The Opposite of Snobbery
Say what you will about this era's Republican presidential candidates; they at least have chutzpah.
Millionaire blue-blood George W. Bush pretended to be a down-home cowboy. Two-time divorcee and longtime Washington influence peddler Newt Gingrich struts around preaching about traditional family values and insisting he's a D.C. outsider. Now, topping them all is Rick Santorum, who last week declared that only "snobs" support efforts to make a college education more accessible to all Americans.
Santorum, of course, has not one, not two, but a whopping three separate degrees, two of which come from public universities — that is, two that were taxpayer-subsidized, courtesy of the "Big Government" Santorum now claims to loathe.
Hypocritical — and dare I say, snobbish — as it is for someone with such a pedigree to attack President Barack Obama's college affordability initiatives, Santorum did inadvertently stumble into a significant question: Is higher education for everyone? The answer today is "not necessarily," but that's precisely because of the affordability problem Obama aims to solve.
N+1 magazine notes that since the late 1970s, when Santorum was enjoying his taxpayer-subsidized higher education, "the price of tuition at U.S. colleges has increased over 900 percent." In 2011, that meant the average total cost of a year at a public university was $21,477, up 5.4 percent in just 12 months. Thanks to cuts to programs that make college and vocational education more affordable — cuts Santorum supported in Congress — those tuition increases promise to get even steeper in the coming years, all but ensuring that a future college student will have even more than the $25,250 in education debt that today's average student carries.
With higher education this unaffordable but with most decent-paying jobs in our economy still requiring a degree, the trends have created another bubble scenario.
Those lucky enough to get a job out of school can barely pay back their now-massive loans, and those left jobless in the recession can't pay back their loans at all, leaving us facing the potential of mass defaults and yet another financial meltdown.
Not surprisingly, this frightening situation has initiated a debate over whether college remains a good investment. Most of the data say that on average it still is — that the money typically spent on higher education is made back in comparatively higher wages during a career. However, that data is less clear than it once was, and that typical experience is no longer such a guarantee. Indeed, there are more and more situations where college might not be such a solid financial investment — not because it's wrong for a particular student's interests, but because the economics of tuition prices and the anemic job market make it too risky a gamble.
Those economics are an obvious symptom of a larger crisis involving all sorts of cuts: revenue-draining tax cuts, cuts to education budgets and cuts to public programs that sustain decent jobs. But because any critical discussion of those policies offends the GOP's corporate financiers, Santorum is trying to define the crisis on unrelated, culture-war terms. He would have us believe the emergency is about "snobbery" from Democrats arrogantly pressuring Americans to get degrees. In this, he gets a two-fer: He can both avoid tough issues and pander to the anti-intellectual, anti-elitist sensibilities of Republican primary voters.
As the facts prove, though, the real crisis is about a conservative economic agenda whose anti-government extremism is making the path to a degree and a decent job even tougher than it naturally is during tough times.
Trying to make that path just a tad easier — like it was when Santorum got his three degrees — isn't snobbery. It's the opposite.
Those lucky enough to get a job out of school can barely pay back their now-massive loans, and those left jobless in the recession can't pay back their loans at all, leaving us facing the potential of mass defaults and yet another financial meltdown.
Not surprisingly, this frightening situation has initiated a debate over whether college remains a good investment. Most of the data say that on average it still is — that the money typically spent on higher education is made back in comparatively higher wages during a career. However, that data is less clear than it once was, and that typical experience is no longer such a guarantee. Indeed, there are more and more situations where college might not be such a solid financial investment — not because it's wrong for a particular student's interests, but because the economics of tuition prices and the anemic job market make it too risky a gamble.
Those economics are an obvious symptom of a larger crisis involving all sorts of cuts: revenue-draining tax cuts, cuts to education budgets and cuts to public programs that sustain decent jobs. But because any critical discussion of those policies offends the GOP's corporate financiers, Santorum is trying to define the crisis on unrelated, culture-war terms. He would have us believe the emergency is about "snobbery" from Democrats arrogantly pressuring Americans to get degrees. In this, he gets a two-fer: He can both avoid tough issues and pander to the anti-intellectual, anti-elitist sensibilities of Republican primary voters.
As the facts prove, though, the real crisis is about a conservative economic agenda whose anti-government extremism is making the path to a degree and a decent job even tougher than it naturally is during tough times.
Trying to make that path just a tad easier — like it was when Santorum got his three degrees — isn't snobbery. It's the opposite.
CONNECT













10 comments on "The Opposite of Snobbery"
March 06, 2012 3:40pm
As an educator I find it insulting to be called a snob because I happen to believe in education and have dedicated my whole life to the pursuit of knowledge.
Santorum misses the point of education, it is not to guarantee anyone a job, but a way to become a life time learner who delights in staying open minded, tolerant, mindful, and most of all reverent to what an education can do for a person.
This is how I see it. The less Americans with higher education the easier it will be for people like Santrom and a like to keep people down. They are scared that once we the people are educated and can see through the nonsense, we will demand change and that is something they are afraid of.
March 04, 2012 4:32pm
Subsidising a college education is more that snobbery, it's an attempt to freeze an obsolete, elitist business model in place. Colleges haven't produced more productive people in general for years. The higher income of college grads is largely a function of professional licensing where the licenses require a college eduction, the selection effect where people capable of gaining a degree have a higher ability to earn regardless of whether they attend college, the fact that graduates are usually the children of high income earners and often better connected and other effects. If you have people not being able to pay back their student loans then obviously college isn't that great and investment, even subsidized. That's the biggest thing that caused the Occupy movement, college kids who realised they'd blown daddy's dough and felt owed.
March 04, 2012 4:20pm
We need Tax Reform more than anything in order to bring our great country back to Greatness. "Tax Em Like 1938", is my motto and battle cry. In 1938 we had 33 tax brackets to cover all classes of income. These brackets ranged from 4% for all income up to $64,000. (adjusted for inflation) all the way to 79% for income over $79,000,000. "Tax Em Like 1938". God Bless the 99%.
March 04, 2012 2:54pm
As usual, the GOP wants government big enough to give THEM what THEY want - and put the screws to everyone else that wants exactly the same for themselves. WE need people in our legislatures that are for US. Those that believe this nation should do well and be prosperous for the 99%.
Guess what? It ain't the GOP that will do that for WE, the People.
March 04, 2012 3:11pm
we need to vote out all politicians that dont bilieve in a government for the people by the people and one thing for sure is we need all money taken out of government that means fat checks free health care and most importantly hand-outs(bribes) to elected men and women so that maybe if their salary was only what an average american worker and had no free health care or any extra money maybe just maybe they would work for the 100%
March 04, 2012 2:33pm
The repugnicans don't want more people getting educated, they want to sit fat and happy with their fancy degrees and close all affordable avenues behind them. Typical piggish baby-boomer mentality too; take from all generations above and below, to hell with anyone else, so long as they can have their tax cuts and crab sandwiches.
If the 'peasants' keep believing they can "work hard at another job" for these greedy elitists to make up for the low pay, they'll keep voting Red. In Florida, before the minimum wages dropped to $2 an hr, the PR was running thick about it being a "raise" for the workers! Can you believe it?
They really act like everyone who has less money than them is stupid. And now they're using their money to block access to higher education.. probably because they see the connection between critical thought and falling for their brainwash! Yes, they just want everyone to be obedient sheeple that dont question authority, like in their heartland.
March 04, 2012 3:13pm
it must drive them crazy that they cant figure a way to keep us from comunicating and posting and reading the true facts off the internet so lets keep making them mad and hopefully more and more americans will wake up smell the coffee and help get these 'moronic ol boy mentality' out of government
March 04, 2012 2:26pm
Yes, true David Sirota, but . . .
The "but," for me, remains accepting the view of college as careerist or vocational ed. If we keep to this, we fall more to the logic of biz ed -- the logic of all Corporate America. We grow the walls around academic departments. We further silo imagination. The only bottom lines that remain will be the vulgar monied ones that the far-right justices ruled for in their Citizens United case.
Instead, let's open to strategies as at www.EssayingDifferences.com
March 04, 2012 11:54am
Elite snob! He STILL is a cafeteria Catholic! The rage against abortion and birth control yet nothing on capital punishment, wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, etc.
The height of hyprocisy!!! As Gary Wills said recently, "he is a Papist (Opus Dei) not a Catholic. The average Catholic cannot gain entry into Opus - it is an elitist group!! Betcha Rush wants to gain entry into Opus!!