While Republicans Warn Against ‘Greece,’ That is Exactly Where Austerity Budgeting Will Lead U.S.
Indebted America is in danger of turning into destitute Greece, or so congressional Republicans and conservative commentators have been warning us for years now. For many reasons, this is an absurd comparison — but it may not always be quite so ridiculous if Washington's advocates of austerity get their way
The Republicans actually want to impose Greek-style budget slashing on the United States. And the federal budget sequestration scheduled to take effect next week could represent the first serious step here toward the kind of fiscal policies that have proved so ruinous not only in Greece — raising unemployment, destroying hope and encouraging extremism — but across Europe.
Nearly every day, House Speaker John Boehner or Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell — or Sen. Rand Paul or Rep. Paul Ryan, or almost any other prominent Republican — insists that the only way to improve the economic prospects of the American people is to impose drastic budget cuts on them. While these Republican leaders don't love the sequester budget only because it cuts too deeply into defense programs, they are eager to impose similar cuts or worse on every domestic function, from health care and education to food safety and infrastructure.
Unwilling as they usually are to name specific cuts, the Republican plans that have emerged lately are indeed similar in scope and impact to those imposed by European central bankers on Greece, Spain, Portugal, Ireland and other beleaguered states across the continent (and imposed by the British government on the United Kingdom itself).
Enacting the same fiscal policies in this country would, presumably, induce the same effects. Yet despite their enthusiasm for extreme austerity the Republican, Tea Party, and assorted media soothsayers almost never want to discuss what has happened in Europe as a result of those same policies.
It is not always possible to ignore the unhappy reality of renewed recession, from England to Italy.
Just last weekend, the British were jolted by news that Moody's had downgraded investments in their country's sovereign debt from its traditional AAA status.
Why would the bond-rating agency do something like that? Principally because the miserable budgeting of Tory Prime Minister David Cameron's government has mired the United Kingdom in negative growth,with no prospect of reducing its debt, which keeps growing. So the scheme that was supposed to improve the fiscal outlook for the British has merely lowered their credit rating. That wasn't supposed to happen — in fact, the austerity plan was designed to preserve Britain's AAA rating — but it was inevitable as soon as Downing Street chose budget-balancing over growth.
The same downward trajectory can be marked wherever the leaders of dominant Germany have forced austerity plans onto indebted governments.
So damaging has this process become for all of Europe that the Germans finally began suffering the ironic consequences in the last quarter of 2012. Their export-led growth strategies cannot work when their neighbors, reduced to poverty, can no longer purchase German goods. If German exports pick up again this year, it will only happen because customers in the U.S. and China remain exempt from the effects of austerity.
Until now, the United States has escaped the fate of Europe, remaining the "sole bright spot" of steady growth in the global economy because President Obama resisted the fiscal extremism of his Republican adversaries and contrived to ward off recession with necessary spending. Now sequestration, with all of its dire social and economic effects, will provide a taste of what is to come under Republican austerity: a shrunken nation with a dim future.
CONNECT













11 comments on "While Republicans Warn Against ‘Greece,’ That is Exactly Where Austerity Budgeting Will Lead U.S."
March 04, 2013 10:47am
I agree with all of the articles posted on NATION OF CHANGE, and would do anything in my power to to get as many other citizens as possible to read and digest them as well.
March 03, 2013 1:47pm
What a pantload. This guy has it exactly backwards. The unrest in Greece is because all the spoiled government workers have been on the gravy train for so long that they can't conceive of actually working for a living. We want to prevent this government from putting us in the position Greece was in BEFORE austerity. The sequester is not austerity at Grecian levels, it is vitally necessary to prevent HAVING to go as far Greece had to, in the future. Dimwit.
March 03, 2013 10:53am
The Patriot Act replaced the US Constitution and allows the government to take Americans into custody without probable cause and be held indefinitely incommunicado (disappear Pinochet-style).
The National Defense Authorization Act deputizes the US military to police Amerika to protect the corrupt 1% from the 99%.
Representative democracy is dead -- it was subverted over the last several decades, and the subversion is no longer being hidden but openly perpetrated by the filthy rich billionaires, millionaires, and Fortune 500 corporations and the influence-peddling politician enablers who they bought.
Welcome to the fascism described by George Orwell in 1984 and Animal Farm.
March 03, 2013 10:39am
Greece's problems in the first place were because of inadequate tax revenue--taxes were not being collected as expected because of systemic and expected fraud and evasion of taxes by everyone from the top down! More effort by the government in the years before Greece's finances toppled, to assess and collect the correct amount of tax would have been very unpopular in the good years, but, just as Republican's self-control over their urges to cut taxes and wage expensive wars, might have paid huge dividends in years to come. However, we know that the countries of the world are not run by the principles in "Poor Richard's Almanack", now, don't we?
March 03, 2013 10:35am
I have warned about this since 1974. They are pushing the middle class, trying to provoke them into revolution so they can slaughter them. The first step was to wreck their income, and their healthcare, then makes defense inaccessible by closing off protective defensive weapons.
When the people are sufficiently weak enough, the schools will turn violence upon students which has already begun in which kids from 4 years old to 9 years old were cuffed and sent to jail for kid stuff, in an effort to provoke parents enough to start a civil war, then come the armed drones and goodbye middle classes. While they are stripping America's guns the HLS has bought 2.60 Trillion rounds of .233 armor piercing ammo and millions of bullet proof vests, leg and head armor and a number of tanks. Why else would this shadow army need those things for searching airline passengers. Soon they will be stopping drivers and strip searching them for more provocation.
March 03, 2013 10:21am
We (the US) have already been downgraded by Moody's! Our debt is too much to sustain. Our paychecks in ALL of the so called "classes" of Americans have already been cut. More taxes means less money in our paychecks. The current administraion is ALL ABOUT MORE TAXES! Add to that, the unrestrained printing of counterfeit money by the privately owned and mis-named Federal Reserve bank, is causing inflation which causes a CUT in income especially in the private sector and among the middle and lower 'classes'. I don't understand bankrupting us ALL in order to support this monster government.
If the government took every penny that we all make (to include those horrible successful people) it would still not be enough to satisfy the rapacious appetite of a government addicted to spending. Do we really need to study the effects of drugs/alcohol on sex workers in Thailand? There are millions of dollars being wasted by the government on stupid stuff like this example. Yet we have people actually making the argument AGAINST reining in this extravagant spending! Unbelievable.
March 03, 2013 6:55pm
So you're ok with the billions spent on drones and waging futile wars thousands of miles from home?
The reason your country is in the current crisis is thanks to eight years of mismanagement by Bush jnr thats why Obama was re-elected. Republicans are all about "personal responsibility" code words for it's your fault if you're doing it tough even though it was corporate America which sent all your jobs offshore .
The Republicans always have the same agenda, no tax for billionaires , corporate welfare on a grand scale, keep the minimum wage at a level so low people have to live in their cars.
If any of those messages fail the old backup always works god, guns, and abortion.
America is what you get when Corporations and lobbyists run your country.
March 03, 2013 10:20am
As I have said since 2003. Obama is one with the Tea Party as sure as I am Pete. The only way out of the mess is to dump Bernanke, who twisted Milton Friedman's QE. Milton Friedman said "drop the money out of helicopters to the people, not to the banks, and poof the depression is gone. The lie of Bernanke is the opposite, Throw the trillions (right now $27 Trillions) have gone to the banks draining the middle class of which both he and Obama and the Tea party wish to to be rid.
March 03, 2013 10:18am
When I was in high school, tax rate for the super wealthy was up to 90%. Then it was dropped to 70% in the 70s then to 33% during Bush with so many loopholes that resembles a bird cage: where the illusion is that all pay taxes but the super wealthy can hide their income in places we cannot fathom. If we want a stable, sustainable society, we must make those who derive most from government services, especially the military industrial complex, pay their fair share instead of playing with words and twisted arguments (Newspeak). Most government services are geared towards protecting the wealthy. The poor has almost nothing to lose. That is why the tax system is supposed to be progressive. Those who do not need the income should be taxed very high so the incentive to keep hoarding disappears and with it, a more stable, humane society emerge with a functional government representing all, not just the 1%.
March 03, 2013 7:12pm
Well said Norman, the Right have twisted the message about taxes with various approaches right back to Reagans "trickle down" now it's class war, or taxing success.
As long as you have Tea party crackpots ,and religious nuts in congress it's not looking good.
March 03, 2013 10:06am
The Republicans want to cut , but not the military and Homeland Security budgets - to ensure they have the power to enforce the cuts to the people .