Article image
Chris Hedges
Truthdig / Truthdig Op-Ed
Published: Tuesday 9 October 2012
“We do not speak of war. War is captured only in the long, vacant stares, in the silences, in the trembling fingers, in the memories most of us keep buried deep within us, in the tears.”

The Maimed

Article image

Chris Hedges gave this talk Sunday night in New York City at a protest denouncing the 11th anniversary of the war in Afghanistan. The event, at the Vietnam Veterans Memorial, was led by Veterans for Peace.

Many of us who are here carry within us death. The smell of decayed and bloated corpses. The cries of the wounded. The shrieks of children. The sound of gunfire. The deafening blasts. The fear. The stench of cordite. The humiliation that comes when you surrender to terror and beg for life. The loss of comrades and friends. And then the aftermath. The long alienation. The numbness. The nightmares. The lack of sleep. The inability to connect to all living things, even to those we love the most. The regret. The repugnant lies mouthed around us about honor and heroism and glory. The absurdity. The waste. The futility.

It is only the maimed that finally know war. And we are the maimed. We are the broken and the lame. We ask for forgiveness. We seek redemption. We carry on our backs this awful cross of death, for the essence of war is death, and the weight of it digs into our shoulders and eats away at our souls. We drag it through life, up hills and down hills, along the roads, into the most intimate recesses of our lives. It never leaves us. Those who know us best know that there is something unspeakable and evil many of us harbor within us. This evil is intimate. It is personal. We do not speak its name. It is the evil of things done and things left undone. It is the evil of war.

We do not speak of war. War is captured only in the long, vacant stares, in the silences, in the trembling fingers, in the memories most of us keep buried deep within us, in the tears.

It is impossible to portray war. Narratives, even anti-war narratives, make the irrational rational. They make the incomprehensible comprehensible. They make the illogical logical. They make the despicable beautiful. All words and images, all discussions, all films, all evocations of war, good or bad, are an obscenity. There is nothing to say. There are only the scars and wounds. These we carry within us. These we cannot articulate. The horror. The horror.

War gives to its killers a God-like power to take life. And there are those here tonight that have felt and exercised that power. They turned other human beings into objects. And in that process of killing they became objects, machines, instruments of death, war’s victimizers and war’s victims. And they do not want to be machines again.

We wander through life with the deadness of war within us. There is no escape. There is no peace. We know an awful truth, an existential truth. War exposed the lies of patriotism and collective virtue of the nation that our churches, our schools, our press, our movies, our books, our government told us about ourselves, about who we were. And we see through these illusions. But those who speak this truth are cast out. Ghosts. Strangers in a strange land.

Who are our brothers and sisters? Who is our family? Whom have we become? We have become those whom we once despised and killed. We have become the enemy. Our mother is the mother grieving over her murdered child, and we murdered this child, in a mud-walled village of Afghanistan or a sand-filled cemetery in Fallujah. Our father is the father lying on a pallet in a hut, paralyzed by the blast from an iron fragmentation bomb. Our sister lives in poverty in a refugee camp outside Kabul, widowed, desperately poor, raising her children alone. Our brother, yes, our brother, is in the Taliban and the Iraqi insurgency and al-Qaida. And he has an automatic rifle. And he kills. And he is becoming us. War is always the same plague. It imparts the same deadly virus. It teaches us to deny another’s humanity, worth, being, and to kill and be killed.

There are days we wish we were whole. We wish we could put down this cross. We envy those who, in their innocence, believe in the innate goodness of America and the righteousness of war and celebrate what we know is despicable. And sometimes it makes us wish for death, for the peace of it. But we know too the awful truth, as James Baldwin wrote, that “people who shut their eyes to reality simply invite their own destruction, and anyone who insists on remaining in a state of innocence long after that innocence is dead turns himself into a monster.” And we would rather be maimed and broken and in pain than be a monster, and some of us, once, were monsters.

I cannot heal you. You will never be healed. I cannot take away your wounds, visible and invisible. I cannot promise that it will be better. I cannot impart to you the cheerful and childish optimism that is the curse of America. I can only tell you to stand up, to pick up your cross, to keep moving. I can only tell you that you must always defy the forces that eat away at you, at the nation—this plague of war.Sometimes I feel like a motherless child

Towering about us are banks and other financial institutions that profit from war. War, for some, is a business. And across this country lies a labyrinth of military industries that produce nothing but instruments of death. And some of us once served these forces. It is death we defy, not our own death, but the vast enterprise of death. The dark, primeval lusts for power and personal wealth, the hypermasculine language of war and patriotism, are used to justify the slaughter of the weak and the innocent and mock justice. ... And we will not use these words of war.

We cannot flee from evil. Some of us have tried through drink and drugs and self-destructiveness. Evil is always with us. It is because we know evil, our own evil, that we do not let go, do not surrender. It is because we know evil that we resist. It is because we know violence that we are nonviolent. And we know that it is not about us; war taught us that. It is about the other, lying by the side of the road. It is about reaching down in defiance of creeds and oaths, in defiance of religion and nationality, and lifting our enemy up. All acts of healing and love—and the defiance of war is an affirmation of love—allow us to shout out to the vast powers of the universe that, however broken we are, we are not yet helpless, however much we despair we are not yet without hope, however weak we may feel, we will always, always, always resist. And it is in this act of resistance that we find our salvation.

This article was originally posted on Truthdig.



Get Email Alerts from NationofChange
Author pic
ABOUT Chris Hedges
Chris Hedges is a weekly Truthdig columnist and a fellow at The Nation Institute. His newest book is “The World As It Is: Dispatches on the Myth of Human Progress.”

Top Stories

9 comments on "The Maimed"

Diesixdie

October 10, 2012 8:36pm

Well thanks, Mr. Hedges. You had me in tears in the middle of a pizza restaurant. Well done.

Unconditional1

October 10, 2012 8:58am

Karma IS, as karma does. Shoot the Universe and the Universe shoots back. It is all about cause-and-effect. Humans, with massive, insatiable egos, always must show how big, powerful, and important they are to the rest of the Universe!

Co-creating with free will, does not sanction wonton destruction against the rest of the Cosmos. It does however, guarantee accountability to every expression that co-creates such infantile free-will choices.

wildthang

October 09, 2012 5:21pm

There you have it... we create monsters like Saddam against Iran, and Noriega and the freedom fighters of Afghanistan against the Soviets and then turn around and call them monsters to be taken out like a CIA cleanup operation. So what of making ourselves into monsters? What of glorifying taking the gloves off? What if it does the same to all of us who are urged to worship war as glory and as humanitarian aid? What if the buddhists are right and everyone has been our mother, father, sister, or brother or lovers or child in some other lifetime? What if we are to be reborn in Iraq or Russia or China? Or Native Americans or....

emmanuel williams

October 09, 2012 2:26pm

Sanctuary

Whatever remains
of the soldiers who died in war
of the soldiers who killed them
be it with hands or with arrow or gun or whatever came next

whatever is left
when their blood pulses no more
when the grieving is done
and their bodies are stripped to the bone

whatever is left
be it horror or pain
be it triumph or numbness or shame

May they find sanctuary
here among redwoods and mist
here in a silence too deep to be heard
lest they have nowhere to go
nowhere to rest as the screaming subsides
and the thunder of guns
nowhere to release
all that was done to them
all that they did
all that they know
of the meaning of victory
all that they know
of our species.

May this be their home
for as long as they need.
Here among trees
where the soil is clean of our deeds
may they find peace.

Emmanuel Williams

tabitha

October 09, 2012 7:12pm

This is very sad and very moving. Unfortunately we never learn from our mistakes and wars will never end. Romney will increase Defence spending with another trillion dollars even though it has not been asked for. This is a man who has never gone to war and none of his five sons ever ventured from the safety of their comfortable lives, and yet would have no trouble at all sending other people's children to go and die. All his speeches are tinged with aggression, not peace. He calls himself a Christian, was once a missionary. Well, his actions and behavior and policies - as vague as the are - do not portray kindness, compassion and Christian values. Giving large sums of money to charities does not a christian make.
During the 2008 debate when Obama said he would sit with all the enemies of America and try to broker peace between the nations, McCain mocked him by asking if he was also going to have tea with them as well? This is a man who has known war and suffering and yet is as hard as they come. Peace loving people just don't understand and never will. What a wonderful world God created for us and how wonderful it would be if we could all co-exist in peace. The amount of money wasted on wars and weapons that kill is beyond comprehension. Have Republicans forgotten that they once sent weapons to a group of thugs in Afghanistan who later turned these same weapons on America? Osama Ben Laden was once a friend. Have they forgotten the thousands of body bags that came home from Iraq, followed by the thousands on 9/11? I guess they have and it is my prediction that Romney, IF elected (HE WILL NOT) would impose another war, not only on America but on the world by helping Netanyahu. God help us all. These two are so much alike. What I don't get is why anyone with even half a brain would think of voting for this man.

woetopoe

October 09, 2012 11:11am

This is a moving and eloquent speech that unfortunately will do nothing to alter the basically flawed mindset of man. We simply are, by nature, an inherently debauched species that has not evolved in the numbers necessary to change the inevitable trajectory of murder and mayhem we have perpetrated for millenia.
Just for a working example, take a copy of this humanistic and heartfelt speech to a meeting of ANY American Legion Post or Veterans of Foreign Wars location. Get up and read it to the veterans present and take careful notice of the reaction you obtain. Also, the next time Romney or Ryan, neither one of them Vets, speaks to a crowd, take note of the "ballcaps" with various ship names or military affiliations, enthusiastically clapping the "hawkish rhetoric." Dick Cheney, who obtained five deferments during the Vietnam War, because he claimed to have "other priorities," would get standing ovations EVERY time he spoke to a veterans group. Veterans vote for the Republicans by vast margins in every major election. The "predator" recognizes its own kind. We are a primitive, war-like species that would still be sharpening spears and chasing animals for dinner (when not slaughtering one another) if not for the inventions of a mere handful of more intellectually advanced human beings. Take a look at world events today. Things are not changing and we will have environmentally destroyed ourselves and our planet long before they would have had the opportunity to evolve differently. Obviously, there are a number of vets who do not fit my portraiture. To you I can only tell you thanks and wish you peace. This was a helluva speech however...if only the masses would actually listen.

lizziemaef

October 09, 2012 11:03am

Thanks for a powerful piece, Chris, that captures the unfathomable destruction caused by war - physical, mental, emotional, spiritual. I wish all Americans would read this so that when a presidential candidate says he would wield America's military might more aggressively they would boo instead of cheer. The problem is that too many people - and not only in the US - believe in the simplistic idea that war and aggression are actually capable of solving problems.

Mary Muir

October 09, 2012 11:34am

During another of our many wars, Viet Nam, there was a a saying: "Suppose they gave a war and nobody came." That would help these days, ya think?

Trish House's picture
Trish House

October 09, 2012 9:58am

The lifting up and the healing must be as personal and as fought for as the wars that brought this great sadness upon us. We must lift people up by working together to insist and demand that each person has a right to a share of the land and the resources we need to make ourselves self sustaining. Then we must help each other to live that new way.

We must end the hoarding of these things that give power and control over our lives to those that are best at collecting things and who then insist that we pay them for the use of them again. We pay with jobs; war jobs, insurance jobs, banking jobs, government jobs... All these make us meek and dependent on the charity & good opinion of our bosses. So we allow the wars so we can pay our rent, we allow the lobbyists to buy our votes, we allow the bankers to sell our land and we allow corporations to hoard the things that we need to live our lives and make us pay them far too much for.

Give all men land, give them the tools for their survival & you will find a different world; a world in which men say NO when invited to fight in wars in exchange for their food and shelter, a world in which men say NO when invited to drill oil from our gulfs, a world in which men say NO when coerced by lobbyists to sell our souls for exploitive corporation's profits.

If we must fight, let us fight for power in the hands of every man and woman in America, let's fight for the freedom to live without the corruption and greed of corporations driving our every thought and deed. Let's fight for the care and comfort of every single one of us so there is no homelessness, no hunger, no one choosing whether to die from cold, starvation, or lack of medicine. If we fight our own demons that keep us from cooperating and sharing, and our demons that demand the American Dream as our right (no matter what the cost to people on other lands), and we fight more fiercely for peace and comfort for every one of us we can, together, reverse the debt we owe for our acts that have caused so much harm.