Joe Conason
NationofChange / Op-Ed
Published: Saturday 16 June 2012
Romney called him and two or three other residents into his room, saying, “Come up, I want to show you something.” When they entered Romney’s room, ”And laid out on his bed was a Michigan State Trooper’s uniform.”

Did Young Romney Impersonate a Police Officer? Another Witness Says Yes

Article image

When Mitt Romney was a college freshman, he told fellow residents of his Stanford University dormitory that he sometimes disguised himself as a police officer — a crime in many states, including Michigan and California, where he then lived. And he had the uniform on display as proof.

So recalls Robin Madden, who had also just arrived as a freshman, the startling incident began when Romney called him and two or three other residents into his room, saying, "Come up, I want to show you something." When they entered Romney's room, "and laid out on his bed was a Michigan State Trooper's uniform."

Madden, a native Texan who graduated from Stanford in 1970 and went on to become a successful television producer and writer, has never forgotten that strange moment, which he has recounted to friends over the years as he observed his former classmate's political ascent. The National Memo learned of the incident from a longtime Madden friend to whom he had mentioned it years ago.

Said Madden in a recent interview, "He told us that he had gotten the uniform from his father," George Romney, then the governor of Michigan, whose security detail was staffed by uniformed troopers. "He told us that he was using it to pull over drivers on the road. He also had a red flashing light that he would attach to the top of his white Rambler."

In Madden's recollection, confirmed by his wife Susan, who also attended Stanford during those years, "we thought it was all pretty weird. We all thought, 'Wow, that's pretty creepy.' And after that, we didn't have much interaction with him," although both Madden and Romney were prep school boys living in the same dorm, called Rinconada.

Other eyewitnesses have previously recalled Romney's alleged use of a police or trooper uniform in pranks during his high school years at the exclusive Cranbrook School in Bloomfield Hills, Mich.

Phillip Maxwell, a prep school buddy, told the New Republic in 2008 that Romney had pulled over students from a girls school next door to Cranbrook while wearing a police uniform as a prank. Other former classmates described Mitt as a "happy-go-lucky guy known less for his achievements and more for his pranks."

In "The Real Romney," a biography published by Boston Globe reporters Michael Kranish and Scott Helman this year, another former friend recalled how Romney had "put a siren on top of his car and chased two of his friends who were driving around with their dates." The two friends were in on the scheme, but the girls were not. There was beer in the car trunk, according to a prearranged plan. Mitt told his two counterparts to get out of their vehicle and into his car. Then they drove off, leaving the girls behind.

"It was a terrible thing to do," said one of his accomplices, a Cranbrook classmate named Graham McDonald.

To some observers, Romney's alleged masquerading as a cop to intimidate innocent drivers shows a character defect that is also revealed by other bullying incidents during his youth. When those incidents were disclosed in The Washington Post earlier this year, Romney issued an apology of sorts, stating that he had done "stupid" things and was sorry if he had harmed anyone.

While he may have believed that his cop antics were harmless, Romney may well have been breaking the law merely by donning a police uniform, committing a crime if he pretended to be a cop and a felony if he did so more than once. In both California and Michigan, any person convicted of fraudulently impersonating a police officer may be sentenced to up to one year in prison.

The Romney campaign did not respond to multiple requests for comment.

Following his sophomore year at Stanford, young Mitt left and never went back. For more than two years, he served as a Mormon missionary in France — thus avoiding the obligation to wear a very different uniform in Vietnam.

Copyright Creators.com


Get Email Alerts from NationofChange
ABOUT Joe Conason

Joe Conason has written his popular political column for The New York Observer since 1992. He served as the Manhattan Weekly’s executive editor from 1992 to 1997. Since 1998, he has also written a column that is among the most widely read features on Salon.com. Conason is also a senior fellow at The Nation Institute.

Top Stories

13 comments on "Did Young Romney Impersonate a Police Officer? Another Witness Says Yes"

wildthang

July 16, 2012 3:52pm

So if he gets into the uniform of commaner-in-chief of the world police force what would he do? Or the red, white and blue cape with 'S"uper-power? Of course he will have minders keeping watch on him at all times... he might not get to do as much as he thinks...

Theodore Ziolkowski

June 16, 2012 2:22pm

When Mitt Romney was a college freshman, he told fellow residents of his Stanford University dormitory that he sometimes disguised himself as a police officer — a crime in many states, including Michigan. This is a Felony and not a prank, I am not sure what the statute of limitations are in regards to this crime. In Michigan, any person convicted of fraudulently impersonating a police officer may be sentenced to up to one year in prison.

"He, Mitt Romney, told us that he was using it to pull over drivers on the road. He also had a red flashing light that he would attach to the top of his white Rambler."

For more than two years, the coward, Mitt Romney served as a Mormon missionary in France — thus avoiding the obligation to wear a very different uniform in Vietnam. I tried to serve my country but was classified 4F due to a Physical Limitations. I still think people like myself should serve, because we can maintain the desk jobs. My brother served two rotations and earned three Purple Hearts and more. A friend of mine died there. as each of you may have also had many more Friends, brothers, and sons who were injured and died to defend this cowards right to come home and get Rich after the War.

grannm

June 16, 2012 12:11pm

God save us from another Harvard MBA president whose studies in business administration trained him for a life of greed and deceit.

Ronni85

June 16, 2012 11:36am

Obama is not the fighter WE the People need, but he is certainly not so vain as to play dress-up for his wanna-be life.

Curtis Smay

June 16, 2012 11:33am

Anyone thinking of voting for Romney or any other Red tide member is sure runing low on brain fuel . Do you like living in a failing nation ? Well that is what the red tide has and will do for you.

Jeffrey Hill

June 16, 2012 10:15am

Mittens is currently impersonating a human being.

Curtis Smay

June 16, 2012 11:35am

You got that right and that should be illegal as well . Why would the voters want to vote for a known liar and law breaker?

Paul Charles Ha...

June 16, 2012 10:49am

...and not very convincingly, I might add... (OK, I DID add)

miz.behaves

June 16, 2012 10:07am

No politician is lily-white pure by the time he or she reaches the level needed to run for President of the US.

All have done or not done things that can and will outrage some people. Obama never served in the military, which I think ought to be a requirement to be president. And to my mind, is a "terrible thing" not to do.

Of course, serving in the military will likely never be a requirement for being president.

Yes, it is against the law to impersonate a police officer. However, these pranks, which everyone agrees should not be done, are often "forgiven" if done by students, depending on where they live and who they "know."

It is hardly front page news.

MNhistoryfan's picture
MNhistoryfan

June 16, 2012 6:23pm

It goes to his character. By then, he was old enough to know better. The incident with the forced haircut is evidence that he's a bully and lacks compassion.
So does driving cross country with the dog on top of the car. So does his business experience in which other people suffered and paid the price and--just like W and his Texas Rangers--who walked out of the deal with money and left his compatriots holding the bag.
What does being in the military have to do with being president? I think only to show the horrors of war and that the president would be driven to any any and all means to avoid it.
I have not seen anything about Romney that suggests he is caring and compassionate and that his character would be improved by military service--unless he was in the middle of Afghanistan trying to survive IEDs, snipers, etc. When -- if -- he returned, he might have more understanding of war.

NHsolarguy

June 16, 2012 11:29am

Obama is my age, and there were no active wars during that time... he was too young for Vietnam, and by the time we got into the Middle East, he would have been about 30. I don't think serving in the military should be requirement - looking at the problems that soldiers have after serving, I would say a bigger requirement is a desire to keep us out of war.

On the other hand, character flaws don't go away... Romney has trouble relating to non-rich people. He was a bully. He likes to fire people. He beat up on gay kids. He's the kind of guy that probably smoked pot as a kid, but would now put other kids in jail and ruin their lives for the same offenses. Impersonating an officer was not just a prank, and wasn't "just a little" illegal. If he ever got caught, I'm sure that it got "handled" by his father's people, something that most of us can't rely on. How many years in prison would Obama have gotten if caught doing the same thing? If he didn't get killed while getting arrested, he'd probably still be in prison. Romney is truly the 1% personified, and that alone makes him unfit for office.

Say what you want about Obama - maybe some of his policy choices are compromises that don't make everyone happy, and he has been constantly hampered by a Republican Party that opposes everything he tries, regardless of whether they think it's good for the country or not. That makes them unfit for office, not him. But at least Obama has empathy for the normal non-rich person in this country. He worked his way through law school the hard way, with lots of disadvantages and none of the perks that Romney had. As a young man he worked as a community organizer to help people.

Obama is intelligent, well educated, and a man of character. He listens to other points of view, has a loving family, and is in politics to make life better for most people. Romney, like George W, was a spoiled rich kid, wasn't interested in his education or learning other points of view, has daddy issues, and his policies are totally focused on making his rich friends richer. We really don't want to go back there!

MNhistoryfan's picture
MNhistoryfan

June 16, 2012 6:28pm

Even more disturbing to me about Romney's religion than the one-time multiple marriage partners (for men) is the Mormon belief that they can retroactively "save" non-Mormons from hell and make them Mormons by some ritual and baptismal hokey pokey. I don't want to be a Mormon. Jews are particularly incensed at this retroactive "salvation."
How can any sane person really believe in this.
As for Obama, despite my disappointments with him and the belief he could have pushed harder for Democratic principles, he is smart, educated, articulate, and persistent in working his way to bring himself up largely by himself. His mother and Kansas grandparents could not help him much financially, but I admire anyone who has the guts to do what he has done. Much more in touch with those who did similar things.

Paul Charles Ha...

June 16, 2012 10:48am

So sez you...