Chris Pyle, Whistleblower on Domestic Spying in 70s, Says Be Wary of Attacks on NSA’s Critics

Amy Goodman
Democracy Now! / Video Report
Published: Monday 17 June 2013
During his testimony, Alexander denied claims he has personal wiretapping abilities at the agency and insisted phone data collection has helped prevent dozens of terrorist attacks.

As NSA director General Keith Alexander blasts the leaks that exposed widespread surveillance of Americans, we’re joined by Chris Pyle, a former military instructor who exposed the CIA and Army’s monitoring of millions of Americans in the 1970s. Pyle discovered the Army and CIA were spying on millions of Americans engaged in lawful political activity while he was in the Army working as an instructor. His revelations prompted Senate hearings, including Senator Frank Church’s Select Committee on Intelligence, ultimately leading to a series of laws aimed at curbing government abuses. Now teaching constitutional law and civil liberties at Mount Holyoke College, Pyle says the NSA is known for attacking its critics instead of addressing the problems they expose.

 TRANSCRIPT

This is a rush transcript. Copy may not be in its final form.

JUAN GONZÁLEZ: We want to go on to the National Security Agency director, General Keith Alexander, who testified before Congress Wednesday, a week after a trove of secret documents about his agency’s widespread surveillance program stunned the nation and sparked heated debate. During his testimony, Alexander denied claims he has personal wiretapping abilities at the agency and insisted phone data collection has helped prevent dozens of terrorist attacks. He refused to publicly answer questions about how the NSA had made the transition to collecting phone records of Americans. Alexander also said he hoped for greater transparency around the surveillance programs, but he argued some secrecy helps the agency’s mission. He was also asked about the impact of the NSA leaks. This was his response.

GEN. KEITH ALEXANDER: Great harm has already been done by opening this up. And the consequence, I believe, is our security is jeopardized. There is no doubt in my mind that we will lose capabilities as a result of this and that not only the United States, but those allies that we have helped, will no longer be as safe as they were two weeks ago. And so, I am really concerned about that. I’m also concerned that, as we go forward, we now know that some of this has been released. So what does it make sense to explain to the American people so they have confidence that their government is doing the right thing? Because I believe we are, and we have to show them that.

JUAN GONZÁLEZ: The disclosure of the secret NSA surveillance program was based on information leaked by Edward Snowden, a former CIA employee who most recently worked inside the NSA’s Hawaii office for the private firm Booz Allen Hamilton. In an exclusive interview with the South China Morning Post, Snowden said, quote, "I’m neither traitor nor hero, I’m an American." He also said he intends to stay in Hong Kong until he’s asked to leave, and he intends to fight any extradition attempts by the U.S. government. Snowden also told the paper, quote, "People who think I made a mistake in picking [Hong Kong] as a location misunderstand my intentions. I am not here to hide from justice; I am here to reveal criminality."

AMY GOODMAN: Well, for more, we’re joined by Christopher Pyle, who first exposed domestic spying in the 1970s here in the U.S. Pyle discovered the CIA was spying on millions of Americans engaged in lawful activity while he was in the Army and worked as an instructor. After he left, he wrote about the Army’s vast and growing spy operations. His article from 1971 began, quote, "For the past four years, the U.S. Army has been closely watching civilian political activity within the United States." Pyle’s story prompted Senate hearings, including Senator Frank Church’s Select Committee on Intelligence. These ultimately led to a series of laws aimed at curbing government abuse. Chris Pyle is the co-author of Military Surveillance of Civilian PoliticsGetting Away with Torture and The Constitution Under Siege. He now teaches constitutional law and civil liberties at Mount Holyoke College and recently wrote a piece headlined, "Edward Snowden and the Real Issues." He joins us from Chicopee, Massachusetts.

Welcome to Democracy Now!, Professor Pyle. Talk about what you feel those real issues are. But before you do, explain what happened to you, how it was you revealed in the early ’70s what was going on in the military.

CHRISTOPHER PYLE: I received a briefing at the U.S. Army Intelligence Command that showed me the extent of the surveillance system. There were about 1,500 Army agents in plain clothes watching every demonstration in the United States of 20 people or more. There was also a records system in a giant warehouse on about six million people. I disclosed the existence of that surveillance and then recruited 125 of the Army’s counterintelligence agents to tell what they knew about the spying to Congress, the courts and the press. As a result of those disclosures and the congressional hearings, the entire U.S. Army Intelligence Command was abolished. This was before Watergate.

JUAN GONZÁLEZ: And, Professor Pyle, did you, at that time, suffer any repercussions from your willingness to step forward and reveal what was going on to Congress?

CHRISTOPHER PYLE: Well, two things happened. The Army created a 50-man unit in the Pentagon whose sole job was to discredit my disclosures. That effort failed: The disclosures were all quite accurate. I was also put on President Nixon’s enemies list, which resulted in a tax audit.

AMY GOODMAN: Christopher Pyle, let’s turn for a minute to the Church Committee’s special Senate investigation of government misconduct, which you played a key role in the mid-'70s, U.S. Senate committee chaired by Democratic Senator Frank Church of Idaho, who conducted a massive investigation of the CIA and FBI's misuse of power at home and abroad, the multi-year investigation examining domestic spying, the CIA’s attempts to assassinate foreign leaders, the FBI and CIA’s efforts to infiltrate and disrupt leftist organizations, and a lot more. This is Senator Frank Church speaking during one of the committee’s hearings.

SEN. FRANK CHURCH: You have seen today the dark side of those activities, where many Americans who were not even suspected of crime were not only spied upon, but they were harassed, they were discredited and, at times, endangered.

AMY GOODMAN: And this is another clip from the Church Committee Senate hearing. This is CIADirector William Colby testifying. He was asked if he found the work of the committee unwelcome.

WILLIAM COLBY: No, I do not. I’ve—as I’ve said to the chairman, I welcome the chance to try to describe to the American people what intelligence is really about today. It’s a—it is an opportunity to show how we Americans have modernized the whole concept of intelligence.

AMY GOODMAN: That was then-CIA Director William Colby. So, if you would, Chris Pyle, take this forward, from what came out of the Church Committee hearings, that started with your exposé from being a military whistleblower, to what you’re seeing today with Edward Snowden.

CHRISTOPHER PYLE: Well, what we’ve seen in the ensuing years has been a vast explosion in intelligence-gathering capabilities. But the most significant part of that is the fact that civilian corporations are now doing the government’s work. Seventy percent of the intelligence budget of the United States today goes to private contractors like Booz Allen, which employed Edward Snowden. This is a major change in the power of surveillance. It now goes not only to the government, but to private corporations.

JUAN GONZÁLEZ: Well, you seem—in a recent article, you seem to raise what you think are the real issues in these Snowden leaks. You mention, one, the inability of Congress to actually do legitimate oversight over intelligence. You say that the secrecy system is out of control. And you also say that the system is also profoundly corrupt because of all this use of private contractors who make huge amounts of money that no one can actually hold them accountable for. Could you talk about those issues?

CHRISTOPHER PYLE: Yes. The forerunner of the PRISM system that Snowden disclosed was called Trailblazer. It wasted $1 billion on private contracts. It replaced a much less expensive system called ThinThread, which had more privacy protections and had been developed inside the government. Now, the reason that private contractors get this business is because members of Congress intercede with them with government agencies. And we now have a situation where members of the Intelligence Committee and other committees of Congress intercede with the bureaucracy to get sweetheart contracts for companies that waste taxpayers’ money and also violate the Constitution and the privacy of citizens. This is a very serious situation, because it means that it’s much more difficult to get effective oversight from Congress.

AMY GOODMAN: I wanted to go back to the Senate Appropriation Committee hearing with the NSAdirector, General Keith Alexander, defending the phone surveillance practices exposed by Edward Snowden.

GEN. KEITH ALEXANDER: I thought the great part about this program was that we brought Congress, the administration and the courts all together. We did that. That’s what our government stands for, under the same Constitution. We follow that Constitution. We swear an oath to it. So I am concerned, and I think we have to balance that. I will not—I would rather take a public beating and people think I’m hiding something than to jeopardize the security of this country.

AMY GOODMAN: Professor Pyle, could you respond?

CHRISTOPHER PYLE: Well, we all want to protect the security of the country. We all want to protect the Constitution. But when government agencies are totally unaccountable, we can’t do that. Members of Congress do not go to those briefings, even if they’re offered, because once you go to the briefing, then you can’t talk about what you’ve been told, because it’s classified. So the briefing system is designed to silence Congress, not to promote effective oversight.

Members of Congress don’t want to spend time on oversight. They’re too busy raising money. New members of the House of Representatives this winter were told by the Democratic Campaign Committee that they should spend between four and six hours a day dialing for dollars. They have no time to do the public’s business. They’re too busy begging for money. President Obama himself attended 220 fundraisers last year. Where does he get the time to be president when he’s spending so much time asking wealthy people for money to support his campaign?

JUAN GONZÁLEZ: Well, Chris Pyle, in Wednesday’s Senate hearing, Senator Dick Durbin askedNSA director, General Keith Alexander, why someone like Booz Allen employee Edward Snowden was in a position in which he had access to the classified information he leaked.

SEN. DICK DURBIN: He was a high school dropout. He was a community college dropout. He had a GED degree. He was injured in training for the U.S. Army and had to leave as a result of that. And he took a job as a security guard for the NSA in Maryland. Shortly thereafter, he took a job for the CIA in what is characterized as IT security inThe Guardian piece that was published. At age 23, he was stationed in an undercover manner overseas for the CIA and was given clearance and access to a wide—a wide array of classified documents. At age 25, he went to work for a private contractor and most recently worked for Booz Allen, another private contractor working for our government. I’m trying to look at this résumé and background—it says he ended up earning somewhere between $122,000 and $200,000 a year. I’m trying to look at the résumé background for this individual who had access to this highly classified information at such a young age, with a limited educational and work experience, part of it as a security guard, and ask you if you’re troubled that he was given that kind of opportunity to be so close to important information that was critical to the security of our nation?

GEN. KEITH ALEXANDER: I do have concerns about that, over the process, Senator. I have grave concerns over that, the access that he had, the process that we did. And those are things that I have to look into and fix from my end, and that across the intel community, Director Clapper said we’re going to look across that, as well. I think those absolutely need to be looked at. I would point out that in the IT arena, in the cyber-arena, some of these folks have tremendous skills to operate networks. That was his job, for the most part, from the 2009-'10, was as an IT, a system administrator within those networks. He had great skills in that areas. But the rest of it, you've hit on—you’ve hit on the head. We do have to go back and look at these processes, the oversight in those—we have those—where they went wrong, and how we fix those.

JUAN GONZÁLEZ: That was NSA director, General Keith Alexander, speaking before the Senate on Wednesday. Well, in 2012, General Alexander spoke at DEF CON, the annual hacker convention. During his speech, Alexander tried to court hackers to work at the National Security Agency. The third bullet on his PowerPoint presentation that he refers to is privacy and civil liberties must be protected.

GEN. KEITH ALEXANDER: I think the third bullet down is what we really want to do is innovate freedom, how we’re going to look at where we take this next. This is a great opportunity for not only our nation, but for the world. And, you know, one of the things that I’m really proud of saying is, when you look at Vint Cerf and the others, we’re the ones who helped develop, we’re the ones who built this Internet. And we ought to be the first ones to secure it. And I think you folks can help us do that.

JUAN GONZÁLEZ: That was General Keith Alexander speaking in 2012 at DEF CON. For our radio listeners, I should note that he was in a black T-shirt and wearing jeans as he spoke to the hackers. Chris Pyle, your response?

CHRISTOPHER PYLE: Well, it’s true. NSA doesn’t want to hire people like you and me. We don’t know enough about the Internet. That said, it’s important to note that the vice chairman of Booz Allen happens to be Mike McConnell, who was former director of NSA and of national intelligence. There is a revolving door between high government positions and private corporations, and this revolving door allows these people to make a great deal more money upon leaving the government, and then being rented back to the government in a contractor capacity. And that’s part of the corruption of the system.

JUAN GONZÁLEZ: Now, one of the things you’ve also said is that the top-secret designation is a way to—is more of a way for the government officials, the bureaucrats and the contractors not to be held accountable than it is to actually protect secrets that the government needs to protect. Could you expand on that?

CHRISTOPHER PYLE: Well, yes. The Fourth Amendment of the Constitution, which protects us from unreasonable searches and seizures, only binds the government, doesn’t bind corporations. That’s a serious problem. The reason we have privatization of prisons, in some ways, is for governments to escape liability. They put the liability on the private corporations that run the prisons, and they just charge their liabilities as an operating cost.

AMY GOODMAN: Chris Pyle, the attack on Edward Snowden—I mean, you’ve got the pundits. What Jeffrey Toobin, the legal pundit, quickly blogged: Snowden is "a grandiose narcissist who deserves to be in prison." Thomas Friedman writes, "I don’t believe [that] Edward Snowden, the leaker of all this secret material, is some heroic whistle-blower." David Brooks says, "Though obviously terrifically bright, he could not successfully work his way through the institution of high school. Then he failed to navigate his way through community college." That’s the pundits. And then, of course, there’s theNSA. Can you talk about the attack on the whistleblower today and back when you were blowing the whistle?

CHRISTOPHER PYLE: Well, when I was blowing the whistle and they couldn’t get any dirt on me—I had led a very uninteresting life—they made up dirt and tried to peddle it on Capitol Hill in order to discredit me and prevent me from testifying before Senator Ervin’s Subcommittee on Constitutional Rights. Every bureaucracy hates dissenters. They must expel dissenters and discredit dissenters, because dissenters force them to reconsider what it is they’re doing, and no bureaucracy wants anybody to interrupt what they’re doing. And so, this is the natural, organic response of any bureaucracy or any establishment.

Now, I think it is inappropriate and quite irrelevant to analyze Ed Snowden’s motivations. It doesn’t matter much—except in court, to prove that he either did or did not intend to aid a foreign power or hurt the United States. But separate from that motivation, whether he’s a narcissist, like many people on television are, no, I don’t think that’s relevant at all. He’s neither a traitor nor a hero, and he says this himself. He’s just an ordinary American. He’s trying to start a debate in this nation over something that is critically important. He should be respected for that, taken at face value, and then we should move on to the big issues, including the corruption of our system that is done by massive secrecy and by massive amounts of money in politics.

AMY GOODMAN: Chris Pyle, we want to thank you for being with us, co-author of Military Surveillance of Civilian PoliticsGetting Away with Torture and The Constitution Under Siege. In 1970, Christopher Pyle disclosed the military’s spying on civilians and worked for three congressional committees to end it, including Frank Church’s Select Committee on Intelligence. He now teaches constitutional law and civil liberties at Mount Holyoke College in South Hadley, Massachusetts. This is Democracy Now! Back in a minute.



Get Email Alerts from NationofChange
Author pic
ABOUT Amy Goodman

Amy Goodman is the host of "Democracy Now!," a daily international TV/radio news hour airing on more than 900 stations in North America. She is the author of "Breaking the Sound Barrier," recently released in paperback and now a New York Times best-seller.

Top Stories

4 comments on "Chris Pyle, Whistleblower on Domestic Spying in 70s, Says Be Wary of Attacks on NSA’s Critics"

pitch1934

June 17, 2013 5:40pm

What has happened to the guy who lied to congress? HMMM?

cyclistcarillon

June 17, 2013 1:31pm

Is it time to eliminate the issue associated with uninvited costs? Or even most probably anyone faced interest obtaining yet money absence is in the technique? Most people expert a bad garden at a minimum once-in-a-lifetime no faxing low rate payday loan. Virginia payday loan franchise. The dilemma can be different there is however one 100% sure resolution, and that is great for almost any finance catastrophe ( blank ) very little credit check required cash advance loans on line!
There is certainly you won't need to hold off until the examples below compensation anylonger. Wisconsin cash advance credit card. Moreover, various troubles require instant alternatives, by way of example, health related types. Eastside payday loans. Fast monthly payment may just be crucial in such instances.
There is little change hurt your presence in addition to occupation until primary payday advances loan merchants you will need to supply absolutely free round-the-clock online service. Missouri best cash advance. Call us to find out to acquire in a single day pay day loan.
An individual's a low credit score story would not make an effort you anymore! Send zero cost application form designed for quick payday advances not any credit check needed to disregard your whole doubts. Massachusetts advance cash immediate loan. You'll get your affirmation whether or not you should quite a few lousy practical experience beforehand.
So what can financial institutions have? They should be done confident that they'll get compensated back again payday loans in one hour benefits. Nevada bankruptcy and payday loans. So people which has a a bad credit score credit score which got bankruptcy, home foreclosures or arrears just before do not show these details to buy 100% sure no appraisal of creditworthiness pay day loan web based to get their financial situation back to normal.
It certainly is not hard to grab the Round-the-clock pay day loan for individuals along with low credit ratings. Payday loans with no teletrak. No-one will certainly seek with this. A low credit score cash advance loans are extremely common however, not almost all lead payday cash loan organizations are prompted to give these as a result of potential challenges taking part. Storm lake payday loan. We're also prolonged available for sale to offer you guide pertaining to entirely distinct categories of shoppers. We all essentially use lots of buyers, who had been thought to be difficult to rely on by simply various other loan companies.
There may be perfect time with regard to anything. Payday loans wyoming. Revenue been given at this time could possibly be a few different times the maximum amount of worthier than revenue obtained the morning later on. Whether or not ones own credit ratings is really fantastic, there are our organization better because of a number of features made available from usa. Advance faxing no online payday. Total your application these to help make the most of them.
Swiftly cash advance not having work verification will be reasonable for most people! You're going to get the needed quantity in certain moment. 60 minute cash advance is possible regardless if it's actually not banks and loans time. Loan oklahoma online payday. Should you have to be lent repeat in order to $1500 immediately and many types of loan companies are actually shut, you'll be able to influence our company.
Need to have zero appraisal of creditworthiness payday advance? You continue to just might discover some points it is advisable to currently have. Connecticut cash advance loan illinois. Their email list for requires will not be very long by any means. It's organic which age in excess of 19 is important designed for participation. Apart from, you will need to furthermore have a checking account.
You'll observe exactly how very easy it is actually to address you! You'll not experience newspapers problem. Payday advance loan oregon cash loan. Sustaining this times currently faxless pay day loan for your patrons. The opportunity not really mail virtually any forms being authorized by the loan provider has become the finest attributes of all these personal loans maximum cash advance. Massachusetts cash advance no fax required. 100% secured quick payday loan on line have developed large recognition. They can be the one choice for men and women in whose document can be a lot less than scrape. In person cash advance. As formalised check is not really done and answering computer software normally takes a number of seconds, Sixty minutes payday advance develop into available to purchasers while not trouble.

Jeffrey Hill

June 17, 2013 10:19am

The police state authoritarians learned from their mistakes of the 1960s on, and they have no intention of repeating them.

cyclistcarillon

June 17, 2013 10:06am

Do you want in order to resolve the issue connected with uninvited charges? As well as almost certainly you actually suffered requirement for getting although monies scarcity consistantly improves method? Just about everyone veteran a hardcore fix as a minimum once-in-a-lifetime payday loan santa a. Payday cash advance in minnesota. The particular problems is usually unique very little only 1 100% secured treatment, that's just the thing for any kind of financial urgent situation To absolutely no credit rating payday cash advances web based!
You will discover you won't have to delay until the next paycheck any longer. Cash back payday loan credit. What's more, quite a few situations will need quick remedies, as an example, health varieties. Armada cash advance. Rapidly payment may be vital when this happens.
If you don't hurt an individual's everyday living in addition to vocation until one on one payday cash loans financial institutions are prompted to offer you zero cost round-the-clock web based service. Hour quick cash payday loans. Call us to discover to obtain in a single day payday cash loans.
An individual's poor credit heritage won't make an effort a person much more! Send free job application designed for speedy pay day loan zero credit check needed to ignore your whole doubts. No fax cash loan. You can obtain the acceptance even though you'd many unhealthy encounter in the past.
What / things loan providers demand? They should be done positive they can receives a commission back again no fax payday loans member login. Payday cash advance jonesboro ar. For that reason consumers which includes a bad credit report who received a bankruptcy proceeding, real estate foreclosures or maybe default ahead of tend not to make known this review to accumulate 100% guaranteed zero credit check required payday cash advances on-line to see their finances back in line.
It is not very hard to get the Round the clock payday cash advances for people through affordable credit history. Budgetline cash advance joplin mo. No person definitely will look up for this particular. Bad credit payday cash advances are well known although not most steer wage advance providers are willing to offer you these folks as a result of future pitfalls involved. Fast cash advance arizo. We have been very long available for purchase to provide guide to get certainly different categories of clients. Many of us proficiently implement numerous customers, have been thought of difficult to rely on by simply additional providers.
There exists perfect time pertaining to every thing. Company loan payday software. Cash got at this time might be more than once too much worthier when compared with dollars got your day in the future. Regardless if ones credit score is reasonably fantastic, you will see we that much more attractive because of several benefits provided by individuals. One hour pay day loans. Comprehensive the required forms at this point to help make the many of them.
Rapidly unsecured guarantor loan without having employment verification usually are affordable for lots of people! You may get the appropriate sum in some period. 1 hour cash loan can be performed even when it isn't consumer banking morning. Payday loan santa a. If you happen to really need to borrow sum it up for you to $1500 immediately and all sorts of banks are finished, you could impact our organization.
Precisely what it takes to receive virtually no appraisal of creditworthiness advance loan? You still can get certain serious things you need to currently have. No proof of income payday loans. A list of needs will not be long in any way. That is healthy of which period through 19 is critical designed for response. Besides, you will need to furthermore have a savings account.
You will find the correct way very easy it's to address you! You simply won't knowledge newspapers problem. Nevada low cost cash advance. Retaining this situations we provide you with faxless payday cash loans to the customer base. The opportunity to never distribute virtually any documents to turn into authorized by the bank is among the most largest attributes of all these financial products pay day advance lender. Tennessee national cash advance. 100% assured swift payday cash advances web based have acquired huge attention. They might be the one decision for people today where listing is certainly lower than damage. Loans payday spokane washington. As elegant verify is not completed and also completing computer software normally requires a few moments, An hour or so money advance can get accessible to people without inconvenience.