The School to Prison Pipeline: Education Under Arrest

Kanya D'Almeida
Inter Press Service / News Analysis
Published: Saturday 19 November 2011
“Two elementary school kids from Irvington, New Jersey were charged with ‘terroristic threatening’ for playing cops and robbers – with a paper plane. ”
Article image

Metal detectors. Teams of drug-sniffing dogs. Armed guards and riot police. Forbiddingly high walls topped with barbed wire.Such descriptions befit a prison or perhaps a high-security checkpoint in a war zone. But in the U.S., these scenes of surveillance and control are most visible in public schools, where in some areas, education is becoming increasingly synonymous with incarceration.

The United Nations, along with various human rights bodies and international courts, have recognised that "free education is the cornerstone of success and social development for young people". 

The landmark Brown v. Board of Education court ruling, which officially desegregated U.S. schools in 1954, stated, "It is doubtful that any child may reasonably be expected to succeed in life if (he/she is) denied the opportunity of an education.”

Yet hundreds of thousands of children in the U.S. are being systematically stripped of their right to education and transferred from the schoolhouse to the jailhouse. 

Along with tough disciplinary measures such as "zero tolerance policies", the last two decades have seen a huge influx of law enforcement officers into playgrounds and classrooms. 

Statistics from the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) indicate that the number of school resource officers (SROs) increased by 38 percent over the last ten years, even while reported incidents of theft and violence in schools are at their lowest since the National Center for Education Statistics first gathered comprehensive data in 1992. 

 A report released Tuesday by the Justice Policy Institute (JPI) detailing the extent and impact of policing in public schools confirmed what education and justice experts have argued for years: increased law enforcement does not make schools safer for students or foster better learning. 

In fact, the report found that police presence in schools devastates the learning environment, increases the number of arrests and referrals of youth into the juvenile "justice" system, and disrupts a child’s educational process by favouring suspension and expulsion over communal learning. 

"Police in schools undermine the education of thousands of students each year," Amanda Petteruti, lead author of JPI’s report, told IPS. 

"The impact of arresting and incarcerating students is significant: research has shown that within a year of reenrolling after spending time confined, two-thirds to three- fourths of formerly incarcerated youth withdraw or drop out of school. After four years, less than 15 percent of these youth had completed secondary education," she stressed. 

"Even contact with courts increases the chances that a high school student will drop out," she added. 

Children under siege According to ‘Derailed! The Schoolhouse to Jailhouse Track’, a detailed study undertaken by the Advancement Project, a six year-old student in Palm Beach County, Florida was arrested back in 2003 for ‘trespassing on school property’, while walking through the schoolyard on his way home. 

In Indianola, Mississippi, elementary school students have been hauled off to jail for talking during an assembly. 

Two elementary school kids from Irvington, New Jersey were charged with ‘terroristic threatening’ for playing cops and robbers – with a paper plane. 

In 2007, school security cameras captured footage of two guards in Palmdale, California assaulting a 16-year-old girl and breaking her arm for dropping a piece of cake on the floor. Both armed guards pushed the high-school student down on a table, throwing racial slurs like "nappy-head" at her while twisting her arm. 

These stories, unfortunately, are not exceptional, but have become the norm in hundreds of public schools across the country. Most of the thousands of arrests and referrals that happen each year are for minor infractions, misdemeanors or perceived 'threats' such as those outlined above, based on the subjective opinions of teachers or security guards. 

Students of color often bear the brunt of these punitive policies. 

"Data from (think tanks) suggest that students of color are disproportionately affected by the presence of SROs," Petteruti told IPS, particularly "in districts like Pinellas County, Florida, South Carolina, Colorado and, according to the ACLU in Connecticut, East Hartford". 

The Advancement Project also found that it was 58 percent more likely for police to be called into schools whose student body was majority black, Latino, Native American or Asian American. 

"Data from the U.S. Department of Education (DOE) indicates that students of color are more likely to be suspended than white students, and are more likely to go to schools where there are more law enforcement responses. Students of color are more also more likely to come into contact with police and surveillance in schools," Petteruti said. 

The severe policing of urban schools in low-income neighborhoods and communities of color is an extension of a nationwide racially biased strategy that hounds minorities and swallows them up in burgeoning prisons. The strategy has roots in the ‘get tough on crime’ movements of the 1980s and early 1990s. 

According to the Advancement Project, "the media and political world focused on a growing crime problem and a few brutal crimes to create a new type of criminal, the 'superpredator'.

"Superpredators were brutal, conscienceless, incorrigible and, most frighteningly, they were young. They were presented as the products of permissive single-parent families, poverty and a lenient judicial system," it continued. 

"The public and political system responded with outrage and with draconian changes to juvenile law - boot camps, and a zero tolerance attitude that made even the slightest offence a crime. 

Get Email Alerts from NationofChange
ABOUT Kanya D'Almeida

Kanya d'Almeida is one of the signers of SJP and is a feminist writer and an activist on human rights issues.

FEATURE A

Connect with your friends

Find new content you might like and see what your friends are sharing!

Top Stories

9 comments on "The School to Prison Pipeline: Education Under Arrest"

uphzzah

ezaks

November 28, 2011 11:39am

I just completed a project for my sociology class that examined the connection between the school-to-prison pipeline and the private prison industry. It seems that the private prison industry is directly benefiting from the tough disciplinary measures explained above, as more students are being arrested and sent to either public or private juvenile facilities. The industry is essentially capitalizing off of vulnerable youth, specifically youth of color, which has many negative implications that are generally overlooked by society.

Curious about how the private prison industry directly and indirectly benefits from the school-to-prison pipeline? Or about how the media has shaped society's view of privatizing juvenile facilities and youth of color? Then check out these blog posts and tell me your thoughts!

Part 1: http://soctheory.iheartsociology.com/2011/11/28/the-link-between-the-pri...
Part 2: http://soctheory.iheartsociology.com/2011/11/28/society’s-view-of-privatization-and-youth-of-color-what-are-the-implications/

janis

November 20, 2011 7:47pm

In a high school, I believe a lot of the teachers would rather let the school resource officer dole out the discipline rather than handling the situation itself. Now, it depends on the severity but I believe, before the cops have to be involved there is an enormous amount of time to turn a negative interaction into a win-win respectful relationship between the adult(teacher) and the adolescent(student). Many kids are scooped up into the law before they are given many good talkin' to's! Far too many students are written up when the kid is only testing out the waters. Teens think they are invincible. Just because they think this way doesn't mean that their isn't time to turn them around before the law has to be involved.

george r

November 19, 2011 11:48pm

Some of the rules in school need changing. Society needs to be a little more blind and deaf to minor infractions. Why get a kid in trouble for a lifetime when you could ignore something that harms no one? At Poly High School in Long Beach a good kid got caught with some marijuana. Rather than face his parents, friends, relatives, judges, police, school authorities the boy committed suicide. The cops know that a lot of good kids smoke pot and drink beer. Not all of them need to become criminals. None of them deserve to die.

Bevan Trembly

November 19, 2011 10:32pm

Absolutely, true, Sir, and could it be that your hair is on fire?Yur homie on the East Coast.B.

anono

November 19, 2011 5:12pm

The solution!! Ninja hall monitors! Ninja hall monitors who can quickly intervene bad behavior before it happens and twist some ears when it does! Get rid of the guns and badges and uniforms and brutality. The goal is to create a safe haven for children who have no other sanctuary in their lives. Not to create yet another absurd version of hell for them. Of course this is bad for the -1%'s for profit prisons by cutting out the supply side, but who cares. It's all about the kids.

Brian Glennie

November 19, 2011 2:48pm

Just like Nazi Germany in the 1930's, they just don't wear brown shirts !

white trash wit...

November 19, 2011 2:25pm

Public education is the backbone of this country and is in danger. There is no doubt that the incidents decribed are absurd breaches of authority, they are not in my experience the norm. We have a new superintendant who feels that it looks bad to have the students arrested. Since she came in, she has cut down on the police in the schools and the chaos has gotten worse. Michigan City is not a poor urban area although like all communities we have suffered in the economic downturn. The lack of order in the schools however has nearly reduced us to inner city depredation.

I'm not sure what the answer is, there are better ways to deal with society's outliers than putting them in jail. On the other hand you cannot allow the outliers to disrupt the educational process for the rest. There would be incredible outcry if ineffective parents were taken out of the picture so perhaps manditory parenting classes for parents of disuptive students? Manditory counseling is like leading a horse to water and not being able to make him drink, however while holding his head underwater he can't help but drink a little and every little bit helps.

David Sheridan

November 19, 2011 1:38pm

The goal is not safety, the goal is to create a nation of ignorant proles who accept a police state as normal.