Report from Haiti: Where’s the Money?

Published: Saturday 8 October 2011

Broken and collapsed buildings remain in every neighborhood.  Men pull oxcarts by hand through the street. Women carry 5 gallon plastic jugs of water on their heads, dipped from manhole covers in the street.  Hundreds of thousands remain in grey sheet and tarp covered shelters in big public parks, in between houses and in any small pocket of land.  Most of the people are unemployed or selling mangoes or food on the side of every main street.  This was Port au Prince during my visit with a human rights delegation of School of Americas Watch – more than a year and a half after the earthquake that killed hundreds of thousands and made two million homeless.

What I did not see this week were bulldozers scooping up the mountains of concrete remaining from last January’s earthquake.  No cranes lifting metal beams up to create new buildings.  No public works projects.  No housing developments.  No public food or public water distribution centers.

Everywhere I went, the people of Haiti asked, “Where is the money the world promised Haitians?” 

The world has moved on.  Witness the rows of padlocked public port o lets stand on the sidewalk outside Camp St. Anne.  The displacement camp covers a public park hard by the still hollow skeleton of the still devastated St. Anne church.  The place is crowded with babies, small children, women, men, and the elderly.  It smells of charcoal smoke, dust and humans. Sixty hundred fifty families live there without electricity, running water or security. 

I talked with several young women inside the camp of shelters, most about eight feet by eight feet made from old gray tarps, branches, leftover wood, and pieces of rusty tin.  When it rains, they stand up inside their leaky shelters and wait for it to stop.  In a path in front of one home, crisscrossed with clotheslines full of tiny children’s clothes, a group of women from the grassroots women’s group KOFAVIV told us Oxfam used to help administer the camp but quit in May.  When Oxfam left, the company that had been emptying the port o lets stopped getting paid and abandoned the toilets.  Some people padlocked them and now charge a couple of cents to use the toilets, money most residents don’t have.  There is no work to earn the money for pay for toilets.  The Red Cross has just visited the camp that morning telling them they would be evicted October 17.  Where will they go, we ask?  We have no idea they told us.  Jesus will provide, they told us.

Where has the money raised for Haiti gone?  What about the Red Cross?  What about the US government?  What about the money raised in France, Canada and across the world? What about the pledges to the UN?  Where is the money?  The people of Haiti continue to be plagued by the earthquake of more than 20 months ago.  They are our sisters and brothers.  They deserve answers.  They deserve help.

Bill Quigley
ABOUT Bill Quigley
William Quigley is a law professor and director of the Gillis Long Poverty Law Center and the director of the Law Clinic at Loyola University in New Orleans.

He has been an advisor on the human and civil rights to Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch USA, and a Chairman of the Louisiana Advisory Committee to the US Commission on Civili Rights.

He was chosen as the recipient for the 2006 Camille Gravel Civil Pro Bono Award from the Federal Bar Association New Orleans Chapter, received the 2006 Stanford Law School National Public Service Award, and the 2006 National Lawyers Guild Ernie Goodman award. Bill also serves as the Associate Director of the Center for Constitutional Rights.
Follow Bill Quigley via RSS
Make your voice heard.
Write for NationofChange
I’ll tell you what really pisses me off: The absolute indifference of most Americans to who it is...
I was searching around the internet for the full video of the recent hearing on the Authorization...
I - Who Is Alan Hart? Alan Hart is an author and a journalist. He is the former Middle East Chief...
On May 8, 2013, Natalie Prescott, a well-known personal injury attorney based in California, was...
The relevant life policy can be regarded as one of the best things that has happened to the...
PART I - Richard Falk Tells the Truth Shortly after the 15 April 2013 Boston Marathon bombings...
[Note: This paper was presented to the World Future Society General Assembly in Washington D.C. in...
Boston Marathon, this thing called terrorism, and the United States What is it that makes young...
Alternative finance options like payday cash, same day cash advance, fast loans are becoming...
Last night, from Abu Dhabi, Secretary of Defense Chuck Hagel revealed certain intelligence...
I had an opportunity to interview WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange at the Ecuadorian Embassy in...
On the night of December 2-3, 1984, Union Carbide’s plant in Bhopal India exploded. Approximately...
This week is Earth Week, and while many are saying “Reduce, Reuse, Recycle,” we think key topics...
Part I - High Anxiety Americans may assume that public insecurity is a condition you find under...

2 comments on "Report from Haiti: Where’s the Money?"

R bb nc?onb3obana tyt bektop, a he maccnb. jia3ep bbwe toxe ha eto hamekhyn...Bce pabho tn? enemehta ?pnaetcr aenatb yka3atenem (?yctb n "ymhbm"). Tak uto, uto bektop, uto maccnb vecotr v(T); v[1] = new B();valarray x(T); x[1] = new B();A **a = new (A*)[T]; a[1] = new B();// ...FOR_EACH_VECTOR_ITEM( v, item, if (item) { delete item; item = 0; } );FOR_EACH_VALARRAY_ITEM( x, item, if (item) { delete item; item = 0; } );FOR_EACH_ARRAY_ITEM( a, item, if (item) { delete item; item = 0; } );delete[] a;

Sandra Streifel

October 16, 2011 12:43pm

Many people don't know how foreign aid money to "developing countries" works. Surplus corn and other agricultural products that must be destroyed under agricultural laws which control the price of corn, and so on, may be used for foreign aid instead, which causes a crash in the price of food in the country that is being "aided" and cripples the farmers' economy, which sends more people to cities to try to find work. Agricultural aid is often in the form of Dow and Monsanto herbicides, pesticides and genetically modified seed, which is suited only to industrial scale farming, and, among other problems, leads to accumulation of land in the hands of a few, with most people peasants or debt slaves.

Haiti's government is not the one the people would choose, but the one that the US would prefer. In Haiti, the aid was not used in accord with the people's groups that had formed to distribute food and work together, like KOFAVIV, it was used in accordance with the wishes of the Haitian government, or by the best judgement of the "experts" who had never been to Haiti. Even before the earthquake, slums had women's groups who organized to protect each other and their children. The earthquake was an excellent opportunity for existing government terrorism to combine with foreign aid that was not directed toward developing self-reliant and sustainable communities and employment opportunities for the people of Haiti. That is definitely not the priority of the Haitian powerful, nor of the US government.