Article image
Froma Harrop
NationofChange / Op-Ed
Published: Tuesday 7 August 2012
“With the pragmatic Republican establishment under ideological attack, its moderates may no longer feel free to be themselves.”

The Grand Old Party’s Breaking Up

Article image

When traditional Republicans tell their tea party wing that they have to negotiate with Democrats, the radicals' frequent response is: No, they don't. One side has to win. But before that fistfight at the edge of the falls can take place, one side has to win within the Republican Party. Civil wars are not pretty.

The tea party movement has become the dead bad-luck bird hanging around the GOP establishment's neck. Its anger-fueled energy has forced moderate Republicans off ballots in places where moderates tend to win. It has burdened otherwise centrist Republicans with radical positions that don't go well with a general electorate. The Grand Old Party is being taken over by an ideological fringe with unclear motives, a loose grasp on reality and little interest in actually governing.

The most recent victim is Ohio Republican Steven LaTourette, who says that he's had it after 18 years in the House. The uncompromising partisanship drove him out. "Anybody that doesn't understand that in a split government, you've got to find a common-ground way out of it, it's not going to be your way or the highway, is nuts," he said.

But suppose the right wing is nuts. Or suppose it isn't nuts but doesn't quite understand that pushing the United States to the brink of default, as it did last summer, is bad for the world, the United States and even itself. Or perhaps the radicals think that grown-ups somewhere will attend to the details while they play.

The right wing so badgered Maine Sen. Olympia Snowe that the Republican moderate — and shoo-in for re-election — has decided to leave the Senate. Now the party may lose her Senate seat to a Democrat. In Indiana, longtime Republican statesman Sen. Richard Lugar lost the primary to Richard Mourdock, a tea party favorite. That seat is now up in the air as Mourdock and Democratic Rep.

Joe Donnelly battle it out. Donnelly has turned his opponent's tea party ties into a campaign issue.

Poor Mitt Romney is unable to pick sides — among fellow Republicans, that is. He says one thing in swing state Colorado, another in usually Republican Indiana. His socially moderate record as governor of Massachusetts would play well with most independents, who will ultimately decide the election. But he can't go there for fear of losing a right wing that does not like him.

Speaking of Massachusetts, Republican Sen. Scott Brown is now running neck and neck with Democrat Elizabeth Warren. He's done this in a generally liberal state by talking up his independent stands and how he wants to work with Democrats. But suppose he's re-elected and his fellow Republicans won't work with him, a likelihood, given the increasing demonization of moderates within the party.

And suppose — a real consideration for Massachusetts voters — Brown becomes a neutered outcast, while his re-election sends control of the closely divided Senate to the right-wingers. Do centrists in Massachusetts or anywhere else want tea party activist Jim DeMint, of South Carolina, controlling the powerful Senate Commerce, Science and Transportation Committee?

And with the pragmatic Republican establishment under ideological attack, its moderates may no longer feel free to be themselves. Snowe voted to create the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, which the right opposed. But with the Maine tea party later breathing down her neck, she only voted "present" during a filibuster of the appointee to run the bureau, the unobjectionable Richard Cordray, former attorney general of Ohio.

One's rooting for traditional Republicans to retake control of the asylum and restore a normal brand of politics. That would be very good for the country, a not-small consideration. The only side winning so far is the Democrats'.

Copyright Creators.com


Get Email Alerts from NationofChange
Author pic
ABOUT Froma Harrop
Froma Harrop’s nationally syndicated column appears in over 150 newspapers, including The Dallas Morning News, Houston Chronicle, Seattle Times, Denver Post and Newsday. The twice-a-week column is distributed by Creators Syndicate, in Los Angeles. Harrop has written for numerous other publications, ranging from The New York Times and Institutional Investor, to Harper’s Bazaar and Metropolitan Home. Previously, she covered business for Reuters Ltd., in New York, and was a financial editor for The New York Times News Service. A Loeb Award finalist for economic commentary, Harrop was also honored by the National Society of Newspaper Columnists. Over the years, the New England Associated Press News Executives Association has named her for five awards.

Top Stories

10 comments on "The Grand Old Party’s Breaking Up"

Theodore Ziolkowski

August 08, 2012 11:49am

Here is the perfect plan for the Democratic Party to take full control of the Senate and the House of Representatives. First we must vote in every Primary and in the Republican Primaries in every state. We must make sure that the Tea-Party candidate is elected to represent the Republican Party. Then the Tea-Party will defeat itself with the radical positions that don't go well with a general electorate, in the General Elections.

The tea party movement has become the dead bad-luck bird hanging around the GOP establishment's neck. Its anger-fueled energy has forced moderate Republicans off ballots in places where moderates tend to win.

If we do this, it will mean the death of the Republican Party.

strugglingtomakeit

August 08, 2012 2:14am

All a bunch of BS! I am so tired of all the lies.
Can't we all try to tell the truth for a change?
Trust but VERIFY!
Do not listen to the MSM!
Research the topic yourself. You might just find the TRUTH out there..somewhere. You will not find it in the media.

All of you putting down the TEA Party...Why don't you go to some of their rallies and find out what they are REALLY up to?

Theodore Ziolkowski

August 08, 2012 11:51am

Been there, done that. All I saw and talked to were Dumb as a Rock, Red-Neck Biggots.

Joe the Voter

August 08, 2012 9:03am

As a FORMER liberal member of my local Tea Party I had to stop going to meetings. I realized they are closed minded and fully brain washed by fringe thinking that bears little connection to reality.

Despite "saying" they just want to "educate" the public to the truth, they refuse to accept or even read any truth that does not support their own brand of thinking. They selectively ignore anything that contradicts what they have chosen to believe.

I like the people...they are friends and neighbors. But they are dead-set against anything or anyone who is not ultra-conservative.

With such a closed mind-set their only political purpose is to preach to their own kind who are already sold on their own limited set of "liberties" that often don't include all Americans.

Swimmer

August 08, 2012 5:18am

Follow the history of the TEA Party votes, or lack there of! It is there way or the highway.

Craigpurcell

August 07, 2012 1:21pm

The Tea Party is energized about something or the other... What are the Libs energized about ?

arky70

August 07, 2012 11:33am

I keep trying to explain this to people I know who say they will vote Republican in November. These are ill informed people who don't realize the change in the Party, especially these past two years since the takeover by the Koch Bros founded and funded Tea Party radicals. The GOP is mostly dead and it's now the Tea Party.

LKB2012

August 07, 2012 11:00am

The Tea Party folks I run into in the rural parts of NY and PA seem to be a mix of anti-government "I hate everybody" survivalists who want the government out of their business - somehow bonded with the fundamentalist Christians who want the government in everybody elses business when it comes to all moral issues. I find them odd bed mates.
Most of the moderate Republicans are being run off, or they are just too tired to argue with the Tea Party extremists anymore, so they leave.
I can only imagine how awful the negative ad campaigns will become by November.

Jerry Mercks's picture
Jerry Mercks
Huntsville, AL
August 07, 2012 10:22am

To the people of Massachusetts. Don't be fooled by brown. He has been a radical since he was elected. Now he pulling a romney, pretending to be moderate. You can bet your last penny that if he is elected he'll be right there with the extreme tea party folks. If the right-wingers on Wall St. didn't think so they wouldn't be giving him so much money.

Caveat Emptor

Jeffrey Hill

August 07, 2012 9:51am

Lunatic fringe wants ideological purity in the Republican Party.

Only Confederates, Ku Klux Kristians, and NeoNazis need to belong.

The tea is laced with bath salts.