Illinois School Board Abandons Transgender Students for Hate Group’s Favor

Zack Ford
Think Progress / News Report
Published: Monday 22 October 2012
“After realizing that affirming transgender students’ preferred names and restrooms was not mandated by the state, the Board was eager to cater to negative feedback, led by the hate group the Illinois Family Institute. ”
Article image

As projected, the East Aurora, Illinois, School Board held an “emergency” meeting Friday night to reconsider the transgender-inclusive policy it had unanimously passed just earlier in the week. After realizing that affirming transgender students’ preferred names and restrooms was not mandated by the state, the Board was eager to cater to negative feedback, led by the hate group the Illinois Family Institute. At the “Spirit Day” meeting, the four Board members in attendance voted unanimously to rescind the policy — less a reconsideration than a foregone conclusion.

Rick Einhorn, a resident of the community, attended the meeting and transcribed the remarks made by Board President Annette Johnson. She tried to explain that the policies simply were not vetted properly, and since it was not policy issued by the Illinois State Board of Education, the Board simply could not stand by it.  She apologized at least six times and three times explained that she was “not making excuses.” Still, she had little to say about affirming transgender youth, and her poor understanding of their experiences was made evident when she pointed out that she could relate because she used to be a tomboy:

JOHNSON: This is very tough for me tonight. This is very tough for me tonight. I guess, maybe I was thinking of how it’d affect me personally. I was that tomboy in school and the boys picked on me. That happened. I know how it goes. I really do. I will tell you. I am sorry, from the bottom of my heart that this ever happened. This, again, there is no win in this. You’ve got one side, you’ve got the other side.

Johnson claimed that the Board will reconsider adding transgender inclusion to its anti-bullying and diversity policies, but couldn’t offer an explanation why such protections were not already in place.

Members of the The Civil Rights Agenda, a Chicago-based LGBT advocacy organization, told the board that it had been bullied into rescinding the policy and that by doing so, it was inviting bullying to continue against trans students. Rick Garcia, the group’s policy advisor, said he hopes the school has “a very large legal defense fund” because “the first transgender student who is hurt or harmed in this district will be a millionaire.”



Get Email Alerts from NationofChange

Top Stories

3 comments on "Illinois School Board Abandons Transgender Students for Hate Group’s Favor"

SaulT

October 22, 2012 3:36pm

Talk about "catering to negative stereotypes," by slandering those who simply don't want male adolescents using female washrooms in high schools as "hate groups!"

dwdallam

October 22, 2012 4:02pm

@SaulT

What's wrong with having females and males in the same restroom? Are we not "advanced" enough yet to share the restroom with our opposites? France has had cooed bathrooms for since ever. Big deal. If a problem arises, you deal with it, just like any social problem. Moving forward means giving humans more freedom and the education to deal with that freedom and responsibility for your fellow human beings.

Doing the opposite is regressing.

Diane

October 22, 2012 12:05pm

It rather looks like liberals, or those who care, are going to have to learn how to be bullies, too. Seems the only way one is heard nowadays is through making threats. Until school board members develop the courage and the ethics to withstand hate group threats, we laid-back liberals may have no choice.