Article image
Robert Reich
NationofChange / Op-Ed
Published: Wednesday 4 July 2012
Our system of government is America’s most precious and fragile possession, the means we have of joining together as a nation for the common good. It requires not only our loyalty but ongoing vigilance to keep it working well.

Patriotism July 4, 2012

Article image

In the last two weeks, the Supreme Court has allowed police in Arizona to demand proof of citizenship from people they stop on other grounds (while throwing out the rest of Arizona’s immigration law), and has allowed the federal government to require everyone buy health insurance — even younger and healthier people — or pay a penalty. 

What do these decisions — and the national conversations they’ve engendered — have to do with patriotism? A great deal. Because underlying them are two different versions of American patriotism. 

The Arizona law is aimed at securing the nation from outsiders. The purpose of the heatlhcare law is to join together to provide affordable health care for all. 

The first version of patriotism is protecting America from people beyond our borders who might otherwise overrun us — whether immigrants coming here illegally or foreign powers threatening us with aggression. 

The second version of patriotism is joining together for the common good. That might mean contributing to a bake sale to raise money for a local school or volunteering in a homeless shelter. It also means paying our fair share of taxes so our community or nation has enough resources to meet all our needs, and preserving and protecting our system of government. 

This second meaning of patriotism recognizes our responsibilities to one another as citizens of the same society. It requires collaboration, teamwork, tolerance, and selflessness. 

The Affordable Care Act isn’t perfect, but in requiring younger and healthier people to buy insurance that will help pay for the healthcare needs of older and sicker people, it summons the second version of patriotism. 

Too often these days we don’t recognize and don’t practice this second version. We’re shouting at each other rather than coming together — conservative versus liberal, Democrat versus Republican, native-born versus foreign born, non-unionized versus unionized, religious versus secular. 

Our politics has grown nastier and meaner. Negative advertising is filling the airwaves this election year. We’re learning more about why we shouldn’t vote for someone than why we should.

As I’ve said before, some elected officials have substituted partisanship for patriotism, placing party loyalty above loyalty to America. Just after the 2010 election, the Senate minority leader was asked about his party’s highest priority for the next two years. You might have expected him to say it was to get the economy going and reduce unemployment, or control the budge deficit, or achieve peace and stability in the Middle East. But he said the highest priority would be to make sure the President did not get a second term of office.

Our system of government is America’s most precious and fragile possession, the means we have of joining together as a nation for the common good. It requires not only our loyalty but ongoing vigilance to keep it working well. Yet some of our elected representatives act as if they don’t care what happens to it as long as they achieve their partisan aims. 

The filibuster used to be rarely used. But over the last decade the threat of a filibuster has become standard operating procedure, virtually shutting down the Senate for periods of time. 

Meanwhile, some members of the House have been willing to shut down the entire government in order to get their way. Last summer they were even willing to risk the full faith and credit of the United States in order to achieve their goals. 

In 2010 the Supreme Court opened the floodgates to unlimited money from billionaires and corporations overwhelming our democracy, on the bizarre theory that corporations are people under the First Amendment. Congress won’t even pass legislation requiring their names be disclosed. 

Some members of Congress have signed a pledge — not of allegiance to the United States but of allegiance to a man named Grover Norquist, who has never been elected by anyone. Norquist’s “no-tax” pledge is interpreted only by Norquist, who says closing a tax loophole is tantamount to raising taxes and therefore violates the pledge. 

True patriots don’t hate the government of the United States. They’re proud of it. Generations of Americans have risked their lives to preserve and protect it. They may not like everything it does, and they justifiably worry then special interests gain too much power over it. But true patriots work to improve the U.S. government, not destroy it. 

But these days some Americans loathe the government, and are doing everything they can to paralyze it, starve it, and make the public so cynical about it that it’s no longer capable of doing much of anything. Norquist says he wants to shrink it down to a size it can be “drowned in a bathtub.”

When arguing against paying their fair share of taxes, some wealthy Americans claim “it’s my money.” They forget it’s their nation, too. And unless they pay their fair share of taxes, American can’t meet the basic needs of our people. True patriotism means paying for America. 

So when you hear people talk about patriotism, be warned. They may mean securing the nation’s borders, not securing our society. Within those borders, each of us is on our own. These people don’t want a government that actively works for all our citizens. 

Yet true patriotism isn’t mainly about excluding outsiders seen as our common adversaries. It’s about coming together for the common good. 

This article was originally posted on Robert Reich's blog.



Get Email Alerts from NationofChange
Author pic
ABOUT Robert Reich

 

ROBERT B. REICH, one of the nation’s leading experts on work and the economy, is Chancellor’s Professor of Public Policy at the Goldman School of Public Policy at the University of California at Berkeley. He has served in three national administrations, most recently as secretary of labor under President Bill Clinton. Time Magazine has named him one of the ten most effective cabinet secretaries of the last century. He has written thirteen books, including his latest best-seller, “Aftershock: The Next Economy and America’s Future;” “The Work of Nations,” which has been translated into 22 languages; and his newest, an e-book, “Beyond Outrage.” His syndicated columns, television appearances, and public radio commentaries reach millions of people each week. He is also a founding editor of the American Prospect magazine, and Chairman of the citizen’s group Common Cause. His widely-read blog can be found at www.robertreich.org.

Top Stories

16 comments on "Patriotism July 4, 2012"

Pikewich

July 05, 2012 3:45pm

Patriotism has nothing to do with being loyal to your government.

Patriotism is making sure your government does the right thing.

mike morell

July 04, 2012 1:19pm

Surprising how rank and file Dems and Repubs agree on most issues: Love of home and country, brotherhood, jobs, patriotism, politeness, fairness, respect for woman rights, national security, nation before ego. Yet, most national frictions are caused by Rightie demagogues bent on taking over the party. GOP’ll collapse if Repubs don't retake control or form a new party, the National Party? To pull majorities like they used to.

vestal allen
Harker Heights, Texas
July 04, 2012 2:41pm

Are you sure there is a difference between the right and left? They make speeches on CSPAN as if they were but they know these speeches do not matter. Until one party has the house, presidency and a filibuster proof majority in the senate they can point fingers as each other as to why nothing ever really changes. When the democrats had a filibuster proof majority what happened? They lost it immediately. Politics is theater. Professional wrestling. Maybe nothing ever changes because the corporations that own our government do not want change.

mycophile

July 04, 2012 12:26pm

There are (short of the "benevolent aliens" hypothesis coming true) only two possible forks in the road that we are on towards complete enslavement by our multi-national corporations and bankers via their control of government. One is to support their emasculation of government to the point of its collapse, and the other is to take control of it ourselves.

Either would require us to endure pain.

The shrinking and collapse of government by the monied elite will be done by selectively reducing its public services such as road and bridge repair and the like. It will be done by selectively reducing fire and police budgets only for responses to things like human-on-human violence and property damage suffered by persons not of very high income or those who are critics of the unfair system. Picture that. Picture Rio de Janeiro. Don't forget to include its slums in that picture.

The taking by the common persons of control of government can only be a better solution if that control is then used to re-model it, replacing some of its underlying structural components that were rotten or weak when they were first installed, and then making its layout more efficient and sensible applying using the lessons we have learned from past mistakes and successes and modern understandings of environment and technology. Whether that results in a bigger or smaller building would be determined not by ideology, but by what was appropriate to achieve those goals.

But the only way to get the control necessary to have that opportunity, and the only way to remodel instead of demolish and re-build entirely anew, is to sacrifice comforts.

Let it be taken from you, pay later, or pay now. There is no free lunch.

Patricia Dixon

July 04, 2012 11:44am

This country we call America, not really thinking we are part
of the AMERICAS two continents joined by land and by many
mutual interests, was founded on the concept of "US", the
Anglo Saxon white Puritans who committed genocide against
the "OTHERS", the natives of these lands.
Since that time this concept has grown to include: women, blacks,
immigrants of all races and nationalities, the elderly whom we deposit
in warehouses called nursing homes, and children who are the targets
of all kinds of abuses in schools and homes, preys to the worse
pedophiles in our society, etc, etc.
So our dependence on the perpetuation of bashing the "other" is at
the heart of who we are, it threatens our democracy and all that we
aspire to be. So this 4th of July we should reflect on the oneness of
who we are, all connected with no boundaries, no religion,
no political affiliations, just humans who can choose between
love or hate.

mwalco

July 04, 2012 11:06am

Referring to Justice Kennedy, Jim Hightower wrote, "Is he on the court — or in a comedy club? Not only were Kennedy and his fellow corporatists wrong on the substance of their decree, but also ridiculously wrong on the politics. You don't need a law degree to see that CEOs are presently flooding this year's presidential and congressional races with hundreds of millions of corporate campaign dollars, gleefully perverting the political process to buy government policy for their own gain. That not only gives the appearance of corruption, it is corrupt."

vestal allen
Harker Heights, Texas
July 04, 2012 4:45pm

What did you expect from the Supreme court? The Patriot act is blatantly unconstitutional. The only way to undo the 4th amendment is to call a constitutional convention. The Supreme court is just a tool of of corporations that buy our congress. We are very screwed.

Julian Alien

July 04, 2012 11:04am

That is the last thing in America I would be proud of.No I am not buying any Chinese fireworks.The only thing I want from the Federal Government is to shrink to a tiny fraction of it's size.Then the Democrats and the Republicans can argue over the few dollars that are spent.

vestal allen
Harker Heights, Texas
July 04, 2012 2:53pm

I used to agree with small government until I researched what happened to Chile under Pinochet. Total free markets. Unemployment went to 44.5%. Poverty rates more than doubled. The air and water in Santiago are poisonous because of no regulation. Eventually they kicked out the "Chicago boys" and re nationalized some industries but they have a long way to go digging themselves out of the "small government" hole they dug themselves.

woetopoe

July 04, 2012 10:54am

As a lifelong student (55 yrs. old) of American history I can appreciate your sentiments Mr.Reich. You, also, are a lifelong student of the "same" history as I.
We "both" know this. That avarice and power will invariably trump the cards of altruism and egalitarianism even in the face of a "patriotic dealer." I agree with your basic premise of "supporting our government." But millions of us continue to see "our" government slavishly fawning before the powers of a corporate oligarchy, engaged in "wars of empire" NOT the maintenance or protection of "freedom," and decimating our environment, just to name a few grievances. I've voted Democrat since '74...what's it got me? A "continual" shift to the right and the abdication of principles that once were the core of the party.
You're former boss, Bill Clinton, signed the repudiation of the Glass/Stegall Act, thereby setting the course for the largest (and still unpunished) instances of financial malfeasance the country has ever witnessed. As a U.S. citizen I recognize the absolute necessity of a sound and functional U.S. government. I also see a government that is increasing disconnected from its citizenry as they assume an aura of "self-appointed" royalty. It's awful hard to feel "patriotic" towards the bunch in D.C. of late.

Sojourner

July 04, 2012 12:21pm

I don't agree that "That avarice and power will invariably trump the cards of altruism and egalitarianism." Woman suffrage, right of unions to collectively bargain, end of segregation, food and drug regulation, Clean Air/Water Acts, occupational health and safety laws, Medicare, Social Security, Unemployment Insurance, etc, etc, all were furiously opposed by the 1% who were defeated by mass political action on the part of the 99%. Yes, many of those victories are today under attack by power elite, but the efforts the 1% are making to repeal or weaken those reforms are testimonies to the importance and effectiveness of those past victories.

woetopoe

July 04, 2012 3:51pm

I believe you're overlooking the word "invariably" in the sentence of mine you both re-quote and refute. Every "victory" you rightfully allude to is either being successfully attacked or is disintegrating before our very eyes and beneath our very noses. Let's go down the line. 1. Women's suffrage: I haven't seen any movements to deny the vote to women. Yet the role of women in our society is facing undeniable threats from the reduction of reproductive rights to the continuing of male dominated hierarchies that pay women 77 cents, for the same job, as a man. The women who "do" accede to political office in many cases must acquiesce to what is still a white, male dominated political structure. The "vote" hasn't changed things much. Emma Goldmann once wrote that "if voting made any difference they'd probably outlaw it." 2. The right of unions to collectively bargain: Union membership in the United States was near 60% in the late 1950's. It stands at about 9% today. Any questions? 3. End of segregation: By virtue of monetary policy, affordable educational opportunities, unceasing attacks on "entitlements," gated/gilded communities, etc, the country is "re-segregating" itself and undoing 50 years of progress in that area. 4. Occupational health and safety laws: De-regulation, De-regulation, De-regulation. This is one of the key components of the Conservative mantra and is being implemented in many states by ALL Republicans and a sizable number of their "blue dog" acolytes, including, in some instances, President Obama himself. 4. Medicare, Social Security, Unemployment Insurance: These vital services ALL fall under the all encompassing banner of "entitlements," now fast becoming a "dirty word," in our lexicon. Medicare and SS are continually defined as "going broke," and Unemployment Insurance was successfully held hostage by House Republicans a little over a year ago...a possible harbinger of things to come. History, in many ways, is cyclical. The 1% you allude to is "winning" the current battle for the hearts and minds of large numbers of Americans much as they did during the Gilded Age of 100 years ago. Blood, sweat, tears, financial disaster and eventually a World War were necessary to put their "blue noses" back to a "constrained" position, even while they feverishly plotted a return to their former status. Take a look around...they've been extraordinarily successful, much to my chagrin, and I believe yours.

vestal allen
Harker Heights, Texas
July 04, 2012 10:26am

Nearly a half million children died in Iraq because of the sanctions. We denied the Iraqi people chlorine to purify water. Any American that is proud of that better hope there is no God and no judgement day. We give weapons to Israel that they use to commit more war crimes against the Palestinians under the 4th Geneva convention than we can count. Corporations own our government. What have we got to be proud of?

Norman Allen

July 04, 2012 10:23am

It is not the government the people hate. It is a government of, by and for corporate CEOs/board members at the expense of the people they hate. Any rational person would hate a government that does not serve but takes his/her hard earned cash to pursue corporate goals. Indeed the hatred of taxation without representation was the foundation on which this country was formed and sparked progressive changes around the world. Now we are where George Washington stood: taxation and dying for corporate goals without representation of the masses whose money and lives are hauled to maintain/secure raw materials/resources for the multinational corporations who effectively run governments all over the world. So, Patriotism is to go with General Washington and force the government to become representative of the people! Patriotism=PEACE and harmony with each other, nature and other nations. There is no FREEDOM without Freedom from corporate slavery.

Ronni85

July 04, 2012 10:18am

Happy Birthday, America!
Wake up, you won't find a lot of these in your futures if you don't.

Rebel with a Cause

July 04, 2012 7:39am

Happy Birthday, America!
Now tell me, whatever happened to Turtle Island?