Occupy Wall Street and the Pope Agree: It’s Time to Tax Speculators
The Catholic Church has for many years raised objections to the patterns of globalization, concentration of wealth and economic equality that have encouraged the massive redistribution of wealth upward that has made the rich richer, the poor poorer and the middle class more vulnerable than at any time in generations.
And, now, as the Occupy Wall Street movement raises the issue of economic inequality, the church is stepping up with a proposal to begin to address the extreme injustice of a system that taxes working people for necessities but allows speculators to avoid even the most basic responsibilities.
On the eve of the G-20 leaders, the Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace has endorsed a series of reforms to the global economic financial and monetary systems that features as its centerpiece the development of a financial transactions tax.
From the note on financial reform from the Pontifical Council:
Specific attention should be paid to the reform of the international monetary system and, in particular, the commitment to create some form of global monetary management, something that is already implicit in the Statutes of the International Monetary Fund. It is obvious that to some extent this is equivalent to putting the existing exchange systems up for discussion in order to find effective means of coordination and supervision. This process must also involve the emerging and developing countries in defining the stages of a gradual adaptation of the existing instruments.In fact, one can see an emerging requirement for a body that will carry out the functions of a kind of “central world bank” that regulates the flow and system of monetary exchanges similar to the national central banks. The underlying logic of peace, coordination and common vision which led to the Bretton Woods Agreements needs to be dusted off in order to provide adequate answers to the current questions. On the regional level, this process could begin by strengthening the existing institutions, such as the European Central Bank. However, this would require not only a reflection on the economic and financial level, but also and first of all on the political level, so as to create the set of public institutions that will guarantee the unity and consistency of the common decisions.
These measures ought to be conceived of as some of the first steps in view of a public Authority with universal jurisdiction; as a first stage in a longer effort by the global community to steer its institutions towards achieving the common good. Other stages will have to follow in which the dynamics familiar to us may become more marked, but they may also be accompanied by changes which would be useless to try to predict today. In this process, the primacy of the spiritual and of ethics needs to be restored and, with them, the primacy of politics—which is responsible for the common good—over the economy and finance. These latter need to be brought back within the boundaries of their real vocation and function, including their social function, in consideration of their obvious responsibilities to society, in order to nourish markets and financial institutions which are really at the service of the person, which are capable of responding to the needs of the common good and universal brotherhood, and which transcend all forms of economist stagnation and performative mercantilism.
On the basis of this sort of ethical approach, it seems advisable to reflect, for example, on: a) taxation measures on financial transactions through fair but modulated rates with charges proportionate to the complexity of the operations, especially those made on the “secondary” market. Such taxation would be very useful in promoting global development and sustainability according to the principles of social justice and solidarity. It could also contribute to the creation of a world reserve fund to support the economies of the countries hit by crisis as well as the recovery of their monetary and financial system…
The G-20 gathering in Cannes November 3 and 4 is expected to discuss a financial speculation tax, with strong encouragement from French President Nicolas Sarkozy and German Chancellor Angela Merkel—whosays, “We must ensure that financial market actors share in the costs of fighting the crisis. I will push for this until it happens, at least in Europe, even better worldwide.
Sarkozy and Merkel have work to do; there is opposition within the G-20 even to an exceptionally modest 0.1-percent speculation tax. That opposition is coming from the United States and Canada, in particular. But there will also be pressure for the tax from outside the G-20, as unions from around the world rally at Cannes to agitate for the proposal.
The culture-jammers at Adbusters, who issued the “Occupy Wall Street” call, are calling on activists worldwide to rally October 29 for a “Robin Hood Tax” on all financial transactions and currency trades.National People’s Action (NPA), which refers to the financial transactions tax as a “take from the rich and give to the poor” initiative, is urging Americans to join October 29 rallies to “Rise Up and Fight for the Robin Hood Tax.”
Arguing that “Wall Street and Big Banks must pay their share for our economic recovery,” NPA says that a financial speculation tax “would tax short term and often speculative activity—the sort of thing that helped create the crisis—and generate billions of dollars of revenue. For ordinary investors, the cost would barely be noticeable, but for Wall Street traders’ activities, it is estimated that such a tax could generate up to $150 billion a year.”
US unions, especially National Nurses United (NNU), are in the thick of the initiative. NNU has been working closely with international unions to encourage global campaigning on behalf of the tax. But it is also working domestically to promote a US version
On Thursday, Congressman Peter DeFazio, D-Oregon, and US Senator Tom Harkin, D-Iowa, both long-time supporters of taxes on speculators, will introduce legislation that would impose a modest tax—less than the 0.1-percent tax proposed in Europe—on financial transactions. The Harkin-DeFazio proposal, though small in scope and narrowly focused on specific types of transactions, would raise tens of billions of dollars that could be used to address budget shortfalls and domestic needs.
The Harkin-DeFazio plan would, as well, place a bit of the tax burden on those most able to pay.
“This is an absolutely essential step to address the 99 percent problem,” said Damon Silvers, director of policy at the AFL-CIO, referring to the Occupy Wall Street claim that the movement represents the 99 percent of Americans whose economic prospects are limited by the 1 percent who control most of the nation’s wealth.
“The financial sector in the United States and worldwide is profoundly undertaxed,” Silvers said. “Inherently, any tax on the financial system is a progressive tax.”
The linkage between the Occupy Wall Street agitation and the push for a financial transactions tax is being made by several groups that were early and enthusiastic supporters of the protest movement.
National Nurses United, which has launched a “Tax Wall Street” campaign, will rally on the doorstep of the US Treasury Department November 3, calling on Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner and the Obama administration “to end lobbying efforts at home and abroad against a Wall Street tax.”
“It is long past time for Secretary Geithner and President Obama to get on board with other world leaders in supporting this common sense approach to raise badly needed revenues to help fund the critical programs we need to revive the US and other global economies,” says NNU executive director RoseAnn DeMoro.
Along with the NNU; the AFL-CIO; the Service Employees union; the Amertican Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees; the National Education Association; Demos; Rebuild the Dream; National Peoples Action; and Americans for Financial Reform are signing on with BanksterUSA’s petition to members of Congress with a simple message:
The deficit issue that we face today was in large part created by the world financial crisis, a crisis caused by Wall Street speculation. Now it’s time to call upon Wall Street to start paying its fair share to help us out of the hole they dug.
A small tax on financial market transactions has the potential to raise significant revenue and simultaneously limit reckless short-term speculation that can threaten financial stability. We are writing to ask you to support such a tax, and to request that it be part of any new budget plan.
Financial transaction taxes have a long track record both in the United States and globally. The United States had a transfer tax from 1914 to 1966. The UK levies a transaction tax on stock transfers and has done so for many years. The European Union is on the verge of approving a small transaction tax, including ten cents per $100 on stock transactions. The tiny transaction tax they are working on is estimated to raise over $70 billion annually. A similar transaction tax in the United States would raise even more money, as our financial markets are larger.
We join over 1,000 economists who recently signed an open letter advocating a financial speculation tax as “tethnically feasible” and “morally right.”
Technically feasible.
Morally right.
And necessary if we are ever going to get serious about raising the revenues that are needed—from the people who need to pay.
Copyright © The Nation – distributed by Agence Global.
CONNECT















20 comments on "Occupy Wall Street and the Pope Agree: It’s Time to Tax Speculators"
nvonct
VWNW3l tegfxtyhcwxd
g68lqL dbazkclpnbpr
I wanted to spend a mitnue to thank you for this.
October 28, 2011 3:50pm
Does anyone love and trust GOD enough to go to the pope and ask him if he is a being of light that support's GOD'S divine plan? And if he refuses to answer or changes the subject or says something silly, you must tell him; he must leave. Then walk away. Come out of her. I would, but too poor. And clearly it isn't my job but falls to one of his brothers or sistas. (In church)
October 28, 2011 3:45pm
Yes, why don't they pay taxes? After all their priority is their treasures they don't give their people. Or ours. It's stealing from our gov. that only goes to their people and any kind of work they can force the sistas to do. That's IMMORAL. In GOD'S eyes....He warned them of that sort of thing before. Does the pope not read the bible? After all, it's the same as my King James, but has a few more books which they really ignore anyway. Remember Judith, pope?
October 28, 2011 7:48am
That's all well and good but it's all just LIP SERVICE! OCCUPY THE VATICAN! Would he redistribute the wealth of the tax sheltered church that does absolutely nothing for most of the people I know including me...
October 28, 2011 3:09am
Yes, tax all transactions, the shorts , derivatives(that are out of control and not taxed). Reinstitute the Glass Stegall Act of 1933 which was a set of reforms responsible for the longest crisis free period in U.S. financial history. Its repeal was a deregulation that was lobbyed for by banking and wall street, they said that it "would bring greater stability and competitiveness to the financial services industry". This deregulation is what brought us the bailouts and subsidies and a debt to be paid back by taxpayers.
I also think the tax exemptions of the churches need to go, the mega churches seem to have a political ear and voice, thus this status of tax exemption should go.
October 28, 2011 2:21am
This is actually a very good idea and should be promoted. Why not include the Vatican in the movement? We need all the help we can get to make changes in the system!
October 27, 2011 4:46pm
For years I have said Tax the Churches too, they are wealthy beyond belief. Lets all share the burden His Holiness... You've been sucking the money from the poor for 1000's of years, now it's your turn to kick in.
October 28, 2011 7:50am
Hello! Occupy the Vatican!!
October 27, 2011 4:42pm
Are you kidding me? Have you ever been to the Vatican and seen the opulence there? People in gold encrusted houses should watch where they throw stones. Which is not to say that I disagree with his statement.
October 27, 2011 2:38pm
Every man, every human being has feet of clay. His is but another single voice that joins to our choir. I welcome the harmony.
We, the people are the song here on this our piece of dirt.
The challenge is how sweet & true is our melody? Hum along; find out if you can dance to it.
October 27, 2011 12:24pm
Bull. Irredentistry is just another ploy, and the white pope might as well be the black one. If the pyramid is broken, perhaps evolution has something instead to replace with at the base, like learning. Consider Lynn Margulis as a start. Also, and unfortunately, the term Al Qaeda means the base, and it was orignated to indicate the software used to launder drug money, requiring the sophistication of a good 2nd grader to make the AI work. Now, there are some first rate irredentists, the ones who 'inspired' www.RememberBuilding7.org, or Indira Singh.
October 27, 2011 12:12pm
The holier than thou position of the Catholic Church is bit ironic because it is one of the largest property owners in the world. Maybe the religious orders should practice what they preach and surrender more of their wealth to support the poor.
October 27, 2011 1:47pm
The catholic church is mainly holding cultural treasures that it has passed on through many generations, and will continue to do so. There is nothing "speculative" about that procedure and they will not have to pay a speculation tax on it.
October 27, 2011 11:47am
Yes Tax speculators Limit / end credit default swaps ...derivatives and
unethical practices which are many Jail those banksters who broke the law
Fine them in the billions so they stop
October 27, 2011 11:36am
A dream at best. The Wall Street speculators have no concern whatsoever for the welfare of mankind. They seek only to enrich themselves at the expense of other. They have purchased ivory towers on which they now perch, living in terror that they may fall and not be seen as the gods they perceive themselves to be. They will lie, steal, cheat and murder - mass murder if necessary - to keep from being recognized as the filthy cowering sewage they actually are. Each would gleefully burn the eyes out of an infant with a soldering iron if it would get them an extra stripe on their golf cart. They are the most despicible collection of human excrement the planet has ever witnessed. Wall Street Speculators: the shit of human society.
October 27, 2011 11:49am
Thats exactly why we must have more not less regulations and safe guards to reign in corp greed Deregulation since 1981 has failed miserably as has our many anti US trade policies..
October 27, 2011 11:31am
What about the con artists: the religious institutions, the offshore squirrels, the Swiss bank account thieves, and those who manipulated the system to their advantage for a long, long time? Would His Holiness (whose predecessor included the Borgias) agree with taxing the con artists?