You are viewing the NationofChange archives. For the latest news and actions, visit the new
Get Email Updates | Log In | Register

Federal Judge Strips Vermont of Power to Terminate Nuke: State Government Diddles but Vermonters Take Matters into Own Hands

Dan DeWalt
This Can’t Be Happening / News Analysis
Published: Sunday 12 February 2012
“In the past, when the federal government passed heinous legislation that flew in the face of decency and common sense, such as the fugitive slave act, Vermont took appropriate and defiant action.”
Article image

Entergy Nuclear of Louisiana, which operates the Vermont Yankee (VY) nuclear reactor in Vernon Vermont has launched an attack on the state of Vermont with the help of the federal courts.

Vermont state law gives the state the power to decide whether to allow further operation of the reactor past March 21, 2012 (the expiration date for VY). When Entergy bought VY, they agreed to this law and swore that they would not try to abrogate it. This was an outright lie on Entergy's part, and they sued the state as soon as it was decided that further operation of this crumbling, leaking and led-by-liars reactor would NOT be in the interests of the state and they were not given permission to continue operation past March 21.

Federal Judge J. Garvan Murtha, a George W. Bush appointee to the federal bench in 2002, gave Entergy all that they wanted and denied Vermont the right to legislate on this matter. The judge misconstrued testimony and completely ignored the case presented by the state to show that the Vermont legislature acted within the purview allowed by federal law. In his decision he cites quotes referring to safety that are either unattributed or taken out of context, having been expressed outside of the actual process of crafting the legislation. Some quotes cited even fail to distinguish between legislators and advocates who were speaking in committee hearings.

This ruling goes hand in glove with current Federal policies that enrich the 1% and keep power firmly in the hands of America's largest corporations. It affirms that corporate profits trump the interests of the citizenry. And it's based on the laughable notion that only the Federal government can be trusted to keep us safe from radiological accidents caused by corporate malfeasance and profit-driven lax practices.

The executives of Entergy have lied under oath repeatedly to the Vermont legislature. Reactor officials testified that there were no pipes in the ground underneath the plant, but that falsehood was exposed when the source of tritium leaks at the reactor in 2011 were found to be coming from a network of underground pipes located precisely where they claimed there were none. Entergy repeatedly warned that VT would lose a reliable energy provider if VY went off line, but VT utilities have chosen to buy future power elsewhere and not one watt of VY power will be purchased by any Vermonter. Entergy tried to bribe the legislature (in Louisiana talk, they called it a gift offer) and have run roughshod over every aspect of the state's self governance, relying on their tight association with the NRC, which abets rather than regulates the industry, to ensure that their reprehensible actions are allowed to occur unchecked.

The state of Vermont is fighting back, considering all possible moves that can be made to rein in this corporate behemoth, but Federal law and the courts are limiting the State's possible responses. It is an outrage that a federal judge would ignore a lengthy and well documented trail of lies and deception on the part of a powerful corporation, and choose instead to basically accuse the Vermont legislature of lying about its intent when passing the legislation. He chose to accept Entergy's lawyers' claim that the legislature was trying to address radiological safety issues, which are exclusively under federal jurisdiction, and he rejected the legislature's defense that they were responsibly considering issues of environmental safety and economic benefit to the state.

In the past, when the federal government passed heinous legislation that flew in the face of decency and common sense, such as the fugitive slave act, Vermont took appropriate and defiant action. The legislature responded to that abomination with the swift passage of a habeas corpus bill that effectively prevented a fugitive slave from being returned. President Millard Fillmore threatened to call out the U.S, army to enforce the law, but Vermont didn't flinch, and his threat came to naught.

Direct defiance (or nullification) of the federal government edicts by states was somewhat common in the pre-civil war days. Today, the legislature feels more timid about direct defiance, thinking that the legal appeals process is the only avenue that they can realistically utilize.

But Vermont citizens are seeing it otherwise. Thoroughly fed up by the brutish greed and callous disregard shown to them by Entergy, they are organizing to take direct action against the corporation, both in Vermont and elsewhere in the country. Citizens in VT, NH, MA and NY will be targeting Entergy corporate headquarters and other installations from March 22 onward.

Luckily for them, Entergy is further alienating the citizenry by attempting to leverage their district court victory into a scorched earth devastation of the state, demanding no further accountability to the state's Public Service Board, denying the state's request to access radiated water wells on the reactor site for further testing, demanding that Connecticut River water quality and temperature permits be nullified and that the state pay over four million dollars to the corporation to pay for their high priced lawyers during the trial.

This brazen, relentless and vicious assault is irritating Vermonters of all stripes and it seems that Entergy will soon feel their wrath. While the corporation may feel secure with the federal court (so far) protecting them from the civilly obedient legislature and governor, it remains to be seen if they will be able to withstand the storm of protest that is brewing over the horizon.

For more information about

For more information about how you can get involved and prepared to participate in nonviolent direct actions to shut down Vermont Yankee, visit the SAGE Alliance on the Web:

feds over run state ask ariz

feds over run state ask ariz about that

Rule of Lawyers! aka Rule of

Rule of Lawyers! aka Rule of Force & Fraud! aka CRIMINAL JUST US!

The TRUTH and the Constitutional Rule of Law are Minor Inconveniences and Insignificant Technicalities to "judges" who view the Constitution as their personal roll of toilet paper.

Where are US Senators Bernie Sanders (I-Vt) and Patrick Leahy (D-Vt)?!

Mr. Leahy is the head of the US Senate Judiciary Committee responsible for confirming the appointment of "judges" to the federal bench and for their removal from the bench by impeachment.

Corporations , republicans

Corporations , republicans and Catholics are not people.
No nuk is a safe nuk and all should be shut and no new permits for new construction . There are only two reasons to build nuks , 1. is greed and 2. is ignorance.What good is power generation if you are nuked to death.

ETNIKS's picture

On April 4, 1995, President

On April 4, 1995, President Bill Clinton nominated John Garvan Murtha to a seat on the United States District Court for the District of Vermont vacated by Franklin S. Billings, Jr.. Murtha was confirmed by the United States Senate on May 25, 1995, and received his commission on May 26, 1995. He served as chief judge, 1995-2002
Chair of the Vermont Commission on Low-Level Nuclear Waste from 1987 to 1990;

Sure looks that way, William.

Sure looks that way, William. Grow a garden. Hang out your laundry. Conserve. Reduce, reuse, recycle.

Yep. Marge Wood

Yep. Marge Wood

. . . Interesting - "Federal

. . . Interesting - "Federal Judge Strips Vermont of Power to Terminate Nuke -
SCOTUS stripped all residents of Florida of their votes - Appoints George Bush President - Justice Sotomayer refused to hear the appeal of an innocent man - COURT APPOINTED TIME LIMIT EXPIRED. . CORPORATIONS ARE PEOPLE TOO. . .
Almost sounds like our government is out of control. . . the NRC approves two new nuclear plants ????
The "surgeon genera"l has determined smoking may be hazardous to your health?? PAID by the "TAXPAYERS DOLLARS" the tabacco industry receives government tax subsidies from the tax payers - growers also ?.?.?
. . . . .
Gasoline prices go up -.- big oil wants the XL pipeline ( to export the oil not import it ) at the same time gasoline is exported.....
Vice President (REPUBLICAN) Dick Cheney said oil will pay for the WARS -.- secret energy meeting - wanna know who was there ??? SCOTUS SAYS SECRET.....
wind me up and watch me tick as I get ticked off -.- trickle down economy??? I've been trickled on

Comment with your Facebook account

Comment with your Disqus account

Top Stories

comments powered by Disqus

NationofChange works to educate, inform, and fight power with people, corruption with community.

If you would like to stay up to date with the best in independent, filter-free journalism, updates on upcoming events to attend, and more, enter your email below:

7 Compelling Reasons Why You Should Support NationofChange

Our readers often tell us why they’ve decided to step up and become supporters. Here are some of the top reasons people are giving.

1. You’re keeping independent journalism alive
The corporate owned media has proven that it can’t be trusted. In a media landscape wrought with spin and corruption, NationofChange stands in very scarce company.

2. You’re sticking it to the rich, powerful, and corrupt
When you have money in this country you can get away with damn near anything, and they do. NationofChange isn’t afraid to expose these criminals no matter how powerful they are.

3. Your donation is 100% tax-deductible
NationofChange is a 501(c)3 charity. People tend to assume that many other organizations are (most nonprofits are NOT) but it’s that 501(c)3 status is a bit more rare than you think.

Read the rest...