Article image
Jim Hightower
NationofChange / Op-Ed
Published: Thursday 19 July 2012
The Republicans’ political slogan has been to “repeal and replace” Obama's reform, but they’ve dropped the replace part, saying they can’t offer an alternative until they complete the repeal.

Let’s Consider the GOP’s Health Care Plan

Article image

Here's some useful advice from an old country saying: Never try to teach table manners to a pig — it doesn't work, it'll wear you out, and it just annoys the pig.

The same advice goes for anyone who thinks they can teach even a bit of common sense to the preening political ideologues who've taken over the Republican Party and the U.S. House of Representatives. As we've seen in their incessant, pigheaded attacks on the health care reform law, their minds are not merely fogged up with extremist anti-government theories, they're impervious to rational thought.

They failed to defeat Obamacare in 2010, despite trying to scare old people with mindless lies about "death panels." Now they're trying to repeal the law by getting people to swallow their hogwash that it contains "a massive tax hike on the middle class."

Really? No. One, it's not massive; two, it's a payment for direct benefit that people will receive, namely decent health care coverage; three, very few people will have to pay the so-called "tax" at all; and four, many people and small business will get tax credits and federal assistance to offset the cost of coverage.

Their greatest failure, however, is that they offer no alternative to Obamacare. During the debate on their latest attempt to repeal the law, a Democratic lawmaker asked for a copy of the GOP's health care plan so he could read it aloud to other members. Silence in the chamber.

The Republicans' political slogan has been to "repeal and replace" Obama's reform, but they've dropped the replace part, saying they can't offer an alternative until they complete the repeal.

No surprise — I doubt this bunch can walk and chew gun at the same time.

Though they're a tenacious bunch! Maybe not tenacious, more like dogmatic, obstinate and obtuse, too. Pigheaded — yeah, that's it.

So, once again, on July 11, GOP lawmakers threw a group hissy fit on the floor of the House over the Affordable Care Act that Obama and the Democrats passed two years ago — a law the Supreme Court has just recently ruled to be constitutional. The House Repubs hate, hate, hate that law. So, all 244 GOP members pursed their lips in a collective pout and voted in lockstep to outright repeal the blanket-blank ACA. That'll show Obama who's boss, they crowed!

Well, not really, since their "repeal" won't pass the Senate, much less get past the president's veto pen. But these pouty solons are not really interested in legislating — they're into political peacocking, putting on a show for the fans in the far-right-wing bleachers. And apparently it's an interminable farce, for this was the 31st time that they've voted to repeal the law!

Thirty-one replays with the same do-nothing result. Don't they have real work to do? At some point (probably back at about vote number 20 or 25), they crossed over from appearing ideologically steadfast ... to just plain stupid.

They snidely assailed the health care reform as "Obamacare," as though that's a pejorative. But as the law has begun taking affect, more and more Americans are liking it a lot, because it produces real benefits for us. Start with the 30 million people who get help in affording prescription drugs, plus all of us who get some relief from the gouging and constant denial of coverage by monopolistic insurance giants, and Obamacare becomes a label of pride.

If I were him, I'd run on it — and go after the petty politicos who're trying to take away the benefits it provides for people.

Copyright Creators.com


Get Email Alerts from NationofChange
Author pic
ABOUT Jim Hightower
National radio commentator, writer, public speaker, and author of the book, Swim Against The Current: Even A Dead Fish Can Go With The Flow, Jim Hightower has spent three decades battling the Powers That Be on behalf of the Powers That Ought To Be - consumers, working families, environmentalists, small businesses, and just-plain-folks.

Top Stories

24 comments on "Let’s Consider the GOP’s Health Care Plan"

Riconui

July 20, 2012 5:27pm

Insofar as the 1% could give a shit about my financial situation, I am inclined to not give a shit about theirs. willard says that that is "class warfare". He may be right about that but so what? Even if it is, it didn't start with me, it started with mitt and his various ideological cousins beginning with ronald reagan. If re-engineering our tax Schedules to put more demands on the wealth of the 1% is "class warfare", fine! Give it any name you like. If calling the 1% down for their excesses is denigrating "success" as mitt defines it, too f*cking bad. Tax them until they scream. Tax them until they cry like a child. If that's class warfare, so what? Funny, it wasn't thought of as class warfare when the marginal rates were at 91%. It was what you did to make for a better more equitable society and keep the mobs from your front door. The kind of social myopia that guides the wealthy will come to cost them more than just a few points on their taxes if they don't wise up.

Anacortesrealtor

July 21, 2012 2:12pm

When enough sign at http://signon.org/sign/take-money-out-of-politics we will force approval of the necessary Amendment needed to take the only source of power away from the rich and powerful persons and corporations. We can level the playing field in favor of the majority of our people. Talk to any attorney and I believe that because of what our US Supreme Court did citing free speech, the only way to put a stop to the massive financial lobbying is to amend the US Constitution. Please click on or copy and paste into your browser: http://signon.org/sign/take-money-out-of-politics.

Ron in NM

July 19, 2012 10:14pm

I can see we're all pretty much in agreement about Hightower's article. Too bad the visiting Nazis aren't here now. Well, not everyone's crazy about Obamacare, but I still say it's better than nothing, and it's a step in the right direction. I can't quite understand why the roving Republican ideologues seem to hold self-righteous selfishness to be some kind of supreme virtue, but I guess it's just a case of "I've got mine, so screw you, my fellow Americans." Now that we have the volunteer military, the right-wing blowhards (as on Fox News and talk radio) can forget about serving their country and just wave their little flags as they bank their taxed-less incomes. Then they can get on the media soap-box and tell the rest of us how to be "patriotic" according to their definition. They even had the yahoos hating the French for being honest and sensible about that stupid war against Saddam that W never paid for, so he could hand the bill to Obama at the changing of the guard. I was never much of a conspiracy buff, but it sure makes you wonder if cutting taxes, especially for the super-rich, while launching two costly wars wasn't part of some grand design by W to imperil his Democratic successor's first term; maybe even Roberts was vetted to see if he would make a "Citizens United" decision in order to open the floodgates of unnamed and unaccounted millions from the 1% .

I don't believe a word a Republican says these days, and I like to consider myself an independent thinker and voter. It's going to take a long time for the GOP to persuade me they even deserve an audience for their time-wasting attacks on those who work for a salary. Talk is cheap. I look at what happens when Republicans sit in the White House. Their record speaks for itself. Too bad the Fox-News-addicts never get beyond their "big government" rants, and see that the GOP is currently morally bankrupt. They've sold their souls to you-know-who. But they sure know how to throw up a smoke screen, don't they?

Anacortesrealtor

July 21, 2012 2:13pm

When enough sign at http://signon.org/sign/take-money-out-of-politics we will force approval of the necessary Amendment needed to take the only source of power away from the rich and powerful persons and corporations. We can level the playing field in favor of the majority of our people. Talk to any attorney and I believe that because of what our US Supreme Court did citing free speech, the only way to put a stop to the massive financial lobbying is to amend the US Constitution. Please click on or copy and paste into your browser: http://signon.org/sign/take-money-out-of-politics.

Factkneader

July 19, 2012 8:12pm

GopCare is where?
But beware,
It's a snare
For the unaware!

dwdallam

July 19, 2012 2:47pm

The GOP found out a long time ago that if they told the American people what they really wanted to do, they'd never hold office again. Enter GOP politics post 1976.

Anacortesrealtor

July 21, 2012 2:14pm

When enough sign at http://signon.org/sign/take-money-out-of-politics we will force approval of the necessary Amendment needed to take the only source of power away from the rich and powerful persons and corporations. We can level the playing field in favor of the majority of our people. Talk to any attorney and I believe that because of what our US Supreme Court did citing free speech, the only way to put a stop to the massive financial lobbying is to amend the US Constitution. Please click on or copy and paste into your browser: http://signon.org/sign/take-money-out-of-politics.

gduell

July 19, 2012 12:57pm

Having sold health insurance since 1981, and been an investment adviser almost as long, I know that the health care delivery system is far too profitable for far too many people for them to voluntarily let go of it. Capitalism and efficient & effective health care are mutually exclusive.

CKilvington

July 19, 2012 11:54am

It seems to me that, when talking to a Republican, whether the subject is health care, gay marriage, or a myriad of other social issues, their mindset is, "I've got mine; I don't care if you get yours." or perhaps more accurately, since they've voted 31 times to repeal Obamacare, "I've got mine, and I'll make sure you don't get yours."

Anacortesrealtor

July 21, 2012 2:16pm

When enough sign at http://signon.org/sign/take-money-out-of-politics we will force approval of the necessary Amendment needed to take the only source of power away from the rich and powerful persons and corporations. We can level the playing field in favor of the majority of our people. Talk to any attorney and I believe that because of what our US Supreme Court did citing free speech, the only way to put a stop to the massive financial lobbying is to amend the US Constitution. Please click on or copy and paste into your browser: http://signon.org/sign/take-money-out-of-politics.

clefman

July 19, 2012 11:40am

How dare the middle class and the poor seek the health care that members of the new faux-aristocracy enjoys. The privileged few who have been elected to office, which is only their entitlement, deserve better, don't they? If the lower classes can't afford better then that's only natural selection, isn't it?
has this indeed become the GOP mantra? Are they really sending the country into an economic tailspin just to win an election? How do you suppose the average American defines treason? Espousing the violent overthrow of the government would probably rank high in that definition, but allowing the government to fail from within is not only cowardly, and insidious, but it is not the America that our forbears fought and died for and if such decidedly un-american practices are being carried out by men who were sent to Washington to represent us, then perhaps a recall for non-participation is called for. In business, when an employee does not perform to expectation, he is reviewed, admonished, and then if no behavior is evident, is fired. We have seen an adherence to an artificial ideology that has nothing to do with the job to which they were elected. This is misrepresentation, not representative government.

Anacortesrealtor

July 21, 2012 2:19pm

When enough sign at http://signon.org/sign/take-money-out-of-politics we will force approval of the necessary Amendment needed to take the only source of power away from the rich and powerful persons and corporations. We can level the playing field in favor of the majority of our people. Talk to any attorney and I believe that because of what our US Supreme Court did citing free speech, the only way to put a stop to the massive financial lobbying is to amend the US Constitution. Please click on or copy and paste into your browser: http://signon.org/sign/take-money-out-of-politics.

mike morell

July 19, 2012 11:36am

US has the most expensive Health sys in the world but is only 37th in quality. UK, Can, Fra, It, Jap, Nor, Port; even Colombia are ahead.
Canadians are richer than Americans. They have more bank regulations, more socialism, and universal healthcare. Things Repubs keep screeching against. Better keep Obama.
Dumbos 99%ers that eat the hogwash that more tax cuts to the Romney-likes save money and Obamacare will ruin the nation. Forty million get free care now at our expense. Health Plan will take them off our backs. What we’ve got now’s the most expensive and near-worst healthcare in the world.

Anacortesrealtor

July 21, 2012 2:21pm

When enough sign at http://signon.org/sign/take-money-out-of-politics we will force approval of the necessary Amendment needed to take the only source of power away from the rich and powerful persons and corporations. We can level the playing field in favor of the majority of our people. Talk to any attorney and I believe that because of what our US Supreme Court did citing free speech, the only way to put a stop to the massive financial lobbying is to amend the US Constitution. Please click on or copy and paste into your browser: http://signon.org/sign/take-money-out-of-politics.

Jeffrey Hill

July 19, 2012 11:31am

Amygdala-dominant conservatives have NO need for facts or TRUTH because they have a total disdain for them.

Anacortesrealtor

July 21, 2012 2:40pm

I am not absolutely sure, but I think you have coined an ingenious way of describing small cavities filled with deposits of different minerals; e.g., volcanic rock, deposited in the interior extremity of the brain's temporal lobe. Please click on, or copy and paste into your browser - http://signon.org/sign/take-money-out-of-politics.

Ronni85

July 19, 2012 11:03am

The rich bastards - or those trying to impress the rich - are destroying our country. WE, the PEOPLE need to stand up and support our president - maybe he will come around that we need either A) the public option added to his healthcare bill or B) the deletion of 2 words - over 65 - from the medicare bill. WE need healthcare for ALL, not just most, people.

Anacortesrealtor

July 21, 2012 2:42pm

I certainly agree! When enough sign at http://signon.org/sign/take-money-out-of-politics we will force approval of the necessary Amendment needed to take the only source of power away from the rich and powerful persons and corporations. We can level the playing field in favor of the majority of our people. Talk to any attorney and I believe that because of what our US Supreme Court did citing free speech, the only way to put a stop to the massive financial lobbying is to amend the US Constitution. Please click on or copy and paste into your browser: http://signon.org/sign/take-money-out-of-politics.

qsmith

July 19, 2012 10:31am

This is a great, well-written piece that captures the GOP attitudes perfectly and precisely as well as capturing our subsequent frustrations with the party that has fallen off the right wing cliff. A complaint by a woman in another web site who described her conservative family business sounded like a nice reasonable family out of the 70s or 80s - fine. I would not be surprised if somebody in the "GOP" will now accuse them of being 'liberal.' It s happening all the time now.

Anacortesrealtor

July 21, 2012 2:44pm

When enough sign at http://signon.org/sign/take-money-out-of-politics we will force approval of the necessary Amendment needed to take the only source of power away from the rich and powerful persons and corporations. We can level the playing field in favor of the majority of our people. Talk to any attorney and I believe that because of what our US Supreme Court did citing free speech, the only way to put a stop to the massive financial lobbying is to amend the US Constitution. Please click on or copy and paste into your browser: http://signon.org/sign/take-money-out-of-politics.

ChetDude

July 19, 2012 10:25am

EVERY other industrialized nation on Earth has rejected the For-Profit model of Health Care. In fact, only in the U.S. is health care still considered a commodity instead of a human right. As a result, EVERY other industrialized nation on Earth has a healthier population at far lower cost than in here in the U.S.

Isn't it PAST time to examine the rest of the world's successes, craft a Universal, Effective Health Care System that works from their examples and is sustainable and affordable and dump the failed For-Profit Sick Care System that is making us more ill while bankrupting us individually and as a nation?

And we could have it ... with a one page bill that removes the words "over 65", pays for 100% of part A and B and Part D drug coverage and adds the power to seriously negotiate charges and drug prices to the Medicare enabling legislation ALREADY IN PLACE AS THE LAW OF THE LAND!

Improved and Enhanced Medicare for All – already proven efficient, popular and Constitutional!

Anacortesrealtor

July 21, 2012 2:45pm

When enough sign at http://signon.org/sign/take-money-out-of-politics we will force approval of the necessary Amendment needed to take the only source of power away from the rich and powerful persons and corporations. We can level the playing field in favor of the majority of our people. Talk to any attorney and I believe that because of what our US Supreme Court did citing free speech, the only way to put a stop to the massive financial lobbying is to amend the US Constitution. Please click on or copy and paste into your browser: http://signon.org/sign/take-money-out-of-politics.

Norman Allen

July 19, 2012 9:59am

GOP/elite health plan in a nutshell is to go jump in the lake when you get sick but send us your money when you are well. It is easy cash-flow for the elite, and brine/brimstone for the masses. Nothing has been given by the elites voluntarily and what has been given has been tried many times to usurp. Society does not have to be a tug of war between the super haves and the have not. If we can get through to the elite that their meaningless lives of concentrated wealth/power at the expense of everyone can become a lot more pleasant if they learn to become care takers of the society upon which they sit to get whatever they want. Where is pleasure in forced surrender of one's life to a callous overlord?

Anacortesrealtor

July 19, 2012 10:45am

The central and coordinated message should be "PLUTOCRACY NO - DEMOCRACY YES!" And all should sign at: http://signon.org/sign/take-money-out-of-politics. When enough sign we will force approval of the necessary Amendment needed to take the only source of power away from the rich and powerful persons and corporations. We can level the playing field in favor of the majority of our people. We can reinstate government of the people by the people and for the people and put an end to our current government of the people by the lobbyists for the rich and powerful persons and corporations. See - http://signon.org/sign/take-money-out-of-politics. If necessary copy the link and paste it into your browser.