Article image
Robert Scheer
Truthdig / Truthdig Op-Ed
Published: Saturday 20 October 2012
Hubbard is the ideological hit man instrumental in justifying the mortgage derivatives bubble that caused the Great Recession during the George W. Bush years.

Meet Romney’s Economic Hit Man

Article image

Mark the name of R. Glenn Hubbard, the man who will make your life miserable if Mitt Romney is elected president. Unless, that is, you happen to be one of the swindlers who has profited mightily from the nation’s economic pain. 

Hubbard is the ideological hit man instrumental in justifying the mortgage derivatives bubble that caused the Great Recession during the George W. Bush years. He now serves as Romney’s key economic adviser and is the front-runner to be the next Treasury secretary should the Republican win.

“Romney’s Go-To Economist” read the headline on a New York Times profile of the dean of Columbia University’s Business School, which notes that “During a stint as chairman of the Council of Economic Advisers for President George W. Bush, from 2001 to 2003, Mr. Hubbard was known as the principal architect of the Bush tax cuts.” In that capacity, and after returning to Columbia, Hubbard was also the chief cheerleader for a runaway derivatives market that spiraled out of control and left the Great Recession in its wake.

While pocketing millions in fees from the financial industry that he was ostensibly studying as a neutral academic, Hubbard was an enthusiastic backer of the virtues of a burgeoning unregulated capital market that sold toxic derivatives to the world. In a landmark paper that he co-wrote in November 2004 with William C. Dudley, at the time the chief U.S. economist at Goldman Sachs, it was asserted, “The capital markets have helped facilitate a major transformation of the U.S. mortgage financing system over the past 25 years. … The result has been a dramatic decline in the cyclical volatility of housing activity.” 

Their study was published by the Global Markets Institute of Goldman Sachs at the very time that Goldman, a leader in the capital market, was packaging and selling some of the toxic mortgage-based derivatives that would come close to destroying the world’s economy.

Hubbard’s article celebrated this “revolution in housing finance (that) has led to a large increase in mortgage equity withdrawal.” It extolled the madcap equity lending as “one reason why consumer spending held up well during the 2001-2003 period, even as employment and investment spending faltered.” 

That’s the housing bubble that was destined to pop and left the Bush and Obama administrations running up huge deficits to contain the damage. Hubbard’s co-author knows this well, for Dudley left Goldman in 2007 to work for Timothy Geithner, then the head of the New York Fed that led the charge to rescue Goldman and other banks in the aftermath of the crisis they caused. As evidence of the bipartisan spirit informing the banking bailout, when Geithner was appointed Obama’s Treasury secretary, Dudley replaced him as president of the New York Fed.

But this is a crisis first enabled by the Bush administration’s policy of mindlessly celebrating the mortgage industry’s wild irresponsibility. As Hubbard and Dudley bragged: “The revolution in mortgage finance has increased the ability of households to purchase their own homes. The closing costs associated with obtaining a residential mortgage have fallen, and the terms (for example, the loan-to-value ratio) have become less stringent. At times homeowners can obtain 100 percent financing to purchase a home.” 

This is the mortgage bankers’ equivalent of “The Anarchist Cookbook”—a recipe for disaster. The 100 percent loan meant that the homeowner was not at risk, nor was the investment firm that initiated the mortgage because it packaged it, along with other irresponsible loans, into securities sold to unwitting buyers.

In the paper published by Goldman, the authors take issue with Warren Buffett who as early as 2002 had warned that these “derivatives are financial weapons of mass destruction, carrying dangers that, while now latent, are potentially lethal.” Buffett argued that ” … huge–scale frauds and near frauds have been facilitated by derivatives trades.” 

Not so, said Hubbard and Dudley, siding with then-Fed Chairman Alan Greenspan. “This use of derivatives leads to improved economic performance,” they wrote, insisting, “The capital markets have also acted to reduce the volatility of the economy. Recessions are less frequent and milder when they occur.”

Hubbard, who testified as an expert witness on behalf of two Bear Stearns hedge fund managers in an investment fraud case, is a frequent recipient of financial industry largess in the form of consulting and research fees. Last year, he was paid $785,000 for serving on three corporate boards and has been handsomely rewarded as a consultant to Freddie Mac, Bank of America, JPMorgan Chase and Goldman Sachs. He was paid $420,000 for supporting Fidelity in just one court case.

In the second presidential debate, Romney sought to distance himself from the Bush administration, ever so slightly. But it is Hubbard, a prime architect of the Bush strategy of unfettering Wall Street greed, to whom the Republican nominee turned to co-write “The Romney Program for Economic Recovery, Growth and Jobs.”

That plan not only extends the Bush tax cuts for the super rich, but it would repeal the mild Dodd-Frank legislation holding Wall Street a bit more accountable. If Romney wins, it will be Bush reincarnated, and Hubbard’s ideology, a proven failure, will prevail.

This article was originally posted on Truthdig.



Get Email Alerts from NationofChange
Author pic
ABOUT Robert Scheer
Robert Scheer, editor in chief of Truthdig, has built a reputation for strong social and political writing over his 30 years as a journalist. His columns appear in newspapers across the country, and his in-depth interviews have made headlines. He conducted the famous Playboy magazine interview in which Jimmy Carter confessed to the lust in his heart and he went on to do many interviews for the Los Angeles Times with Richard Nixon, Ronald Reagan, Bill Clinton and many other prominent political and cultural figures.

Top Stories

5 comments on "Meet Romney’s Economic Hit Man"

Richard Avard

October 21, 2012 7:46am

Pull all your cash out of all the banks Buy real gold or silver If you own real estate, pay it off or dump it for what you can get out of it, Have an escape plan to a safe area of US like wyoming where they planning to have their own currency, or to Texas where they are talking seccession again, Get out of all big Metro area Buy a gun or two and lots os ammo
Or leave the country like me if you can get a visa to safe areas like Scandinavia They like white people up there

richarda_ga

October 21, 2012 5:45am

Just when I thought things couldn't get any worse than having a financial industry apologist shill & stooge like Geithner as Secretary of the Treasury.

Ron in NM

October 20, 2012 10:26pm

Well, it's nice to know who we can thank for the real estate bubble. And isn't it great that he's Romney's economic adviser? (The Republicans, however, never tire of blaming Democrats for the bubble and the consequences that followed.)

And Mitt's trying to tell the voting public that he's different from Bush and won't follow the same economic policies?

Yeah, he's got a "5-point plan," in his dreams.

I suppose most people have seen this already, but if not, you can get a good belly laugh out of a video you can find on You Tube. Just Google "Mitt Romney Style gangnam." Even Ann and Paul Ryan are in there. Just a college parody, but I think it nails the character of the Mitt. Check it out!

(But if you're kind of prudish, maybe you shouldn't.)

clefman

October 20, 2012 9:43pm

When Hubbard was named as the principal architect, the article might well have read "unprincipled principal architect".

I believe this trend went back to when it was clear that Bush and his Forty Thieves were on the outgoing tide, they chose to stick Obama with as big a mess as they could muster. There is no such thing as Economic Treason but there should be-using the powers of Wall Street to hurt America from within. I'm sure we can all think of a few names that might well appear on that list including a current national candidate who held a clandestine meeting for a similar purpose.

greghilbert

October 20, 2012 10:49am

I observe there is no mainstream-media frenzy or public outcry over this prime example of the greed-driven corruption of our economy, government, political parties, media and society by a wealthy few and their phalanx of elites.

Spare me the obvious, that such is concentrated among Republican leaders and that Romney would champion more of the same.

Neither was there a media frenzy or public outcry when Obama appointed Geithner his Treasury Secretary, and paid his respects to the bankster CEOs who paid themselves millions in bonuses with taxpayer-funded bailout money. All that and more AFTER those same banksters cost millions of Americans their jobs, homes, and savings.

I'm saying the corruption of America is more pervasive than this article implies.