You are viewing the NationofChange archives. For the latest news and actions, visit the new
Get Email Updates | Log In | Register

Article image
Robert Scheer
Truthdig / Truthdig Op-Ed
Published: Saturday 15 December 2012
After being interned like some wild animal in that cage in Kuwait, Pfc. Bradley Manning was transferred to the Quantico, Va., Marine base and further subjected to conditions that his lawyer termed “criminal.”

The Shameful Exploitation of Bradley Manning

Article image

Keep an American soldier locked up naked in a cage and driven half mad while deprived of all basic rights, and you will be instantly condemned as a barbaric terrorist. Unless the jailer is an authorized agent of the U.S. government, in which case even treatment approaching torture will go largely unnoticed. Certainly if a likable constitutional law professor happens to be president, all such assaults on human dignity will easily pass muster.   

After being interned like some wild animal in that cage in Kuwait, Pfc. Bradley Manning was transferred to the Quantico, Va., Marine base and further subjected to conditions that his lawyer termed “criminal.” Not all that far from the White House, and yet our ever-enlightened president seems not to have noticed that this soldier, whose alleged criminal offense is that he attempted to inform the public of crimes committed in its name, has been held in an environment clearly created to destroy his very sense of self.    

As Manning’s lawyer, David Coombs, a lieutenant colonel in the Army reserves and a veteran of 12 years of active duty, put it: “Brad’s treatment at Quantico will forever be etched into our nation’s history as a disgraceful moment in time.” Coombs warned that the most serious charge facing his client, “aiding the enemy,” is a “scary proposition” designed to “silence a lot of critics of our government.”   

Who is that “enemy” other than the public that came to be informed about the true nature of the U.S. wars in Iraq and Afghanistan by news reports based on a trove of documents allegedly made available to the WikiLeaks website by Manning? The documents were labeled secret, but as the many important news reports based on them revealed, they contained information that an enlightened public had a need and right to know.    

Yet for too many in the mainstream media, led by the example of the editors of The New York Times, the recent military courtroom proceedings where Manning’s lawyer finally got to document the government’s attempt to destroy his client were largely a nonevent. Conveniently so, given that the Times and other major news outlets that were thrilled to exploit the information that Manning uncovered are deeply afraid of being associated with the brave whistle-blower himself.   

Not all, however. The British Guardian—which features Glenn Greenwald, today’s most compelling writer on civil liberties—has taken seriously the plight of the man alleged to be one of the paper’s sources. But why haven’t others? As Margaret Sullivan, the public editor of The New York Times, asked: “Why did readers of The Times have to turn to Ed Pilkington of The Guardian, or to one of the great number of other news organizations that sent reporters, to hear Private Manning tell of the Mordor into which he had been drawn—where he had to stand naked, in chains, in the ‘maximum custody’ brig at Quantico, Va., imploring his prison guards for something as simple as toilet paper, or, earlier, in a ‘cage’ in Kuwait?”   

While the Times is to be applauded for running Sullivan’s devastating critique, the replies from individual editors responsible were lame. Asked why the paper didn’t send a reporter to cover this rare opportunity to learn Manning’s side of the story, Times Washington bureau chief David Leonhardt said, “We’ve covered him and will continue to do so. But as with any other legal case, we won’t cover every single proceeding.”    

Really? This is hardly just another legal case, for it goes to the heart of the First Amendment freedoms on which the Times has relied so heavily during its storied history.    

If the public had a right to know the information that Manning allegedly revealed, as the Times demonstrated by publishing important stories featuring it, then the source should be honored rather than scorned. As Sullivan wrote: “To its credit, The Times published article after article based on the very information that Private Manning provided to WikiLeaks, just as it had published the Pentagon Papers that Mr. [Daniel] Ellsberg leaked during the Vietnam War.”   

Manning is in the same position as was Ellsberg, who four decades ago leaked to The New York Times details of government lies and crimes in Vietnam. Both men had access to material classified as secret, but both believed they had an obligation to puncture the veil of government secrecy when it was employed to deceive the public.   

What is protected in the First Amendment is not the right of commercial enterprises to exploit the news for profit, but rather of citizens to become informed. That requires the courage of heroic sources, including Bradley Manning.

Author pic
ABOUT Robert Scheer
Robert Scheer, editor in chief of Truthdig, has built a reputation for strong social and political writing over his 30 years as a journalist. His columns appear in newspapers across the country, and his in-depth interviews have made headlines. He conducted the famous Playboy magazine interview in which Jimmy Carter confessed to the lust in his heart and he went on to do many interviews for the Los Angeles Times with Richard Nixon, Ronald Reagan, Bill Clinton and many other prominent political and cultural figures.

Boris Badenov's picture

The land of the free my

The land of the free my ass!
It was bought and paid for at least 3 Generations ago.
No freedom here!

Amerika , Land of the free ,

Amerika , Land of the free , Home of the brave ..........Liberty and Justice for all ?
Pure meaningless psychobable . Politicians and political hacks can cheat and steal and they get a slap on the wrist . Example being the C.E.O. of Fannie Mae , Franklyn Raines who cooked the books in order to reward himself with millions of dollars in bonuses. He was fired but then rewarded with over $ 100,000.00 a month in retirement pay for the rest of his corrupt life . When Jon Corzine the C.E.O. of M.S.Global " misplaces " over $ 1 Billion dollars in investors money over a year ago , he has still not been brought to trial . [ could it be that he was a former Senator and Governor of New Jersey and once the head of Goldman Sachs ? ] Will he ever be brought to trial ? The " Fat Cats " all seem to have a "Get Out of Jail Free" card . During the Nurnberg Trials , members of the military were condemned because they went along with the " so called " atrocities . When one of our own tries to bring to light the lies , deception and atrocities of our own leadership in Washington and the military , he is crucified . Our so called Justice Department has proven itself to be totally corrupt when you look at their history of ignoring the " Fast and Furious " operation , the Acorn scandal, the Black Panther voter intimidation scandal and as mentioned earlier M.S. Global and Fannie Mae . The U.S. since 1950 has threatened , bombed and invaded over 30 poor 3 rd world countries who were NO threat to us . We with our Weapons of Mass Destruction have murdered millions of innocent men , women and CHILDREN in order to bring them "Democracy". Because of Bush , Cheny and Rumsfeld and their bold faced distortion and LIES , about 7,000 young innocent kids in the U.S.Military are now dead , they died in vain. The Bush / Cheny Mafioso should have been brought to trial and convicted for mass murder . And after all his promises to pull out, Obama also stabbed us in the back. Serial Killers all.
Free Bradley Manning , a true Patriot .

Scheer writes good

Scheer writes good stuff.

There is, of course, more patriotism in Brad Manning's little finger than in the entire bodies of Bush and Obama (combined).

"The whole purpose of

"The whole purpose of American Democracy is to provide the means to enrichment for those elected and appointed to public offices. If making money rquires lying, that perfectly O-K!"
----Ronald Reagan

Boris Badenov's picture

WOW! Reagan sure was

Reagan sure was stupid!!!

Comment with your Facebook account

Comment with your Disqus account

Top Stories

comments powered by Disqus

NationofChange works to educate, inform, and fight power with people, corruption with community.

If you would like to stay up to date with the best in independent, filter-free journalism, updates on upcoming events to attend, and more, enter your email below:

7 Compelling Reasons Why You Should Support NationofChange

Our readers often tell us why they’ve decided to step up and become supporters. Here are some of the top reasons people are giving.

1. You’re keeping independent journalism alive
The corporate owned media has proven that it can’t be trusted. In a media landscape wrought with spin and corruption, NationofChange stands in very scarce company.

2. You’re sticking it to the rich, powerful, and corrupt
When you have money in this country you can get away with damn near anything, and they do. NationofChange isn’t afraid to expose these criminals no matter how powerful they are.

3. Your donation is 100% tax-deductible
NationofChange is a 501(c)3 charity. People tend to assume that many other organizations are (most nonprofits are NOT) but it’s that 501(c)3 status is a bit more rare than you think.

Read the rest...