Whistleblower Brad Birkenfeld Gets Record $104M for Exposing How UBS Helped Rich Evade Taxes
The IRS has announced a record $104 million reward to a whistleblower who exposed the largest tax evasion scheme in U.S. history. Former UBS AG banker Brad Birkenfeld first reported in 2007 that he and his colleagues had encouraged rich Americans to store more than $20 billion in offshore Swiss bank accounts and cheat the IRS. But after coming forward, Birkenfeld was prosecuted and convicted of conspiracy and sentenced to prison. Following Birkenfeld’s release last month, on Tuesday the IRS vindicated his actions with the largest amount ever awarded under its whistleblower program. We’re joined by Stephen Kohn, an attorney for Birkenfeld and executive director of the National Whistleblowers Center.
Transcript
NERMEEN SHAIKH: We turn now to a major development in the case of a banking whistleblower. Former UBS AG banker Brad Birkenfeld first reported in 2007 that he and his colleagues had encouraged rich Americans to store more than $20 billion in offshore Swiss bank accounts and cheat the IRS. After he came forward, he was convicted of conspiracy and sentenced to prison. Well, he was released from prison in August, and on Tuesday the IRS vindicated his actions with a $104 million award under the IRS whistleblower program.
AMY GOODMAN: UBS ultimately paid $780 million to resolve the investigation, admitted to criminal wrongdoing, and closed the unit where Birkenfeld worked. His disclosure also prompted at least 33,000 Americans to report offshore accounts to the IRS, generating more than $5 billion. The IRS is now investigating at least 11 other banks.
We’re going directly to Washington, D.C., to Stephen Kohn, co-counsel for UBSwhistleblower Brad Birkenfeld, also executive director of the National Whistleblowers Center and the author of The Whistleblower’s Handbook: A Step-by-Step Guide to Doing What’s Right and Protecting Yourself. Birkenfeld himself is under home confinement after getting out of jail, not authorized by the Bureau of Prisons to do interviews, now seeking a presidential pardon.
Stephen Kohn, welcome back to Democracy Now! Talk about this unprecedented award to Brad Birkenfeld, who has just gotten out of jail.
STEPHEN KOHN: Well, it’s the largest whistleblower award in history, but it’s—Birkenfeld turned in the largest financial frauds. He turned in 19,000 felons and $20 billion in one unit. But we also know 33,000 people are turning themselves in and that the total amount of U.S. dollars in illegal offshore accounts is over $5 trillion. That’s the estimation from a Senate report. What the IRS did was try to change the dynamic. When the Justice Department prosecuted Bradley Birkenfeld in one of the most absurd and misguided efforts, they took an asset, a person who turned in the keys to the kingdom, the first whistleblower to expose exactly how illegal Swiss banking worked and illegal offshore banking was working across the world, and instead of using him, they persecuted him. The IRS is now turning that around.
The IRS—I think one of the reasons they had to give such a big award is because they need informants. They need other bankers to step forward. And what the Justice Department did had a devastating impact on their whistleblower program. So they’ve turned around, and they’ve given the largest whistleblower award ever. We worked on that for over three years, through the process, trying to make sure he won, because his victory is really a victory against offshore illegal banking, where millionaires and billionaires stash their wealth, where corrupt politicians put in their money, drug dealers. When you’re looking at this illegal offshore banking, it’s really a handmaiden to corruption. So it’s extremely important public policy, public interest, to go to war against these banks. So, this award to Mr. Birkenfeld, in our view, is one of the most important step forwards to try to induce other bankers to step forward and really tackle illegal offshore banking.
NERMEEN SHAIKH: Well, Stephen Kohn, offshore tax havens have recently come under increasing focus because of Republican presidential nominee Mitt Romney’s foreign accounts. Earlier this summer, he defended his foreign investments during an interview with Radio Iowa.
MITT ROMNEY: With regards to any foreign investments, I understand and you understand, of course, that my investments have been held by a blind trust, have been managed by a trustee. I don’t manage them, don’t even know where they are. Those—that trustee follows all U.S. laws. All the taxes are paid, as appropriate. All of them have been reported to the government. There’s nothing hidden there. There’s nothing. If, for instance, you own shares in, let’s say, Renault or in Fiat, you still have to pay taxes, you still have to disclose that in the United States.
NERMEEN SHAIKH: That was Republican presidential nominee Mitt Romney speaking earlier this summer. Stephen Kohn, can you talk about the significance of this case and how it relates to what Mitt Romney said?
STEPHEN KOHN: Well, first, to clarify, we don’t have—this isn’t an anti-Romney campaign, and we don’t have any direct information about candidate Romney. But I want to talk about how the Swiss banking system works, illegal offshore banking works. There’s two ways it happens. First is, you have a direct account sitting in the bank. You’re trading stocks or gaining interest or whatever. And that was the $20 billion program. The second way is they do set up trusts, offshore trusts in which an American invests in the trust. So you give them a million dollars, and the trustee runs the investments. These are often usually illegal, because the trustee gives the American investor a one-step removal from the actual illegal activities and a method to deny involvement. It also gets very hard to track this money, because if you just put a million dollars into a trust that says has $200 million in assets, how do you follow that money, which may go to one or two or three offshore locations?
AMY GOODMAN: We have five seconds.
STEPHEN KOHN: Yeah, Birkenfeld turned all that in. But to say—I just want to emphasize, this is not an anti-Romney thing, but it does call for more investigation.
AMY GOODMAN: Stephen Kohn, we want to thank you for being with us. I want to encourage people to go to our website today at democracynow.org. Juan González has written a piece in the New York Daily News, as he continues to follow this case. Stephen Kohn, co-counsel for UBS whistleblower Brad Birkenfeld, executive director of the National Whistleblowers Center. And that does it for our broadcast.
We are on our Silenced Majority Tour, an election 2012 tour, continues this week. On Thursday, I’ll be at the Philadelphia Free Library; then go to Pittsburgh at McConomy Auditorium at Carnegie Mellon; on Friday at 5:00 p.m. in Cleveland, at 8:00 p.m. at Oberlin College; Kenyon College noon on Saturday. And we’ll bemoving on from there.
CONNECT














11 comments on "Whistleblower Brad Birkenfeld Gets Record $104M for Exposing How UBS Helped Rich Evade Taxes"
September 17, 2012 10:45am
When is Obama going to get rid of the useless AG Holder and get someone with hutzpah in that office?
September 16, 2012 5:47pm
I think we have as good movement going. And I don't think it will be stopped by any 'filibuster' in Congress. Two things the IRS likes. One is catching cheaters and the other is MONEY.
September 16, 2012 5:00pm
I am unclear as to why mr. Birkenfeld was imprisoned in the first place. What were the charges?
September 16, 2012 8:17pm
He tried to protect his favorite billionaire, by not telling the entire truth about him. Kind of what all prostitutors, I mean, prosecutors do, to little guys who don't turn in all their family members when the catch em dealin a pound or so of pot each month. They give em 40 years, then bragg about it, even laughing at times, at how they just ruined an entire family, for one of the family members single indescretion. Our prisons are full of cases like this, but not 1 of the 33,000 millionaires who were busted for hiding their money from our government, spent an entire single day in jail.
September 16, 2012 4:21pm
I'm glad the idiots are concentrating on the $104 million doallar reward and not on the fact he saved the US government 25 trilliuon in hidden and unreported income.This is the reason the US is broke not foolish government spending but rich people cheating the government and this country out of tax dollars.I've read other reports that as much as 35 trillion is being hidden by the rich and corporations overseas.The US needs more whistleblowers to stop fraud and corruption in the US instead of punishing the people working for the good of the country unlike the republicans and so called "moderate" Democrats
September 16, 2012 6:33pm
Hey Albert, if you want to trade insults I'm happy to point out the stupidity of those who cannot see that paying one whistle-blower $104 million is excessive, and that paying it is A POOR SUBSTITUTE for (1) paying more whistle-blowers lesser sums, and more importantly, (2) prosecuting thousands of rich people and corporations for tax evasion. The whole point is that this one case led to the recovery of $5 billion, but Congress and the Exec branch DOJ and IRS have done next to nothing to recover the hundreds of billions of taxes dodged by the rich and US-based corporations as a result of those trillions in hidden income and assets you mention. In other words, the $104 million is window-dressing, a PR stunt, and the idiots are those it dupes into thinking the problem is being addressed.
September 16, 2012 4:20pm
Summary:
He turned in 19,000 felons and 20 billion dollars in 1 unit.
UBS ultimately paid $780 million to resolve investigation.
UBS closed the unit in which he worked.
Prompted 33,000 people to turn themselves in, gererating more than 5 billion dollars.
IRS is investigating 11 other banks and the off-shore trusts, which are described as usually Illegal (as used by Rommney? Investigation?).
Total amount of US dollars in illegal off shore accounts is over 5 trillion dollars which the IRS is now going after.
Looks like plenty of damage to the 1% involved in these schemes followed from Birkenfeld's action and he deserves every penny of the reward. How someone could conclude otherwise is just amazing.
September 16, 2012 12:41pm
Does he have to pay taxes on that $104m?
I hope he will use some of it to support causes like G.A.P -Government Accountability Project - which specifically supports whistleblowers in all areas of government and industry, both here and internationally - see whistleblower.org. (Of course maybe they already helped him - don't know.)
September 16, 2012 11:15am
I agree with greghilbert. It is excessive. So excessive, in fact, it likely encourages this scenario as a strategy to become ludicrously wealthy:
1) become an investment banker
2) help investors cheat and help your superiors handsomely glean from the spoils
3) turn them in
Problem is, the investors and the financial brass don't even get fines as much as they got away with and they don't go to jail. It's a win all the way around for the 1%.
More appropriate would have been prosecution of UBS directors, a pardon, reimbursement for any and all financial and health hits taken due to having been prosecuted and incarcerated, and a 1 million dollar reward.
September 16, 2012 10:23am
I'm glad Birkenfeld did what he did, and that he was given a substantial reward that might encourage others to blow whistles, but I think $104 MILLION excessive
even after I consider his legal expenses. $104 MILLION?
The mega-reward strikes me as designed by IRS (and the wealthy oligarchs and governmental/political elites who serve them) to distract our attention from all that is NOT being done to address tax evasion by the wealthy and US-based international corporations.
September 16, 2012 9:54am
An icy cold chill just went through all the "blue" blood out there.