Turkey Does the Right Thing

Published: Saturday 3 September 2011

In the wake of the dubious UN investigatory report which all but exonerated Israel for its May 31, 2010 attack on the Mavi Marmara–an attack that killed 8 Turkish citizens and 1 Turkish-America–Turkey has downgraded its diplomatic relations with Israel and suspended all military cooperation. Ankara had little choice in this matter. The Israeli attack was egregious. It took place in international waters against an unarmed civilian vessel and was carried out in defense of a barbaric and illegal policy of collective punishment against one million Palestinians bottled up in Gaza by an Israeli blockade.

For their part, the Israelis claim that they murdered the Mavi Marmara Turks in self-defense. I juxtapose the words self defense and murder quite purposefully, for the Turkish passengers were in the process of defending themselves from a violent assault when they were gunned down by Israeli soldiers who now describe their actions as self-defense. This scenario is a tragic parody of a hundred years of Zionist action in the Middle East. Having come to the region in the baggage train of an imperial occupying power (Great Britain) and successfully establishing themselves by evicting the native population (a process that is on-going), the Israelis define all acts of resistence to their aggression as attacks which require their defending themselves. The Mavi Marmara action fits neatly into this Zionist world of peculiar logic. In this sense, they turn the world upside down.

The Turkish government will have none of this and demanded the minimum of decency from the Israelis–an apology and compensation. In so doing they stand for civilized behavior. The Israelis refuse to apologize. After all, when you have turned the world upside down in the fashion described above, any admission that there lies a bit of faulty reasoning in your outlook threatens to collapse your universe like a deck of cards. So what can Ankara do? It can and has distanced itself from these crazy people and refuses any military affiliations. Why militarily assist the murders of your own citizens?

In making the announcement Turkish Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoglu observed that the Israelis apparently see "themselves above international laws and human conscience." Actually, that is not the half of it. Not only do the Israelis disregard international law, be on the high seas, in the maintenance of the obscene ghetto of Gaza, or through their colonial impositions in the West Bank, but they assiduously seduce others to support their criminal behavior anywhere and everywhere they have lobby influence. Everywhere they go they are the poor victims who need carte blanche to protect themselves. They are the victims who victimize others in the name of self-defense. Israel is taking us all back to a barbaric state of nature.

You can see this perverse influence in the way the UN investigatory report on the Mavi Marmara assault was manipulated and distorted. Though headed by Geoffrey Palmer, a New Zealand lawyer and politician with a reputation for integrity and honesty, he was hemmed in by having to share the investigation with ex-Columbian president Alvaro Uribe–a devoted follower of the Israeli line and ally of Washington. The UN Secretary General Ban Ki-Moon, who is currently under attack by the United Nations Office of Internal Oversight for weakening the moral integrity of the organization, also bowed to a combination of American and Israeli pressure. As a result the panel restricted itself to "reviewing reports from Israel and Turkey, thus sidestepping any independent gathering of evidence or hearing of testimony from eyewitnesses." Ban Ki-Moon insisted that no report would be released unless Palmer and Uribe could reach consensus. That guaranteed equity for Israel’s perverse and lopsided logic. Thus the best the investigation could do is come up with a report that has an Alice in Wonderland quality to it: Israeli assault troops acted in self-defense against civilians even through they (the Israelis) used excessive force bordering on slaughter and mayhem. The investigatory process was suppose to be "transparent" to avoid this sort of corruption, but Ban Ki-Moon refused to let that happen.

Turkey, of course, has rejected the UN report. Now you might say all of this is in vain. Israel’s influence in the halls of power both in the U.S. and Europe is too great for Turkey’s position to be anything but symbolic. Well, you never know. The Turks do have some leverage. Israel dreams of the day when it can officially associate itself with NATO. Turkey is a member of NATO. Indeed, it has the second largest military force in that alliance and will soon host an extension of the organizations early warning system. Under present circumstances hell will freeze over before Israel becomes a full member of NATO. Unfortunately, within Zionist world of illogic, Turkey’s position will just reinforce Israel’s narcissistic sense of victimhood. Yasir Arafat once said that Israel acts like a homicidal "big baby." He was so right.

ABOUT Lawrence Davidson
Lawrence Davidson is professor of history at West Chester University in West Chester PA. His academic work is focused on the history of American foreign relations with the Middle East. He also teaches courses in the history of science and modern European intellectual history.
ldavidson@wcupa.edu
To The Point Analysis
Twitter Feed
Follow Lawrence Davidson via RSS
Make your voice heard.
Write for NationofChange
I - Who Is Alan Hart? Alan Hart is an author and a journalist. He is the former Middle East Chief...
On May 8, 2013, Natalie Prescott, a well-known personal injury attorney based in California, was...
The relevant life policy can be regarded as one of the best things that has happened to the...
PART I - Richard Falk Tells the Truth Shortly after the 15 April 2013 Boston Marathon bombings...
[Note: This paper was presented to the World Future Society General Assembly in Washington D.C. in...
Boston Marathon, this thing called terrorism, and the United States What is it that makes young...
Alternative finance options like payday cash, same day cash advance, fast loans are becoming...
Last night, from Abu Dhabi, Secretary of Defense Chuck Hagel revealed certain intelligence...
I had an opportunity to interview WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange at the Ecuadorian Embassy in...
On the night of December 2-3, 1984, Union Carbide’s plant in Bhopal India exploded. Approximately...
This week is Earth Week, and while many are saying “Reduce, Reuse, Recycle,” we think key topics...
Part I - High Anxiety Americans may assume that public insecurity is a condition you find under...
Can this country do what it takes to reduce gun violence? Let's talk about the issues involved....
This morning I watched on television, the exceptional interfaith service at the Cathedral of the...

12 comments on "Turkey Does the Right Thing"

tigmGz idhbiyqnypdj

MzGilG , [url=http://pqnjfnjcqevt.com/]pqnjfnjcqevt[/url], [link=http://fusjtprkhbdn.com/]fusjtprkhbdn[/link], http://anijwodsuexi.com/

MzGilG , [url=http://pqnjfnjcqevt.com/]pqnjfnjcqevt[/url], [link=http://fusjtprkhbdn.com/]fusjtprkhbdn[/link], http://anijwodsuexi.com/

3k1Hvq plrlbxmalpav

That's 2 ceelvr by half and 2x2 clever 4 me. Thanks!

dr blc

September 16, 2011 12:00pm

Silenced, you're quite incorrect.
Turkey has an enormously ridiculous and self-serving sense of morality. You might benefit by looking into their quite dirty and ongoing war with their Kurdish minority.

Turkey butchered (and threw into unmarked mass graves) a hell of a lot of innocent Turkish citizens of Kurdish origin in the late 1980s and 1990s and Erdogan is reviving that dirty war today.

dr blc

September 16, 2011 11:54am

Davidson continues to impress with his blatherous idiocy and ability to completely refuse to allow anything to get in the way of his preformed feelings about things.

Israel has good and sufficient reason to blockade Gaza (and conducts that blockade in a stupid and callous and occasionally violative manner) but the idea that Israel owes "compensation" to the families of the dead is horsespit and Erdogan knows it to be such and is making the demand knowing that it's never going to be met and knowing that he and his government would never do anything like that.

Erdogan's government is responsible for killing a lot more innocent Turkish citizens (second-class citizens, to be sure) than died in that maritime encounter.

Crusader Rabbit

September 15, 2011 2:25am

"The public avowals of Beginʻs party are no guide whatever to its actual character. Today the speak of freedom, democracy and anti-imperialism, whereas until recently they openly preached the doctrine of the Fascist state. It is in its actions that the terrorist party betrays its real character; from its past actions we can judge what it may be expected to do in the future ... This is the unmistakable stamp of a Fascist party for whom terrorism (against Jews, Arabs and British alike), and misrepresentation are means, and ʻa leader state' is the goal."
- Albert Einstein and 27 other Jewish intellectuals, in a letter to the NY Times, December 2, 1948.

Harold Rosenthal

September 13, 2011 4:27am

The author does not allow law or facts to distort his opinion. Calling the UN Investigative Report "dubious" is not much of a critique. After suffering 10,000 rockets and mortars being fired from Gaza, international law gave Isreal the right to stop every ship steaming to Gaza and search it for weapons. All of the other ships in the flotilla acceded to this right without incident, Only on one ship were the Israelis attacked which in self defense led to the death of nine of the attackers. This is clearly demonstrated by videotape which was part of the evidence in Israel's favor. Read the report and view the tape and reach your own conclusion.

silenced

September 07, 2011 11:46pm

I agree. Hats off to Turkey. They have a courage and sense of morality which is only a distant memory in the west.

Wimr

September 07, 2011 11:28am

How interesting and curious that it should be precisely Turkey that accuses Israel of being above international law. A lapse, perhaps, of historical perspective / memory or blissful ignorance... A case of the pot accusing the kettle...? Ahh, and let's please take the late Mr. Arafat's words seriously: after all he was a peaceful man walking in the footsteps of Gandhi. Logic in the ME can be twisted indeed.

greenspider

September 07, 2011 6:01am

When will the United states learn the lesson of the Turks and pull our own diplomats and cut off funding until Israel steps in line with the rest of the world...