It's the Empathy Crisis, Stupid

Published: Sunday 24 July 2011
The modern version of “Let them eat cake” in 2011 is “Let them breathe pollution.”

I'm sure everyone reading this already knows that our "debt crisis" is a mirage, a canard manipulated by the radical right wing who are theologically devoted to allowing society's rich to become even more so. Our supposed spending problem is nothing more than a "We won't tax the rich no matter what" problem. The media has played along; Pres. Obama and many of the Democrats are also playing along. And the political barometer has taken yet another sharp lurch to the right. But while we don't really have a debt crisis, we do have an empathy crisis and it's the empathy ceiling that has come crashing down on us and desperately needs to be raised.

Recall that in campaigning for the presidency in 2000, George W. Bush actually advertised himself as a different breed of conservative, a "compassionate conservative". I'm under no illusion that this was anything other than Karl Rove branding "W" solely for the purpose of electability. (I went to high school with Karl Rove. There's never been a stray, compassionate bone in the man's entire marshmellow, conniving body). But the fact that compassion was touted as a desirable trait in a politician in 2000 illustrates how far we have degenerated into a truly brutal society, a modern day Mordor. The only difference I can see is the Orcs in Lord of the Rings had better costumes than the Tea Partiers.

Our empathy deficit had its origins in the "tough guy" recipe concocted after 9/11 in the White House kitchen by Bush, Cheney and Rove and has since been served up with a vengeance by rest of the Republican Party and society in general. It has blossomed into a full blown malignant disease of epidemic proportions.

America hasn't given a second thought, or even a first thought to the hundreds of thousands of innocent Iraqis and Afghanis who were needless victims of George and Dick proving their manhood to the world. Abu Ghraib didn't even register as an issue with voters in 2004. In fact that election turned on Rove's swift boat strategy of convincing enough people that John Kerry's heroic war record, i.e. his masculinity, was fabricated. America no longer even pretends to be a country that doesn't torture. The nation that used to lead the prosecution of international war criminals allows its own torturers to justify their actions on national TV without the slightest hint of shame or reprisal. American exceptionalism--we get to torture people we don't like because we're special. And let's not suggest that God, Jesus, or the Bible doesn't approve, or that our beloved and divinely inspired Constitution prohibits this brutality.

The hideous sport of ultimate fighting has captured the mainstream and its own TV channel, becoming our version of Roman gladiators. Pornography has evolved from a display of sex and eroticism to one of disgusting, degrading violence against women who are depicted with less humanity than a corpse. Video games played for hours by teenage boys show women torn in half, drawn and quartered with blood spurting from the remaining body parts. Conservatives are now encouraged by their leaders to "lock and load" when they don't get their way, and no matter how much carnage, any curtailing of our precious guns remains sacrilege.

Sen. Orrin Hatch from my state, a devout Mormon and follower of Christ, couldn't vote for either of Pres. Obama's nominees for the Supreme Court because he couldn't abide justices delivering "empathy" from the country's highest bench. My other Senator, Tea Party general Mike Lee, a supposed Constitutional scholar, recently stated that the Constitution doesn't support child labor laws.  With a few more Mike Lees in the Senate we may be able to return to the good old days of Charles Dickens. The torches and pitch forks being amassed against illegal immigrants is nothing if not a war on empathy.

Climate disruption is already causing loss of livelihoods, disease, famine and death for millions throughout the world. Even much of the US is currently suffering from the very climate extremes predicated by virtually all the world's main stream scientists. Yet half of this country, and the entire Republican Party, swallow the denier Kool-Aid held to their lips by Rush Limbaugh and the blonde dumbos at Fox News even while they pass out from the heat. But it is easy to deny a climate crisis if one has also been purged of empathy.

The all out Republican/corporate assault on the “job killing” EPA, Clean Air and Clean Water Acts has nothing to do with jobs. At its core is a lack of empathy. The health and well being of your family will be sacrificed for corporate profit, hastening the return to a truly medieval gap between rich and poor. The modern version of “Let them eat cake” in 2011 is “Let them breathe pollution.”The real flag of the Tea Party is not "Don't tread on me", but rather "It is my God given right to tread on you." A chilling lack of compassion for the poor, the sick, the homeless, and the unemployed, now dominate the Republican Party's legislative agenda, and the Democrats and Pres. Obama, seem to be increasingly comfortable holding their coats while they throw them all under the bus.

The most nightmarish video I have ever seen was taken outside a townhall meeting two years ago where a disabled person in a wheel chair was trying to explain to a small crowd why health care reform might mean to him, the difference between life and death. The crowd circled around him menacingly, taunting him, humiliating him in a scene right out of Lord of the Flies. It was not an isolated incident. I was not only ashamed to be of the same species, I was ashamed to be in the same phylum as these Tea Party animals.

Charles Darwin had a theory about human nature that seldom gets any attention. He said we are a sympathetic species, we take care of others, and we are inherently cooperative. I can see why, after looking in the mirror, Tea Partiers don't believe in evolution. On this, I finally agree with them.

Dr. Brian Moench
ABOUT Dr. Brian Moench
Dr. Brian Moench serves as President of Utah Physicians for a Healthy Environment and is a member of the Union of Concerned Scientists. He can be reached at: drmoench@yahoo.com
Follow Dr. Brian Moench via RSS
Make your voice heard.
Write for NationofChange
I - Who Is Alan Hart? Alan Hart is an author and a journalist. He is the former Middle East Chief...
On May 8, 2013, Natalie Prescott, a well-known personal injury attorney based in California, was...
The relevant life policy can be regarded as one of the best things that has happened to the...
PART I - Richard Falk Tells the Truth Shortly after the 15 April 2013 Boston Marathon bombings...
[Note: This paper was presented to the World Future Society General Assembly in Washington D.C. in...
Boston Marathon, this thing called terrorism, and the United States What is it that makes young...
Alternative finance options like payday cash, same day cash advance, fast loans are becoming...
Last night, from Abu Dhabi, Secretary of Defense Chuck Hagel revealed certain intelligence...
I had an opportunity to interview WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange at the Ecuadorian Embassy in...
On the night of December 2-3, 1984, Union Carbide’s plant in Bhopal India exploded. Approximately...
This week is Earth Week, and while many are saying “Reduce, Reuse, Recycle,” we think key topics...
Part I - High Anxiety Americans may assume that public insecurity is a condition you find under...
Can this country do what it takes to reduce gun violence? Let's talk about the issues involved....
This morning I watched on television, the exceptional interfaith service at the Cathedral of the...

10 comments on "It's the Empathy Crisis, Stupid"

vPO7fs tsfaioepnpng

Stands back from the keyboard in aamzemnet! Thanks!

doctorsparkles

October 20, 2011 7:14am

Good title, though one can be empathetic and allow suffering. I can't help feel this author would consider God an unempathetic SOB for allowing free will to have its consequences.

What confuses me about this kind of "empathy" argument is its ignorance to the relationship between empathy, freedom and the use of force. You either "get it" or you're not ready yet, but think about it... What personifies empathy more? To allow another to do as he will or to force another to do as you will? Now, what if Mr. A has some advantage over Mr. B... Perhaps Mr. A was born wealthier or stronger, or perhaps Mr. A just worked harder or smarter... Whatever the case, is it empathetic to force Mr. A to surrender his advantage to Mr. B in the name of "equality"? Is it empathetic to forcibly deny Mr. A the fruit of his labor and blessings? Is it empathetic to reward Mr. B for his apparent shortcomings? Does empathy simpy amount to enforcement of "equality"? If you really think so, you have both my empathy AND my pity.

Empathy is a function of bearing witness. It is a healing power which "speaks for itself". It doesn't need government to enforce its superficial appearances in its name with threat of confiscation, violence and imprisonment. In fact, empathy frees its practitioners despite such threats and karma. And so, yes... an empathy crisis, indeed!

Ron Paul vs Big Brother 2012!

Nicolette Ladoulis

October 01, 2011 1:04pm

Well, here's another take from David Brooks...http://www.nytimes.com/2011/09/30/opinion/brooks-the-limits-of-empathy.html?hp&src=ISMR_AP_LI_LST_FB

Serious

September 27, 2011 10:47pm

In Texas, a rhetorical political question was asked” If an injured 30 yr old American had no insurance, what should the medical system do for him? The unequivocal resounding response from present Republican Tea Party members hollered “LET HIM DIE” !

Congressman Alan Grayson was personally interviewed on the Ed Schultz show found on MSNBC.

ED SCHULTZ: Welcome back to The Ed Show.

At last night`s Republican debate, the Tea Party debate, there was a defining moment for the Tea Party and just who they are. It was when Congressman Ron Paul was asked who should pay health care coverage for an uninsured 30-year-old after a serious accident?

(Video Clip, with the audience shouting “let him die.”)

ED SCHULTZ: “Yes!” was the response from several audience members about whether society should let the man die. Not a single candidate -- it should be pointed out -- not a single candidate on the stage stepped forward to say it would be morally wrong to let another American die, by withholding medical care. And no one in the audience voiced any disapproval. Keep in mind this audience had no problem booing opposing viewpoints throughout the entire debate. It makes me think of something said on the House floor, nearly two years ago, by a Democratic congressman from Florida.

(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)

GRAYSON: If you get sick in America, this is what the Republicans want you to do. If you get sick, America, the Republican health care plan is this: Die quickly. That`s right. The Republicans want you to die quickly if you get sick.

(END VIDEO CLIP)

ED SCHULTZ: Congressman Alan Grayson was criticized by Republicans for those comments, but since then, the GOP still has not proposed any alternative health care plan. They just want to rip apart what they call “Obamacare.” And since Republicans continue to pander to the Tea Party base, they don`t have to. They just need to “let them die.”

The former congressman from Florida, who is running for that congressional seat again, Alan Grayson, joins us tonight here on The Ed Show. Congressman, good to have you with us tonight. A couple of things -- first of all, what was your feeling when you were watching that debate last night? You saw the question. You saw the response. And you got the response from the crowd. What were you thinking?

GRAYSON: I thought their true colors were shining through. That`s what I thought. And you know, I`m often proven right, but usually not so vividly.

I have to say that this encapsulates exactly what people fear about the Tea Party, the so-called Tea Party, that they just love the taste of blood in their mouths. That`s what this seems to come down to. You know, they call themselves pro-life. But if you listened to them last night, it seemed like they were pro-death. I think it`s sad.

These are the facts. We have a country with 50 million people who can`t see a doctor when they`re sick. The Republicans, and the Tea Party people, seem to want to blame you if you have liver cancer, like it`s your fault. I think we can show a basic human decency toward other people without losing our own. I wonder about these way over conservative politicized people who seem to have lost their own.

You know, we`re 50th in the world now in life expectancy. Canadians live about two years longer. Japanese live about four years longer. And yet, we pay 30 percent more for capitalized health care than any other country in the entire world. Are you telling me we can`t do better than this?

ED SCHULTZ: Well, I was thinking last night that this may be the same line of thinking when the audience responded to the Texas execution question that was put to Governor Rick Perry last week. Is there a parallel between the reaction to that question and answer as the one we saw last night on health care?

GRAYSON: Yes. What the parallel is sadism. That what the parallel is: a total lack of empathy. You know, if you ever saw the movie "Blade Runner," the only way to tell the difference between the robots and human beings -- the only way, because technology was so advanced -- was that the robots had no empathy. It seems to me that`s a good description lately of what I hear from the Republican Tea Party. No empathy. They just don`t care.

ED SCHULTZ: Well, first of all, I`m surprised none of those candidates stepped up and took that answer last night because I thought it would have been an opportunity for them to distance themselves from the radicals. Does this mean that they`re all radical?

GRAYSON: Oh, absolutely. You know, they`re catering to the basest instinct in every one of us. And whatever you may say about President Obama, good or bad, he has never done that. Never once have I heard the President try to fear monger or push the panic button, which is such an easy thing to do when you`re an elected official. Never once have I heard him appeal to hatred or to fear. And these Republican Tea Party’s do that incessantly on the other side, nonstop. And they’ve got an audience for it, judging from what I heard.

ED SCHULTZ: 49,900,000 people in this country don`t have health insurance. And a doctor was on that stage last night pushing for “the free market.” I think we are a better country than that.

Congressman Alan Grayson, good to have you with us tonight. I appreciate your joining us.

GRAYSON: Thank you, Ed.

Basenjis

September 05, 2011 4:07pm

A lack of empathy or compassion is a mark of the sociopath and such indifference to the suffering of others sets him apart from normal human beings. Although the number of sociopaths compared to normal people is small, it is when they come together to collaborate or to hoodwink others that they are a great danger to society at large. In his research on political sociopathy, the Polish psychiatrist, Andrew Lobaczewski, found that when people without conscience or morality find each other, they can become powerful sources of evil that destabilize, dehumanize, and destroy entire nations.

Hitler's rise in power took place when Germany was searching for a national identity and desperate for stability and economic prosperity. There are enough parallels between conditions in the US in these troubled times and those in Germany in the 1930's that generate great concern among those who know their history that the US is ripe for a fascist takeover.

When a nation's leaders forfeits its conscience, it becomes a mindless engine of destruction. At the ripe old age of 88, I believe there are more than enough good people of conscience in this country who, under the right leadership, can save us, not from some fictional outside terror, but from our own worst selves. Our government no longer has the best and the brightest at the helm--but the best and the brightest are out there somewhere waiting to be called to action as in a true democracy. If all of the like-minded, caring, people of conscience could put aside their fears and their petty differences, we could throw out those unfit to serve due to character deficiencies and build a strong, new, true democracy.

The best and the brightest are with us somewhere out in this vast, beautiful country. The problem, as I see it, is that we are not yet equipped with the knowledge we need to understand how to deal with those who are destroying the country from within. As a start, if you are not familiar with Dr. Lobaczewski's work on political ponerology, I think it can still be found on the internet.

Sieglinde Proctor

September 05, 2011 12:11pm

Lack of empathy is being manifested by bullying in all it's forms. It is plentiful in the "comments" sections of articles, where name calling, threats and despicable statements completely lacking in respect or courtesy are displayed. This seems to be the new playing field. Newcomers, different opinions or real facts are immediately targets of being verbally stoned. And it is not reserved just for the "common" man. Nothing is off-bounds when referring to our president, our Congress or our gods. New bullying rules of the road are also evident, as SUV's, expensive trucks and faster cars are entitled to take your spot, with or without physical gestures, horn blowing or near-swipes. There seems to be an inability to tell the difference between real life and computer life. And while the computer itself is not necessarily to blame totally, it feeds susceptible minds with false and anonymous empowerment. It is hard to be empathetic when on a power grab.

pamann

August 29, 2011 4:50pm

a lack of empathy, a lack of morality in which the haves help the have nots, not because they have to, but out of real empathy. Somewhere the extreme right became viciously selfish like the Russian athiest, sociopath Ayn Rand was.
THe democrats for the most part don't seem to understand this nor how to repell the attacks. THe liberals have always been for their earth and fellow man and true Christian believers and people of any major religion live according to the principles of the golden rule.
I don't understand why the selfish and shameless have taken charge.

Nicolette Ladoulis

August 21, 2011 7:15pm

This is really excellent. Can you expand on it here and elsewhere? Explain why it's happened? We just need to hear it more. (My guess is concerted effort from some who are using evangelical protestants, to hijack Christians. It's a really sick game and I don't think in the end God will find it in the least funny...) Thanks!

Ray Seyfarth

August 14, 2011 1:38pm

A lack of empathy is indeed a large part of the problem. The people on top are the ones who use every means at their disposal to get to the top. This means that most of the business leaders lack empathy as part of the job description. It is up to government to install a sense of balance, but our government is now controlled by business interests. "Corporations are people" although they are psychopaths.