State Department Speaks out Against Russia’s Anti-Gay Propaganda Bill

Igor Volsky
Think Progress / News Report
Published: Friday 25 November 2011
“Russia classified homosexuality as a mental illness until 1999 and decriminalized homosexual behavior in 1993, but homophobic attitudes remain.”
Article image

The State Department briefly addressed an anti-gay propaganda law now being considered in St. Petersburg, Russia during a press briefing on Tuesday. The measure — which passed first reading earlier this month and is now being slightly altered before a second reading on November 30th — would fine groups and individuals for “public actions aimed at propaganda of pederasty, lesbianism, bisexuality, and transgenderism among minors.” Human rights advocates from around the world allege that the discriminatory proposal is in violation of the European Convention of Human Rights, to which Russia is a signatory.

State Department spokeswoman Victoria Nuland promised to take these concerns to the Moscow Embassy and reiterated Secretary of State Hillary Clinton’s strong support for LGBT equality around the world:

QUESTION: Just one quick one on Russia. I don’t know whether you have anything on this, but there’s apparently a bill that’s supported by Putin’s party which would – it’s in two major Russian cities – that would criminalize almost all activity that is related to LGBT equality, equating any discussion of that issue with pedophilia. Have you heard about this? Is this anything that the State Department would be interested in taking up?

MS. NULAND: I have not heard about that one, Jill. I’ll certainly ask our Embassy in Moscow whether they have been active on this issue. I think you know the principled stand that the United States Government takes on this issue and that the Secretary of State in particular takes on this issue, which is that gay rights are human rights and human rights are gay rights. And so I don’t think the Russian Government could have any question about where we would stand on such an issue. But let me take it and see whether we’ve been active at all.

The bill was developed by Russian President Medvedev’s and Prime Minister Vladimir Putin’s “United Russia” party and may serve as a model for imposing federal restrictions on LGBT people. Two regions of Russia — Arkhangelsk and Ryazan — have adopted similar anti-propaganda laws that have been upheld by the Russian courts. Opponents see this latest push as a way to distract voters “from the unresolved economic and social problems, and simply shift focus” to so-called “enemies” against a minority group.

Russia classified homosexuality as a mental illness until 1999 and decriminalized homosexual behavior in 1993, but homophobic attitudes remain. According to a recent study by the National Opinion Research Center at the University of Chicago, Russian support for gay people has declined since the Soviet era, making Russia one of only four nations — along with Cyprus, the Czech Republic and Latvia — to see a reduction in tolerance towards homosexuality. Fifty-nine percent of the Russian population “felt that homosexual behavior was wrong in 1991 compared with 64 percent in 2008, the study showed.” In another poll from last year, when asked “Whom wouldn’t you like to have as your neighbor?” respondents said alcohol and drug addicts, former criminals, and homosexuals.

Originally published on ThinkProgress


Get Email Alerts from NationofChange

Top Stories

10 comments on "State Department Speaks out Against Russia’s Anti-Gay Propaganda Bill"

ohggxkz

As I agree that it is none of Americas business on how Russia governs there country, but if we don't do something who will? Thousands of innocent people will be punished for just trying to be who they are. How is that just?

Remind them that Tchaikovsky was a closeted gay and suffered badly for being who he was and despite that bequeathed to the world a sonic wonderland. Wonder what he could have done if Russia had been tolerant.

Warren Hart

November 26, 2011 8:08am

No, I think the anti-gay law is to sound as if it were protecting children. That is intentional. The political class of the anti-gay crowd know that if the anti-gay law sounded anti-gay then that would stir that much more opposition to it and them. They aren't stupid, just anti-gay.

Rose Coveney

November 25, 2011 8:45pm

When is the US going to stop sticking their nose into the business of people on other continents? Or is this another atempt of the US Government's way of wagging the dog to get the people's mind off of the dispicable behavior of Government and Corp America, while they systematically destroy our middle class? Concentrate on greedy corporations who have sold their souls and find a way of bringing jobs back to our country. What the hell do you intend to do, attack them like you do every other little country you have destroyed for oil and gold? I don't think so. Now your huffing and puffing at the door of the big bad wolf.

Norothschilds

November 25, 2011 3:17pm

How is this ANY of our business? We have soooooo many problems in the USA such as a private central bank/Wall Street that has robbed everybody blind with phony money and real interest/debasement/inflation, the nearly complete de-industrialization and offshoring of high paying jobs, the ever expanding military industrial complex and intelligence industrial complex, the obvious militarization of "our" law enforcement agencies which puts OUR ability to express an alternative opinion into richly deserved scrutiny. Go out and hold a "The Holocaust was a Hoax" or "9/11 Was an Inside Job" or "End the Fed" signs and see how far OUR right to express ourselves goes. Although it is greed that has caused the ruinous expansion of the American Empire, it's our inability to mind our own damn business that's used to sell the ideas in the beginning. Besides, this sudden concern with Russia's social behavior kinda coincides perfectly with their recent support for Iran and overt disdain (completely justifiable IMO) for NATO surrounding them doesn't it? Yes, it does.

Lawrence Blomberg

November 25, 2011 3:12pm

Seems like to me they're protecting minors from sexual content.I think you all missed that.

Norothschilds

November 25, 2011 4:57pm

You are messing up folk's victimhood mentality.

maturesteve

November 25, 2011 1:27pm

This step backward into deeper homophobia and racism for those who are different is disturbing indeed... shows how little progress russia has actually made... Freedom in an inclusive thing ,, not exclusive... and acceptance of the human condition requires greater consciousness than the Russian government possesses.Good that the U S is standing up and speaking out,,,, the pen can be mighter than the sword...I am sure many of those opposed to this in Russia are gay themselves, like the many in our own congress who hide behind bathroom stalls in airports, and other places.. but fail to come forward and try to end this horrific behavior once and for all...

NHsolarguy

November 25, 2011 12:31pm

Now, if we could just treat them with equaity and respect here in the USA...