progressive government could do. We fumbled the ball. Between the Bluedog Dem's and the weak-kneed president we lost a golden opportunity.
December 14, 2011 8:10pm
Reply toPitch 1934:
Obama isn't Superman. Never was and never will be. The Republicans had 30 years to bring this country to its knees. To expect one POTUS and a bunch of shell-schocked democrats to turn it around in two years in the face of a well-constructed right wing political machine is foolish, mean, and unrealistic.
December 14, 2011 1:33pm
One of the most unrecognised causes of the selfishness, and even ruthlessness, that is effecting the leaders of the US politically and commercially, and of course the leaders of other so called democracies too, is the way that loyalty and concern for others comes early in life, when the "mirror neurones" are most active in babies and small children . As the baby watches those who care for them their mirror neurones sensitise the cells in the brain that will need to be activated for the baby or small child to copy what the adult carer is doing, so a baby even in its first day pokes its tongue out when the carer pokes their tongue out at the baby. This mechanism also is the basis of how small children learn languages and other behaviours easily in their early years, copying their mother's and father's behaviours as is the basis of Suzuki's successful method to train outstanding violinists, but has been shown to be important in the development of outstanding sportsmen in golf, cricket, tennis, and mathematicians and of course as is well known with languages. That mechanism continues to be active through early life, and underpins the so called "internalisation" of the behaviours of those around them. Mothers are especially important here, being loyally available and responsive to the child in caring and helpful ways, breast feeding too ideally, leads to "secure attachment" and the internalisation of loyalty and concern for others in the foundation of the child's personality, and as is important around the world today to resilience against drug abuse and other addictions. Father's being available to support mother in the child's early months and years is also important and individual care for the child from a few key carers is essential to the development of physically and emotionally healthy caring adolescents and moral adults, who are concerned for others. As a society we cannot expect to have leaders who are concerned for others if the children of the rich and powerful, who are most likely to be the leaders of the future, have mothers who are constantly distracted from the care of their child by many other demands and interests, with babies "baby sat" by television or too often "cared for" by a succession of carers in early life, who are not bonded to the baby in the way that natural healthy mothers are. That natural bonding gives great joy in the care of their baby to compensate for all the hard work, which paid child care workers may or may not have. Its past time for the misinformation about early child care from those who want to profit from caring for babies and small children and from commercial interests who want to have mothers working for them rather than caring for their babies is systematically challenged, and as a society we work to facilitate loyal maternal care for babies and small children so as to foster the growth of more future leaders who are properly concerned for others.
December 14, 2011 9:14pm
Check out the Thrive Movement. We have a plan going into action to promote a more loving, caring, thriving world.
December 14, 2011 12:39pm
To paraphrase someone much smarter than I...In the face of plutocratic barbarism, everyone know what freedom means.
December 14, 2011 12:20pm
Welcome back Jim. I had written you off with all your talk of blaming the republicans and not admitting the truth that the democrats are just as bad. You are much closer to the truth here.
December 14, 2011 7:07pm
Janice, it would be nice to just be able to agree with you but I fear the Republicans are much, much dimmer than the Democrats. I'd give the Dems a 45W bulb, but the Repubs get Jim's 5W bulb. It becomes blatantly obvious when you look at the Republican Slate (and not just for President). At best they are clowns and at worst, idiots. Look at the various tax reforms (9-9-9, flat, and Gingrich's "Flood the rich with cash") it's an abomination. And flat out counterproductive. These candidates just make no sense. It's as if they have lost touch with reality and as if we are living in Alice-in-Wonderland's rabbit hole where everything is upside and backwards. Soon we may have to call the police and have them committed, for pities sake. Democrats make too many foolish errors but at least they haven't gone over the edge .... yet.
December 14, 2011 1:55pm
The system must be examined from every altitude, and with a juror's prudence, if not a scientist's, but openminded. Period, the highest have become the lowest, even the best of the worst. The exclusionary rule is a revolving door concept that may be suspect for more than just the few we know of. The system at large needs to become part of overall Structure (described, mathematically, by Bertrand Russel as SIMILAR, thus, structure implies the need for dissent applied to a recognition of that which is dissimilar to principle, limits in an applied domain exceeded vis a vis tricks) instead of just 'being kind' to selfish advantages of redistribution, where distribution is the discipline even the collective masses must consider, this distributive function is necessary with an eye toward openness in learning. Otherness is far more than charity, and the supposed charitable will rob you blind of an education, 69ing the music, if they have not already.
December 14, 2011 12:04pm
So is Europe, but that means someone has to lead. So lets lead the rest of the World back to the principals and values that made this the greatest country ever. All that is necessary is to learn about the issues from anywhere but that TV and then go out and vote on the appropriate day. Don't let them take that away from you. Vote out the small minded group and vote in those who are more interested in the country as a whole and people in the village, they are there. People like Eliz. Warren and Alan Grayson and Sen. Bernie Saunders. They are there, we just need to find them and put them in a position to do We the People some good.
Michael Douglas starred in two movies and had a memorable line in each one.
For lack of a better term, Greed is Good. "Wall Street" remember that one
America is Democracy 601. You gotta want it, you gotta work for it... The American President....
Well we are at the point where if we want it we have to work for it. Or else you will lose it and your freedom too. So turn off the TV and the radio and go to the Library and look up the information. Be wary of the stuff we get on the Computer, so much of it is little more than the chewed over TV/Radio/Newpaper bull which are little more than someones press release. We used to depend on the Press and Media to do the research for us, no more. We have to do it ourselves, or we will be nothing more than low information, misinformed voters, confused and frustrated over a process we do not understand or know how to fix. Sound familiar. Want it work for it. NOW.
December 14, 2011 11:36am
NEW DIALOG FROM REPUBLICANS AND THE 1% .
Did you ever wonder what Republican / Wall Street big shots say in their ivory towers? (Been there)
Here you go.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
“ I ran the numbers J.B., and it’s cheaper to pay out for a few dead people than build safety controls into our food processing equipment.”
“Uh, Mr. Cantor, did you say…Michael Moore is a hit, or…put out a hit on Michael Moore?” …Ohhhh…right…we’re Republicans.
“We use Walgreen’s for our women’s healthcare. They have drive-up breast exams now.”
“So J.B., is bringing back slavery still off the table, or…..?”
“The Koch brothers new how-to book, “Fun with World Domination” is a must read.”
“Cantor, Ryan, Walker, Bachman, are all actually Cybernetic Robots. Wow, you really gotta hand it to those Koch brothers!”
“These grapes from Argenovia are dirt cheap. Of course I don’t eat ‘em, are you crazy? They use their own urine as a pesticide.”
“A classroom size of 85 gives kids the “tools” to understand a kill-or-be-killed work environment.” said Governor Walker.
“What oil spill? People will love these self-igniting shrimp.”
“Get your fresh dolphin filets here!”
“Let’s cut more Firemen. People have garden hoses don’t they?”
“Let’s cut more Policemen. People can run can’t they? Hey, remember that Seinfeld episode where that fat guy got mugged? Now that…was funny!”
“So J.B., you never answered me about that slavery thing…”
“Global warming, pollution, deteriorated o-zone, blah, blah, blah. What can happen?”
“Get your fresh polar bear burgers here!”
“Nice job killing off Planned Parenthood. Sweet! Now we’ll have enough new product coming in to launch our “Buy a Baby at Wal-Mart” program.”
“We made billions each time we moved our off-shore manufacturing from America to Japan, to China, to India, and now…to Africa. Ha, ha, ha! Sure, it’s great sticking it to the Germans, British, and Italians…but we really love screwing the French!”
“Air safety, nuclear safety, food safety…blah, blah, blah. What can happen?”
“Hey boss, that’s a great idea, putting nicotine in baby pacifiers. “Start ‘em young” we always say right? Haw, hawww!”
“FEMA was too costly, but now we’ll give you earthquake victims the “tools” to be self-sufficient. Here’s a shovel. Oh, and we’ll want that back later.”
“Get your fresh snow leopard fritters here!
President (!?) Walker said today, “As a cost cutting measure, every state will only be allowed ONE air traffic control tower…but it should be really, really tall.”
“Hmm…you know J.B., I’m really warming up to this slavery thing….”
“We’re cloning chickens for KFC, making mystery meat for McDonald’s…hey, so why not Soylent Green in school lunches?
“Hey kids, get your fresh Soylent Green meat-balls here! Mmmmm…yummy…”
By V
December 14, 2011 9:17pm
Maybe, you would like to go to the Thrive Movement with me.
December 14, 2011 11:24am
Right on, right on, unfortunatly the U. S. is not the only country saddled with small hearted leaders. Canada is just as bad. Or ignorant right wing here are slavishly following the horrible example set in the U.S.