Senate GOP Provides $1.1 Million Tax Cut to Wealthy Estates While Raising Taxes on 20 Million Working Families
The Senate GOP plan to preserve the Bush tax cuts on incomes above $250,000 already amounts to a budget-busting tax cut for the rich, and in addition to it, Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) and Sen. Orrin Hatch (R-UT) also added another tax cut that benefits only the super-wealthy. The Hatch-McConnell plan effectively eliminates the estate tax, costing billions in revenue and giving a huge tax cut to the very wealthiest Americans, as the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities notes:
Specifically, the new Senate Republican proposal, which Senators Mitch McConnell and Orrin Hatch unveiled earlier this month, would:
Cost $119 billion more in forgone revenues over the next ten years than the Obama Administration proposal to reinstate the already generous 2009 estate-tax rules. Analysis by the Urban Institute-Brookings Tax Policy Center shows that all of the $119 billion would flow to the heirs of the estates of the wealthiest three of every 1,000 people who die, since those are the only estates that would owe any estate tax under the 2009 rules.
Give taxable estates an average of more than $1.1 million each in tax reductions, compared to the tax that would be owed under a reinstatement of the 2009 estate-tax rules. The bigger the estate, the more lavish the tax break would be. Estates worth more than $20 million would receive an average tax reduction of $4.2 million in 2013.
As CBPP notes, even President Obama’s estate tax plan is generous, allowing exemptions on millions of dollars of an estate’s value. The GOP’s plan would provide an even larger exemption, and though critics of the tax claim the estate has already been subject to taxation, in most instances it is not because the increase in value of the estate classifies as unrealized capital gains. If the estate was sold, the increase in value would be taxed. When it is inherited, however, those taxes are never levied.
The GOP doesn’t only give huge tax cuts to the very wealthy, though. It also mitigates a small amount of the budgetary damage done by those cuts by ending three tax breaks that benefit the middle class, a decision that will ultimately raise taxes on 20 million working families if the GOP plan went into effect. That isn’t shocking given the bill is co-sponsored by Hatch, one of the leaders of the Republican Party’s movement to raise taxes on the poorest Americans.
CONNECT














12 comments on "Senate GOP Provides $1.1 Million Tax Cut to Wealthy Estates While Raising Taxes on 20 Million Working Families"
July 31, 2012 5:52am
G. You and Ron Paul have a common mentality. DUMB...
How will you get the services that you use every day if there are no Taxes or Government to provide them???
The use of Roads, Telephone, Radio, Television, Computers and the Internet, Electricity, Water, Natural Gas, Hospitals, etc. etc. etc.
Do you want to eat food or use medications that have not been checked by the FDA. How about driving a Car, Truck or riding on a Bus, Train or Airplane that has not been inspected or maintained without Regulations or Enforcement from the Government. What Bank will you want to use and feel safe in without any Banking Laws and Regulations. Or where would you work without the Protection of OSHA or the Department of Labor?
That is just a quick sample of things that would change quickly under a Republican President and a Republican Congress. Maybe you and all of the others that buy into the Republican Talking points, should shut you mouth and engage your minds and think before you say anything.
July 30, 2012 8:38am
I have two words: RON PAUL = NO TAXES. He believe the size of gov't should be decreased and you should keep the fruits of your labor.
July 29, 2012 5:17pm
The 99% and the 1% would both agree, "Federal Income Taxes are unfair".
Why not end them ? Reduce the rate to zero (0).
OK but how do we raise revenue.
As Einstein said, "Keep it simple", tax money not people !!
Please read and improve.... "Don't End The Fed, Amend The Fed"
http://bit.ly/MlQWNs
Read what William Black has to say about banks and Michael Hudson about compound interest (excerpts are in the article).
An explanation of where we went wrong with a solution to how we can fix it.
Challenge it.
Improve it.
Turn it into :
“The Occupy Wall Street Manifesto”
Please, as a journalist investigate and challenge, then improve and endorse if you find it to be beneficial to mankind.
July 31, 2012 6:06am
WE THE PEOPLE WANT EQUALITY, JUSTICE AND FAIR AND EQUAL TAXES FOR ALL!!!!!
Chris Hayes writes: The moral and spiritual damage that extreme inequality has wrought on even those who presided over and dominated by the Capitalism system. But there are actual cognitive, organizational, and social costs to such systems as well. The slave economy of the antebellum South conferred massive material gains on a very small number of extremely wealthy white plantation owners. But it also severely stunted the development of the region. It is the same system that the 1.0% would like to return the United States of America to.
Extreme inequality of the particular kind that we have produces its own particular kind of elite pathology: it makes elites less accountable, more prone to corruption and self-dealing, more status-obsessed and less empathic, more blinkered and removed from informational feedback crucial to effective decision making. For this reason, extreme inequality produces elites that are less competent and more corrupt than a more egalitarian social order would. This is the fundamental paradoxical outcome that several decades of failed meritocratic production have revealed: As American society grows more elitist, it produces a lesser caliber of elites.
Thomas Paine urged that everything "beyond what a man's own hands produce" was a gift that came to him simply by living in society, and hence, "he owes on every principle of justice, of gratitude, and of civilization, a part of that accumulation back again to society from whence the whole came."
Here are the facts. Data from Edward Wolff confirms that from 1983 to 2007 the percentages of net worth and financial wealth for the top 1% remained steady. But the percentages for the rest of the richest 5% increased by almost 20%, while the percentages for the lowest 80% of the population DECREASED by almost 20%.
These issues are difficult to address with Congress largely on the side of the wealthy. At the very least congress should:
(1) Eliminate the tax break on unearned income (capital gains). The richest Americans, who own most of the stocks, should not pay a smaller tax than everyone else.
(2) Implement a small financial transactions tax for stocks. It would be easy to administer on computer trades, it would generate hundreds of billions of dollars in revenue, and it would help guard against the reckless speculation that devastated the financial markets and our country.
In case you haven't heard: Freedom isn't free. Just ask the rich Republicans who seem to think it's fair that Millionaires and Billionaires get big tax breaks not available to middle class working families. After all, "Earned Income" is for losers; winners have "Capital Gains" to keep them warm. And so what if losers pay a higher rate of tax than winners. Somebody has to pay for all that freedom they…uh, I mean we…enjoy.
First, I will say that any Income Tax Reform that continues to allow for EXCEPTIONS, EXEMTIONS, and DEDUCTIONS will never be Fair and Equal to all. Far Too many loopholes exist through which the Top 1.0% of American Tax-Payers the “Rich and Powerful” Individuals and Corporations, Companies, Institutions and Organizations squeeze through and pay NO TAXES. Even if we made the INCOME TAX RATE on every individual who made over one million dollars to be 99%, with the use of the Exceptions, Exemptions and Deductions [that Congress would create] they would not pay any taxes.
The Entire Income Tax Code MUST be Repealed and Replaced. By the elimination of ALL the EXCEPTIONS, EXEMPTIONS, and DEDUCTIONS and by making every source of Income [Wages, Bonuses, Benefits, Interest Earnings, dividends and capital gains and any other Earnings or Gains] be subject to the same Tax Code and Rate no matter How it was earned, Where it was earned, or What it was earned from.
HERE is an Income Tax Code that is based upon Fairness and Equality, and the ability to pay, just like everything else in life. PLEASE note that the implementation of this Tax Code would significantly reduce the size of the IRS, reduce the amount of time to prepare your Taxes, and sorry to say it, but it gets rid of the need for Tax Preparation Companies.
The official numbers for people in Poverty or what is Poverty Income level don’t tell the full story. The situation of the poor is actually considerably worse than the Government reports. The official poverty line is calculated as simply three times the minimal food budget first introduced in 1959, and then adjusted for inflation in food costs. In other words, the American poverty threshold takes no account of the cost of housing or fuel or transportation or health-care costs, all of which are rising more rapidly than the cost of basic foods. So the poverty measure grossly understates the real cost of subsistence.
Existing Poverty Income Taxes:
[1.0] Income earned from $.01 to $13,537.00 for a family of one would pay Zero Tax Rate.
[2.0] Income earned from $.01 to $23,689.00 for a family of two would be Zero Tax Rate.
[3.0] Income earned from $.01 to $30,478.00 for a family of three would be Zero Tax Rate.
[4.0] Income earned from $.01 to $37,267.00 for a family of four would be Zero Tax Rate.
[5.0] Income earned from $.01 to $44,056.00 for a family of five would be Zero Tax Rate.
[6.0] Income earned from $.01 to $50,845.00 for a family of six would be Zero Tax Rate.
[7.0] Income earned from $.01 to $57,634.00 for a family of seven would be Zero Tax Rate.
[8.0] Income earned from $.01 to $64,423.00 for a family of eight would be Zero Tax rate.
For those who are not in the Poverty Income Level the Tax Rates would be as follows:
[9.0] Income earned from $13,537.00 to $100,000.00 would pay a 15.0% Tax Rate. PLUS.
[10.0] Income earned from $100,000.01 to $500,000.00 would pay 17.5% Tax Rate. PLUS.
[11.0] Income earned from $500,000.01 to $1,000,000.00 would pay 20.0%Tax Rate. PLUS.
[12.0] Income earned from $1,000,000.01 to $50,000,000.00 would pay 25.0% Tax Rate. PLUS.
[13.0] Income earned from $50,000,000.01 to $1,000,000,000.00 would pay 30.0% Tax Rate. PLUS.
[14.0] Income earned from $1,000,000,000.01 and up would pay 35.0% Tax Rate.
I would also create a Financial Transaction Fee of $ .25 on each and every Stock Transaction, to generate from $2 to $3 Trillion in Revenue to “Reduce the Deficit and to Invest in our future, our Infrastructure and our middle class.”
U.S. Corporate Income Taxes that were actually paid (the effective rate) fell to a 40 year low of 12.1 percent in fiscal year 2011, despite corporate profits rebounding to their Pre-Great Recession heights. The United States of America, both taxes its Corporations less and raises less in revenue from corporate taxes than its foreign competitors.
Therefore; under my Corporate Tax Rate Corporations would pay 15.0% Income Tax Rate with NO Exceptions, No Exemptions and the NO Deductions. Or they can pay the same Tax Rates as an Individual, seeing as the Supreme Court has ruled they have the same Right to Freedom of Speech, therefore they should have the same Right to pay the same Income Tax Rates. Corporations should not make Business decisions based upon the Income Tax Loop-holes, they should be based on what is the best thing for the Corporation, Employees and the Investors. The top 500 Corporations, Companies, Institutions and Organizations within the Fortune 500, Pay No Taxes today. This Income Tax Plan would ensure that all Corporations, Companies, Institutions or for Profit Organizations that earned a Profit would PAY TAXES.
If Congress wants to provide an incentive to Corporations, Companies, Institutions or Organizations, Congress can do so by creating a Specific Tax Credit for A Specific Corporation or Company, with specified amounts and for specified time limits.
Think about this one simple thing, if we make all forms of Income, no matter how earned, be TAXED at the same Rate we would be doubling the Taxes on the Rich and Powerful.
July 29, 2012 11:38pm
That link was a huge waste of time.
July 29, 2012 3:54pm
At all costs we must preserve America's wealthy class -the most valuable commodity in the nation.
July 29, 2012 3:52pm
estate tax are a equal to grave robbing
July 29, 2012 11:33pm
B.S. It taxes what hasn't been taxed, i.e., unrealized capital gains.
July 29, 2012 2:06pm
When are people going to realize that the republicans are out to destroy the working Americans. They treat working Americans like we are their worst enemy, dirt to be thrown in the street with no money or benefits of any kind. They can't stand to even be in the same room with us. If anyone else did this to us they would be beaten within an inch of their life, put in prison, or deported. Why are we letting them do this to us? When are we going to stand up for ourselves? When we are too broke and too weak from hunger? Because that is what they are doing to us. These people don't deserve the life of luxury they are living at our expense. They are going to buy the election thanks to the help from the supreme court. They are going to take everything they can take from us, sit back and laugh about it. Is no one strong enough to show some pride and demand to stop being walked all over?
July 30, 2012 10:15am
I'm with you all the way. Most people are too busy just getting by to pay attention to politics, but that has to change now. We have to get the 99% to scream that the 1% are Buying our politicians and our Government. We have to demand that Congress change the Tax Code to what we had in the 30's, 40's, 50's, 60's, 70's, and early 80's. For instance in 1938 we had 33 tax brackets from 4% which covered over 1/2 of the population, to 79% for income over $79Million. Today they have put so much burden on the poor and middle class, that we only have 6 tax brackets, that only extend to the upper middle class at $380,000. 6 Brackets is not enough, and stopping the top marginal rate at $380,000. is an insult to the working man. This Tax Code doesn't even reach into the rich income bracket. There are millions of people that earn way over $380,000. The Tax Code has to reach into the rich income brackets by having 10 or 20 more Brackets. Tax brackets should tax the incomes of over $1Million, $2Million, $3Million, $4Million, $5Million, $6Million, $7Million, $8Million, $9Million, $10Million, $11Million, $12Million, $13Million, $14Million, $15Million, $16Million, $17Million, $18Million, $19Million, & $20Million. This is a simple fix to the country's biggest problem. And it's also "Fair and Balanced".
July 29, 2012 11:36am
The Upper Class looks out for there own - there is only so much money to go around, you know.
"The Middle Class can kiss my ass, I have joined the Upper Class at last. "- an old English refrain.
July 29, 2012 9:53am
It's criminal! Not only are the repugnants out "to get us", the guy that promised to be for WE, the PEOPLE if WE elected him, has also been bought off.
NOW, what can WE do? WE can't not re-elect him - he's the lesser of the two EVILS.
It's probably too late to get someone to run against them, what WE need - a CHAMPION for WE, the PEOPLE.