Allan Goldstein
NationofChange / Op-Ed
Published: Wednesday 19 September 2012
“Conservatives’ hopes and plans for the future are exceedingly stingy.”

Debunking Debunking

Article image

I was innocently chilling at home the other day when my TV brutally assaulted me with yet another show about how bad America is.  We’re number one in nothing, our schools suck, our health stinks, and our politics toxic as salmonella.  Then I endured a movie where our double-crossed hero spends two hours dodging bullets from corrupt CIA operatives.

I wasn’t surprised by the negative tone; we live in difficult times.  What got to me was the joy with which the bad news was delivered.  Everywhere I turned there was a talking head chortling with glee over the decline of our once-great nation.

Call it cynicism, call it disillusionment, call it the debunking of America. Just don’t call it liberalism.  Reciting the litany of woe has become a habit with liberals.  It’s hard to fault them for it, but that should never be an end in itself.  Liberalism is about hope and the future, even in the worst of times.  Especially in the worst of times.

When corrosive liberal debunking spreads despair in America, the American people despair and the liberals lose.  Nihilism is the mortal enemy of liberalism.  Because if you don’t have anything to look up to, you don’t have anything to live up to.

Conservatives’ hopes and plans for the future are exceedingly stingy.  Conservatives base their philosophy on the tragic nature of man.  They use that partial truth as an excuse to do as little as possible about human tragedy.

If you think that man is intrinsically evil and always on the verge of being worse, you fear the future.  The conservative thinks mankind is so fallen, so riddled with original sin, he can never live it down.  Though, God knows, some of them try.

As liberals, we can’t buy into that narrative.  But we do, far too often.  We feel the injustices of the world, we see the tragic gaps between our illusions and reality, and we fall right down that chasm.

There is corruption in our society.  But the answer to corruption isn’t corrosion.  It’s a cleansing, it’s healing, and it’s a fresh start.  That’s the liberal message.  Once upon a time, when progressives were smart and tactical and forward-looking they had a name for their ideals.  To use 21st century speak, they “branded,” them very well.  They called it The New Deal.

See what is implied in that?  The deal is rotten, the game is fixed, and the deck is stacked.  So what are we going to do, cry about it?

Nope.  We’re going to crack open a new deck and pass Social Security and the WPA and the Civilian Conservation Corps.  We’re sweeping the chips off the table and starting a fresh game.

Paradise was not achieved.  But liberals kept making progress.  Old people got government pensions, African-Americans got the right to vote, women got a modicum of control over their own bodies, workers got a minimum wage, the general welfare got a little more general.

Is it ever complete?  No, humanity isn’t perfectible, it’s a constant struggle, and it’s a job that never ends.

But it’s the progressive’s job.  The light we shine on corruption and injustice must always point to a brighter future.  Otherwise we’re just looking back in anger.  Looking back: That’s the conservative’s job.

The opposite of liberal debunking isn’t Pollyanna.  The answer to the corrosive, depressing liberal sorrows is an answer.  It’s a goal, it’s a thousand goals, it’s trying, failing, and then trying some more, forever and ever amen.

Or not.  We can agree with the conservatives and give up.  If everything is truly, helplessly, fatally terrible, well, we’ve had a dark age before.

I respectfully submit that things aren’t that bad now, not yet.  I have hopes for the future because I’m a liberal.  I have a vision that keeps me going.  I know there is inequality; I believe in equality.  I know there is dire poverty in a world of obscene wealth; I believe in less poverty and cleaner wealth.  I know that America hasn’t lived up to its promise; I believe in the promise of America.

When people are nagged to death about the sicknesses in our culture, they shoot the messenger.  When they fear the future, they become suckers for nostalgia, even fake nostalgia.

There is a political party, which has spent the last four years peddling fake nostalgia, using ammunition the liberals handed to them.  Their leader is named Romney.

And if we debunking liberals refuse to offer the people hope, he’ll gladly sell them bunk.



Get Email Alerts from NationofChange
Author pic
ABOUT Allan Goldstein

Allan Goldstein lives in San Francisco with his wife, Jordan, and a minimum of two cats. His op-ed newspaper column,“Caught off Base,” has appeared in San Francisco’s West Portal Monthly for the past decade. Satire, invective and humor are specialties.

Top Stories

6 comments on "Debunking Debunking"

Dave Sheppard

September 20, 2012 5:06am

"'Debunking' without just cause."

We perceive to live. To the extent we can perceive reality, let's say, to accurately discriminate between nutrients and toxins, helps our health. Same with information in general.

We'll never see 100.00% reality, as everyone has filters and biases, but the manipulation of other people via misinformation, systematic disempowerment, and sometimes forceful and violent oppression is what lies further down this axis of what the Dominator Paradigm calls Free Market Conservatism.

Look at the world. Look at the last 100 years in the "Third World". It doesn't take a huge amount of research to see that the corporate forces (and U.S. military) that dominated all of the Americas is finally coming home to use similar tactics on the middle and lower classes in the USA as we slide farther away from the American Dream.

Debunking WITH cause would be focusing energy where exposing lies can help change reality for the better. For people. And by "people" I don't mean Goldman Sachs or Halliburton. Down with the vultures and jackals. Up with working together, for as long as humans can avoid snuffing ourselves out.

Just Cause: making humans becoming worthy of survival.

BozoAdult

September 22, 2012 2:07am

Well said!

anono

September 19, 2012 6:12pm

Cancervatism is a mushroom! It relies on on darkness and bullshit to grow. And one of those mushrooms belched "our poor are some of the richest in the world". I didn't realize that living in a cardboard box underneath a bridge in America is so much better than living in a refugee camp in Africa. I guess the distinction between the wealthy poor and the poor poor is which one does or doesn't have duct tape to hold the cardboard together.

Chris Wilborn

September 19, 2012 4:09pm

On the contrary : Conservatives Only want the Best for all mankind. We do not "base their (our) philosophy on the tragic nature of man." We think that humans will always strive for what's best for each individual. It's the governments job to get out of the way and let that happen. Yes, there is a "Human Nature" that will sometimes seek for easy way and that means stepping on someone else's rights. The government is then needed to step in and stop that from happening.
There will always be those who are more lucky, smarter, or just work harder than all the rest (they become the wealthy). They deserve all the benefits that come. We all hope for that wealth. Allan's personal wealth is "obscene" to many others in this vast world.
Because our great nation is based on Religious or ethical ideals, it is assumed that that the wealthy will help out the poor. And, throughout our history, that has been the case. Is our system perfect ? No, not hardly. But, it has worked fairly well. Our poor are some of the richest in the world.
One thing that has made our nation one of the best on this planet is that, in the past, Liberals and Conservatives have been able to work together for the good of all. Again, not perfectly. "Humanity isn't perfectible".
By either side calling names, lying for political gain, "Debunking" without just cause, etc., we will NOT get back to the "Better times ahead".

BozoAdult

September 21, 2012 1:56am

"Conservatives Only want the Best for all mankind."

Adolf Hitler: "Nazis Only want the Best for all mankind."

BozoAdult

September 21, 2012 1:46am

Throughout history there is one example after another of the wealthy not only allowing the poor to stave to death but of also creating the conditions that caused the extreme poverty to begin with.

And that is exactly where we find ourselves at today. The poor did not use deregulation, fraud and greed to bring down the world economy.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=Z-kKGELUc8A