Article image
Froma Harrop
NationofChange / Op-Ed
Published: Saturday 26 May 2012
“Weird how we pay tribute to heroes who make the ultimate sacrifice on the battlefield but absolutely worship those who make fortunes wresting every last penny from other members of their company.”

Bain and Our Screwed-Up Culture

Article image

We recently saluted Leslie Sabo for giving his life to save fellow soldiers in Vietnam 40 years ago. Injured after shielding a comrade with his body, the Pennsylvanian grabbed his grenade and stormed the foe's bunker. He died in the explosion. For his selflessness, America awarded Sabo the Congressional Medal of Honor.

Weird how we pay tribute to heroes who make the ultimate sacrifice on the battlefield but absolutely worship those who make fortunes wresting every last penny from other members of their company. As many see it: If you're rich, you're automatically a great American. Criticize how someone got rich, and you're a "socialist."

President Obama has been pummeling Mitt Romney over the marauding activities of his former investment company, Bain Capital. Some liberals do go overboard defacing all private equity investing with the same paint sprayer. And Obama's ads portraying Bain's victims employ too many violins for my taste. The problem is not the profession. It's what one does in the course of business.

But even among those intent on making it big, people with a conscience will not cross certain lines. Bain blew across them. There seemed little it wouldn't do for a buck. That makes the prospect of a President Romney overseeing the laws that keep destructive "investing" practices legal and incredibly lucrative worrisome.

I don't see how buying a company, piling on $420 million of extra debt, immediately pulling tens of millions out of the business to pay off investors — all the while slashing the workers' pay — and then leaving the wounded patient to die in liquidation nine years later can be deemed honorable. This is what Bain did to American Pad & Paper as it turned a $5 million investment into a $100 million take.

Bain also stiffed Ampad's unsecured creditors, including a pension fund for some of its workers.

These lenders got back two-tenths of a penny for every dollar Bain owed them.

Bain used a similar strategy at GS Technologies, a steel maker. There it parlayed an $8 million investment into $16 million. When the company went bankrupt, the federal Pension Benefits Guarantee Corp. had to spend $44 million bailing out its underfunded pension plan. And workers saw their pensions slashed by up to $400 a month.

Let's talk about capitalism. Granted, self-interest fuels the "animal spirits" that create our great business enterprises. Because the benefits of capitalism flow down to society at large, we are often at pains to divide ethical behavior from the other kind. Sometimes labor costs must be cut to stay competitive. Not every factory can be saved. And Bain apologists argue with some merit that the companies acquired were in trouble to begin with.

OK, but if a company is in trouble, do you multiply its debt by a factor of 22 and immediately take out millions for yourselves? That's what Bain did at Ampad, and, sorry, "looting" is the word.

And here's another question. What kind of people would walk away from a company with their money doubled but break a promise to workers for severance pay and health coverage if it went bankrupt? This was the case at GS Technologies. You answer that.

After World War II, American culture embraced a belief that labor and management should share in the fruits of capitalism. Those norms have been obliterated to the point that many don't remember they existed. Meanwhile, the worshippers of Mammon hail the corporate destroyers as heroes. A financial elite that prospers by turning workers upside down for the change in their pockets should not be overseeing economic and tax policies for the country. Mitt Romney seems awfully comfortable with the way things are.

Copyright Creators.com


Get Email Alerts from NationofChange
Author pic
ABOUT Froma Harrop
Froma Harrop’s nationally syndicated column appears in over 150 newspapers, including The Dallas Morning News, Houston Chronicle, Seattle Times, Denver Post and Newsday. The twice-a-week column is distributed by Creators Syndicate, in Los Angeles. Harrop has written for numerous other publications, ranging from The New York Times and Institutional Investor, to Harper’s Bazaar and Metropolitan Home. Previously, she covered business for Reuters Ltd., in New York, and was a financial editor for The New York Times News Service. A Loeb Award finalist for economic commentary, Harrop was also honored by the National Society of Newspaper Columnists. Over the years, the New England Associated Press News Executives Association has named her for five awards.

Top Stories

7 comments on "Bain and Our Screwed-Up Culture"

Theodore Ziolkowski

May 27, 2012 5:03pm

If you're rich, you're automatically a great American. Conservatives, Republicans and Tea-Party members will attack and disparage any who Criticize how someone got rich, and claim they're a "socialist."

It is true and workers know that because the benefits of capitalism flow down to society at large, we are often at pains to divide ethical behavior from the other kind. Sometimes labor costs must be cut to stay competitive. Not every factory can be saved.

The real issue in the United States of America and in the 2012 Election is What kind of people would walk away from a company with their money doubled but break a promise to workers for severance pay and health coverage if it went bankrupt?

After World War II, American culture embraced a belief that labor and management should share in the fruits of capitalism.

What is needed here is a small disscussion of Character. There is Individual Character and there is Corporation, Company, Institution and Organization Character. It is very clear that the two are no longer the same. Or are they??

Ten attributes of Character are:

1.0] Respect: They show consideration for the worth of self, others, living things, the environment, property and rules.

2.0] Responsibility: Responsible people are reliable, accept the consequences of their words and or actions or inaction, they can be trusted, they take care of themselves as well as others, they are responsible for all they say and do.

3.0] Perseverence: They stick with a task and do not give up even if it is hard.

4.0] Thankfullness: They are gratefull for the things they have, kindness shown, and the world around us.

5.0] Kindness/Courtesy: They are polite and helpful with their words and actions, and being thoughtful of how others think and feel.

6.0] Self-Control: They are aware of the thoughts, feelings, and desires of other, then they make a choice about how to behave.

7.0] Honesty: They are truthful and fair to theirselfs and others.

8.0] Cooperation: They are willing to be helpful and work together to achieve a comman goal.

9.0] Tolerance/Acceptance: They recognize and respect the opinions, practices, or behaviors of others, even if they are different from their own, and welcome new experiences and peple into their lives.

10.0] Friendship: In their lives they like to establish friendships with people who know, like, trust and support each other.

When I look at this list I can see the many short-fallings of Mitt Romney and then when I look at Bain Capital I can see the short-falls passing from Mitt to Bain Capital.

So I am forced to ask myself do I want Mitt Romney with his short comings to be President of the United States of Amerca, the only answer I can make as a Person of Character, is NO.

steve dewitt

May 27, 2012 10:10am

I wonder how many of the occupy people would go to work for bain capital if they were offered $200k/yr plus bonuses. I wouldn't want to be in front of that stampede. O'course if they had the education/qualification they'd already have a good job with a career track.

Brian Glennie

May 27, 2012 8:47am

'the sheriff of Nottingham" is now the hero, alas wither Robin hood and maid Marrian!

wonder6789

May 26, 2012 3:06pm

Excellent article.
Exactly how Obama/Biden should make the case against Rmoney.
Impossible to argue against those points.
We seem to be witnessing the end of Ayn Rand's stranglehold on American politics.

mike morell

May 26, 2012 2:12pm

Ask the ultra rich to carve their teeth with wooden instead of solid gold toothpicks and help the nation. Have Righties scream Socialism! Class warfare!

Jeffrey Hill

May 26, 2012 1:04pm

"In GREED We Trust"
(Damn cat hair in the keyboard)

Jeffrey Hill

May 26, 2012 1:03pm

"In GRED We Trust"