Article image
Froma Harrop
NationofChange / Op-Ed
Published: Friday 6 April 2012
“The right-wing media had launched an outrageous smear campaign against the GM Volt.”

The Car the Right Wing Can’t Kill

Article image

Imagine that. Former Republican President George H.W. Bush recently bought his son Neil a Chevrolet Volt as a birthday present. This is the car that all right-thinking right-wingers demand we hate. In their political prism, the Volt has everything going against it: It's beloved by environmentalists for getting 61 miles to the gallon. It's assembled by unionized workers at General Motors' Detroit-Hamtramck plant. It enjoys government subsidies intended to encourage the production of fuel-efficient cars (started actually by H.W.'s oldest son, former President George W. Bush).

To many, this resembles progress. But to "conservatives" wanting government-bailed-out Detroit to go down in flames, especially if the United Auto Workers union goes with it, this plug-in hybrid is the car that has to die.

Lo and behold, U.S. car sales were hot last month, with General Motors selling over 100,000 vehicles that get at least 30 miles to a gallon. And sales of its Chevy Volt more than doubled from the month before.

The irony is that GM has temporarily stopped production of the Volt following earlier weak sales. And here's why the Volt wasn't flying out of the lots: The right-wing media had launched an outrageous smear campaign against it. As former GM executive Bob Lutz sarcastically put it, the Volt had become "the poster child for President Obama's socialist meddling in the free automotive market."

Lutz responded with special anger to a recent Bill O'Reilly Fox News show in which the host condemned the Volt as "an unmitigated disaster." Joshing over the disappointing Volt sales, O'Reilly's guest Lou Dobbs said, "It doesn't work." Also, "It catches fire."

None of this happens to be true. The European-market Volt worked well enough to be named the European Car of the Year. The "catching fire" claim is pure fiction, Lutz said, based on battery tests "under extremely destructive experimental conditions." Two of the three batteries involved weren't even in a car.

No Volt has ever caught fire in an accident on a public road, he added, while between 2003 and 2007, some 278,000 gasoline-powered cars did.

Sadly, Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney has lowered himself by catering to feverish right-wing fantasies. He softened the rhetoric a bit by advancing the myth that an already weak General Motors and Chrysler could have survived in bankruptcy reorganization without government help. Most economists deemed that scenario impossible at a time of economic meltdown, when nearly all lending had stopped. And who would buy a car from a bankrupt company not backed by the government?

Judging from past writings on energy policy, Romney probably subscribes to a Bush-like belief that government has a role in helping Americans reduce their oil consumption. But he did join the anti-Volt pile-on this week. Using past tense he commented, "I'm not sure America was ready for the Chevy Volt." Then he wished it well.

What weird brand of politics revels at the prospect of plowing under a U.S. product so innovative that the Chinese are demanding its engineering secrets? It's a politics that ignores the huge subsidies that other governments, including China's, are pouring into energy technology. It's a politics that seems to blindly hate organized labor — even after the autoworkers had accepted enormous cuts in their numbers and compensation to keep the car companies afloat. It's a politics that went goofy over Chrysler's Super Bowl ad in which Clint Eastwood announced, "It's halftime in America." Without evidence, some heard a thinly veiled call for a second Obama administration.

Exactly whose side are these people on? If these self-styled patriots want to keep waving the flag, fine. But it should be a white flag, not the American one.

Copyright Creators.com


Get Email Alerts from NationofChange
Author pic
ABOUT Froma Harrop
Froma Harrop’s nationally syndicated column appears in over 150 newspapers, including The Dallas Morning News, Houston Chronicle, Seattle Times, Denver Post and Newsday. The twice-a-week column is distributed by Creators Syndicate, in Los Angeles. Harrop has written for numerous other publications, ranging from The New York Times and Institutional Investor, to Harper’s Bazaar and Metropolitan Home. Previously, she covered business for Reuters Ltd., in New York, and was a financial editor for The New York Times News Service. A Loeb Award finalist for economic commentary, Harrop was also honored by the National Society of Newspaper Columnists. Over the years, the New England Associated Press News Executives Association has named her for five awards.

Top Stories

9 comments on "The Car the Right Wing Can’t Kill"

tolerone

September 18, 2012 7:23pm

Well I like the volt no need to hate.

Alien_Among_You

April 07, 2012 9:37am

Some cars were running on battery power at the turn of the 20th century so just imagine how far along battery technology could have come if we'd been allowed to continue using battery powered cars. Gasoline was considered the worst of all options by the public who were against the idea of cars belching smoke and having smelly gas stations on every corner and yet, here we are more than a century later with gasoline still the leading fuel source for automobiles.

Alien_Among_You

April 07, 2012 9:30am

Not to sound conspiracy theorist but check your history. Prohibition had absolutely nothing to do with the drinking of alcoholic beverages but had everything to do with the use of alcohol as a fuel source. Rockefeller was refining kerosene from which gasoline is a by-product but many Americans were using alcohol as a fuel source. He knew if he could get alcohol outlawed then he could make insane amounts of money selling his then waste product gasoline. How else could a group of women who, at the time, had no political power get a constitutional amendment passed? They were backed and financed by J.D., that's how.

Swimmer

April 07, 2012 6:59am

And we do not subsidize the oil industry?

VoltOwner

April 06, 2012 6:42pm

"This is the car that all right-thinking right-wingers demand we hate."
This is the car that all wrong-thinking right-wingers demand we hate?

Not sure where the 61 MPG comes from, the EPA rated it 38 combined, 40 highway on gas only, and 93 MPGe on electricity only. Most times I have been on the highway when it switches to gas, so I do get 40MPG average on gas.

My wife loves our Volt, the only problem we have with it is having to share it!
We do about 20-25 miles a day, so never go over the battery range, and have driven over 6000 miles since June. It has used less than 2 gallons in that time, plus about $150 in electricity. Plug it in at night, unplug it in the morning. It usually says it will be able to take us 40-45 miles each day, which on some weekends was not enough, thus the gas use. We did spring for the 240V charge station, which allows the car to be charged in less than 4 hours, so we have stopped using gas on weekends. Otherwise the included 120V cord will work for most owners.

I do expect to put a few gallons in come June, since the car is programmed to use some gas after a year, so that it won't get stale. I don't think there is another car out there that has the dash warn ou that you have not put an gas in since last year!

348flyguy

April 06, 2012 6:09pm

Ever since the last of the 1960's we have been the subject of manipulation from governments and oil company's buying influence of the Congress of the United States. Your vote does not matter, what you use what you consume does. The faster we collectively buy Volts, Leafs and other hybrids the faster we can tell big oil to go to hell and stop playing with our military, our politics and our lives.
www.thepracticalliberal.com

Two thumbs up!!

Mitt Rmoney and the right wing will lose. Full stop!

SaulT

April 06, 2012 2:27pm

'Politicians' are all only salespuppets, working to keep selling their sales-masters' main product, oil, for a stiff price... and electric cars sure won't do that for them!

It's not "America" that isn't ready for the Chevy Volt - it's the oil-barons who aren't ready to take the salary cuts it portends, so they directed their paid government puppets to try to kill it off.

;-)