Article image
Robert Reich
NationofChange / Op-Ed
Published: Thursday 27 September 2012
What we’re seeing in Ohio isn’t a new Mitt Romney. It’s a newly-packaged Mitt Romney.

Repackaging Mitt as a Compassionate Conservative? It’s Too Late

Article image

“My heart aches for the people I’ve seen,” Mitt Romney said, on the second day of his Ohio bus tour. He’s now telling stories of economic hardship among the people he’s met.

Up until now, Romney’s stories on the campaign trail have been about business successes – people who started businesses in garages and grew their companies into global giants, entrepreneurs who succeeded because of grit and determination, millionaires who began poor. Horatio Alger updated.

Curiously absent from these narratives have been the stories of ordinary Americans caught in an economy over which they have no control. That is, most of us.

At least until now.

“I was yesterday with a woman who was emotional,” Romney recounts, “and she said, ‘Look, I’ve been out of work since May.’ She was in her 50s. She said, ‘I don’t see any prospects. Can you help me?’”

Could it be Romney is finally getting the message that many Americans need help through no fault of their own?

“There are so many people in our country that are hurting right now,” Romney says.  “I want to help them.”

Later in the day, Romney told NBC that because of his efforts as governor of Massachusetts, “one hundred percent of the kids in our state had health insurance. I don’t think there’s anything that shows more empathy and care about the people of this country than that kind of record.”

But the repackaging of Mitt as a compassionate conservative won’t work. The good citizens of Ohio — as elsewhere — have reason to be skeptical.

This is, after all, the same Mitt Romney who told his backers in Boca Raton that 47 percent of Americans are dependent on government and unwilling to take care of themselves.

It’s the same Romney who was against bailing out GM and Chrysler. One in eight jobs in Ohio is dependent on the automobile industry. Had GM and Chrysler gone under, unemployment in Ohio would be closer to the national average of 8.1 percent than the 7.2 percent it is today.   

This is the same Romney who has been against extending unemployment benefits. Or providing food stamps or housing benefits for families that have fallen into poverty. Or medical benefits. To the contrary, Romney wants to repeal Obamacare, turn Medicare into vouchers, and turn Medicaid over to cash-starved states. 

This is the same Mitt Romney who doesn’t worry that Wall Street financiers — including his own Bain Capital — have put so much pressure on companies for short-term profits that they’re still laying off workers and reluctant to take on any more.

And the same Mitt who doesn’t want government to spend money repairing our crumbling infrastructure, rebuilding our schools, or rehiring police and firefighters and teachers. Romney says he feels their pain but his policy prescriptions would create more pain.  

Mitt Romney’s real compassion is for people like himself, whom he believes are America’s “job creators.” He aims to cut taxes on the rich, in the belief that the rich create jobs — and the benefits of such a tax cut trickle down to everyone else.

Trickle-down economics is the core of Romney’s economics, and it’s bunk. George W. Bush cut taxes — mostly for the wealthy — and we ended up with fewer jobs, lower wages, and an economy that fell off a cliff in 2008.

In Ohio Romney is repeating his claim that, under his tax proposal, the rich would end up paying as much as before even at a lower tax rate because he’d limit their ability to manipulate the tax code. “Don’t be expecting a huge cut in taxes because I’m also going to be closing loopholes and deductions,” he promises.

But Romney still refuses to say which loopholes and deductions he’ll close. He doesn’t even mention the “carried interest” loophole that has allowed him and other private-equity managers to treat their incomes as capital gains, taxed at 15 percent.

What we’re seeing in Ohio isn’t a new Mitt Romney. It’s a newly-packaged Mitt Romney. The real Mitt Romney is the one we saw on the videotape last week. And no amount of re-taping can disguise the package’s true contents.

This article was originally posted on Robert Reich's blog.



Get Email Alerts from NationofChange
Author pic
ABOUT Robert Reich

 

ROBERT B. REICH, one of the nation’s leading experts on work and the economy, is Chancellor’s Professor of Public Policy at the Goldman School of Public Policy at the University of California at Berkeley. He has served in three national administrations, most recently as secretary of labor under President Bill Clinton. Time Magazine has named him one of the ten most effective cabinet secretaries of the last century. He has written thirteen books, including his latest best-seller, “Aftershock: The Next Economy and America’s Future;” “The Work of Nations,” which has been translated into 22 languages; and his newest, an e-book, “Beyond Outrage.” His syndicated columns, television appearances, and public radio commentaries reach millions of people each week. He is also a founding editor of the American Prospect magazine, and Chairman of the citizen’s group Common Cause. His widely-read blog can be found at www.robertreich.org.

Top Stories

4 comments on "Repackaging Mitt as a Compassionate Conservative? It’s Too Late"

jim of olym

September 27, 2012 6:37pm

“I was yesterday with a woman who was emotional,” Romney recounts, “and she said, ‘Look, I’ve been out of work since May.’ She was in her 50s. She said, ‘I don’t see any prospects. Can you help me?’”

Could it be Romney is finally getting the message that many Americans need help through no fault of their own?

“There are so many people in our country that are hurting right now,” Romney says. “I want to help them.”

If he were a Christian at heart, he would give alms to this poor lady. But I wonder what he did do? give her a hug, buy her a sandwich? Give money to the local homeless shelter?

I suppose it's a secret (like people giving their alms in secret to get points in heaven....

Rich Nau

September 27, 2012 2:01pm

Romney needs to start by being honest with himself. He has seen enough business plans in his life to know that if a small change in the tax rate has any effect on deciding to expand the business your margins are too thin and you need to go into a different business. Expansion is driven completely by demand.
In our society demand is driven by the middle class consumer and that is who needs relief for our economy to recover.

Ron in NM

September 27, 2012 1:42pm

So, Mitt has had an "aha!" moment? An epiphany? Now he feels compassion for some of those 47% he brands as dependent "victims"? He saw his lead in the polls diminishing, and now he "sees the light" that he should re-package himself. Just boasting that he's "proud of his success" doesn't seem to be working with the average voter.

(One is reminded of what Jim Hightower famously said about the rich, something to the effect that these guys were born on third base and think they hit a triple.)

Funny thing, when a journalist asks Mitt how he can justify his "47%" comments, he blathers on with some ideological or philosophical fluff that entirely evades the question. Watch him next time he's asked about it. He rambles on about "putting Americans back to work," and so on, which doesn't answer any question at all. Politicians as a group are known for talking a lot and saying little, but Mitt is striving for some kind of award as Top Evader of the Year. I have to feel he thinks that average Americans are stupid beyond belief.

Mitt "feels" for suffering Americans? Believe that, and there's a bridge in Brooklyn that can be bought wholesale (from my brother-in-law).

Whence comes this sense of compassion? From the private schools and prestige universities and country clubs of his youth? Do you know that Mitt claims that he "inherited nothing"? Born with the fabled silver spoon in his mouth, rather like George W. Bush, and now, like him, he wants to refashion himself as a Compassionate Conservative. And yeah, just like W, he sees himself as a "self-made" man.

Somehow it all seems so predictable, wouldn't you say?

William Bednarz

September 27, 2012 10:25am

. . .didn't George Bush once say that if you stand in fromt of a mirror and repeat something - loud and often enought - you will begain to believe it yourself - even if no-one else does
LIE OFTEN - LIE LOUD.....SCREAM.....ARE YOU SAFER TODAY WITH ALL YOUR POLICE PROTECTION....(oh,,I'm sorry - I mean security) . . in your gated community.....gee like China's great wall ( maybe that's why he supports them???)