Isaiah J. Poole
Published: Sunday 3 June 2012
“If we are really serious about standing up against the unholy alliance of conservative extremism and corporate money that has imposed an austerity agenda on the working class while further enriching the wealthy, then we need to help the people in Wisconsin who are trying against the odds to win this Wisconsin recall.”

Wisconsin Recall: A Battle We Can’t Afford to Lose

Article image

For the progressive movement, it's put up or shut up time in Wisconsin.

We said that we despise the agenda of Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker. We cheered the thousands of people who occupied the state capitol in 2011 to protest Walker's ramming legislation crippling public employee unions through the legislature. We celebrated when a legislature recall election led to the ousting of two of the state senators who backed the legislation. And we were bolstered when a record number of signatures put a Walker recall election on the ballot.

But now that it's crunch time, we are dangerously close to losing it all. And the consequences of a recall defeat are almost impossible to overstate. Imagine the gloating on Fox News and the right-wing blogs if Walker wins on Tuesday, and the claims that our insurgent movement for rebuilding the middle class is bloodied and can be left for dead.

If we are really serious about standing up against the unholy alliance of conservative extremism and corporate money that has imposed an austerity agenda on the working class while further enriching the wealthy, then we need to help the people in Wisconsin who are trying against the odds to win this Wisconsin recall.

We're asking people this weekend to sign up with Worker's Voice and contribute time to help get out the vote against Walker.

Workers' Voice is a new political action committee affiliated with the AFL-CIO that offers get-out-the-vote tools that leverage the power of your social networks with information in the voter file.

You can help identify voters, make phone calls, or send your own personalized direct mail to people you know. And you can do it all from home, no matter where you live. And in an election race that polls suggest could go either way, every phone call, every email, every knock on a door will matter.

What has me particularly fired up is an article progressive commentator Sally Kohn has posted on The Daily Beast, with a headline that claims "Democrats Lose Momentum in Wisconsin: The left has seemed more comfortable being angry than channeling that emotion into influence."

I respect Sally Kohn and think she's a smart political analyst. But I would really like to see her proved wrong.

Her sense is that grassroots progressives did a good job pulling together a movement based on opposition to Walker's policies—not just on labor rights but also on a budget that, like national conservative policies, cuts services vital to the middle class and poor while cutting taxes to the wealthy and corporations. But the momentum fell apart when it came time to take that energy and translate it into actual change at the ballot box.

"Progressives have had a far harder time yoking grassroots activism to electoral politics than conservatives, who quickly managed to translate Tea Party rabble rousing into political power," Kohn writes.

It is true that progressives need a more solid strategy for electoral and political gains in the face of how, with the aid of the Citizens United ruling, the right and its corporate backers have dominated the political landscape. That is a key focus of the Take Back the American Dream conference, where many of the plenary meetings and strategy sessions will be focused both on how progressives can score gains in the November elections and on how progressives can affect the course of economic policy during December's "taxmageddon," when Congress must decide how to handle the expiration of the Bush tax cuts, payroll tax relief and a deal on federal spending.

But, as The Nation's John Nichols told me in my interview with him today, people power has already accomplished more in Wisconsin than skeptics in either the left or the right expected. As he reminds us, the Capitol protests were supposed to quickly fizzle, but they didn't. The public was supposed to massively turn against supporters of public employees, but they didn't. The Walker recall was expected to flail in the midst of the harsh Wisconsin winter. It didn't.

So now we come to this moment, where it will become clear to the nation whether the 99 percent can in fact use people power to push back against the 1 percent and insist on government policies that restore a measure of prosperity to the majority of Americans, not just those at the very top.

Workers Voice is one way you can help, but it is of course not the only way. However you choose to get involved, this is the time to move from the sideline to the front line.

Then, at our Take Back the American Dream conference, we can do the work of building on a Wisconsin victory. That conference will feature Paul Krugman, Van Jones, Sen. Bernie Sanders, Ai-jen Poo, Sandra Fluke, Gov. Howard Dean, Melissa Harris-Perry, Chris Hayes and Katrina vanden Heuvel. (Click here to register.)

When you consider all that is at stake throughout the country, as conservatives continue their assault on worker's rights and economic security at both the state and national level, we literally cannot afford to lose on Tuesday.



Get Email Alerts from NationofChange

Top Stories

38 comments on "Wisconsin Recall: A Battle We Can’t Afford to Lose"

Chris Wilborn

June 06, 2012 8:49am

There will ALWAYS be a need for Unions. BUT, not the powerful ones we have now. Just like our TOO Powerful Federal Government, they both need to be taken down several pegs.
Unions, will be very hard to tame. The Federal Government, I'm afraid, will be near impossible.

TheodoreRooseve...

June 05, 2012 10:08pm

The PEOPLE of Wisconsin have spoken!!! Thank you Scott Walker for not turning our state into Illinois or California!

Joe Specht

June 04, 2012 2:48pm

Natural and Unnatural Rights and the “Right” to Collective Bargaining:

A child is born and has natural rights such as the right to protect himself from the world. He also has the rights to move about freely, associate freely, and speak his mind against his government without fear of recrimination. He has the right not to be searched or to have his property seized or to be tried other than by his peers or without due process. Yes, all of these rights seem natural and it seems proper to consider these the natural rights of all people.

Once they become adults, people are free to negotiate in commerce and elsewhere, and are free to negotiate the terms of their employment. If they own businesses that employ people, they are free to negotiate with employees these terms of employment. These, too, should be considered natural rights that free people should possess—whether employee or employer.

But then, about one hundred years ago—well into the industrial age—employers were deemed to be taking advantage of employees and great theories of social inequality took root. One particular result was the creation of a collective bargaining right that forces employers to negotiate with all of their employees as a single entity. While this right obviously sounds good to some people, it should be clear that it provides an unequal coercive power to the group of employees over the employer. (If, at the use of this disgusting term employer, you feel the need to use alternate terms such as "fat cat" or "greedy bastard", feel free. It won’t affect the conclusion.) If a large corporation such as General Motors is faced with a walkout by its entire workforce, thus costing it perhaps hundreds of millions of dollars, GM is likely to provide whatever salary and benefits are demanded by the group in order to avoid a prolonged shutdown. If defined honestly, this is called coercion. In other quarters it is called a right.

When the employer happens to be an elected official or government bureaucrat, the negotiations are so much the easier because the employer has no need to make a profit and, better yet, is now negotiating with other people’s money. (There may even be instances of buying votes by over-giving during negotiations (gasp), but we can leave that phenomenon alone for now.) After such negotiations continue for a sufficient number of decades and with an ever-growing group of employees, it eventually (as in “now”) becomes clear to any sensible and intelligent person with a calculator that the promises that have been made by politicians—the most glaring these days being pension obligations—are impossible to keep. This is the eventual consequence of the enforcement of an unnatural law during the eight or so decades when most citizens weren’t paying very close attention to the cookie jar.

I don’t blame people who are facing stagnating wages and reductions to pension and healthcare benefits for being mad. But they should be mad at the politicians who over-promised with other people’s money rather than at those other people (more commonly called taxpayers, stooges, or stupes) who can no longer pay the tab. And as for the completely lopsided right to collective bargaining, it will eventually go away, simply because we as a group can no longer afford it. As can be seen by the heat in Wisconsin, though, it is unlikely to go away through calm realization and concessions by the overpaid and over-benefitted. It is almost certain that it will go away only through a very long period of ugliness and likely, before it is over, violence.

Free Market Underdog

Keith Hardwick

June 04, 2012 4:00am

Make this story go viral in Wisconsin NOW:
http://uppitywis.org/blogarticle/university-minnesota-scientist-drops-bo...

safara

June 03, 2012 7:28pm

Obviously the Dems in Wisconsin were massively out spent by conservatives. The recall effort became an experiment to determine whether an honest grass roots effort could be mounted to overcome the power of money. The Democratic Party in the state is made up of a dedicated core surrounded by a fearful, play it safe body that has been beguiled by promised lower taxes and uncertainites about losing what they think they have. Add the ties of the Party itself to dependence upon Big Money, lack of imagination, and the nagging reality that they may not win and malaise and resignation surface. Yes, we may not win but there should be a plan for for another battle.

joe baublis

June 03, 2012 9:08pm

I'm so sorry that you characterize it as a battle, because that implies warfare. Can't you find some comfort in the notion that the People who vote are making a decision? Both sides had a chance to promote their agenda and now it's up to the voters to decide. It's not a battle, it's democracy.

Richard Townsend

June 04, 2012 6:42am

No, It's our brand of Democracy that assumes Capitalism is the only economic system available where those Oligarchs who have profited most from the system are ordained as the sacred leadership who are true of heart and without sin. Any attempt to question or change this system is immediately dismissed as blasphemy and the inquirers are banished from the public square as their questions are replaced with far more pressing issues like; What serving size of soft drinks is too much ?

louis r

June 03, 2012 7:37pm

Always "another battle," Always "losing the war" AND the "battles."
Might as well be sharecropping.
Lackeys

bladtheimpailer

June 03, 2012 5:55pm

I'm getting a feeling that somewhere the fix is in. It may be close but in some back room the Dems have been persuaded not to fight too hard, or only hard enough just to lose. This call to progressive people to help try to save the day shows that the Democratic party machine has not been unleashed to win in what you would think was an imperative situation. Those good people of Wisconsin who have tried so very hard are about to learn that the two party system is in reality fake, a sham and a fraud on the American body politic. But all is not lost forever. What those good people did discover was their power. It's just that in this case they've been played for fools. Next time they'll make sure to have their own candidates and party, not the Democrats. Guess we'll all find out on Tuesday.

Richard Townsend

June 04, 2012 7:05am

Remember that this republic started out with everyone being a Republican because we were a Republic, but one ruling force sounded too much like a dictatorship or a monarchy to a population that was not that far removed from the Oligarchical rule in Europe. By the middle of the 19th century the oligarchs and the bankers decided that they needed to create the illusion of Democracy by creating an opposing political entity called the Democrats because we claimed to be a Democracy. One hundred and fifty years later and we are still embracing this duopoly ruled by the same oligarchs that created it. Five, six, seven political entities are not uncommon in Democracies in other parts of the world. Are they messy, of course they are. a true Democracy is a messy form of government because the fight against oligarchs, concentrated wealth, and authoritarian thinking never really ends !

louis r

June 03, 2012 6:16pm

Don't BLAME the media, don't blame the SCOTUS, don't blame the "big money," don't blame the VOTERS, don't blame the GOP or the TP...
Don't blame Walker....BLAME the Dems!!!

Ha, ha...TYPICAL.
Yes, you have a point that the Dems are GOP in DRAG, but...not all and to SUGGEST it the is "Democratsthat are causing the problem" is to PROVE you are either a "plant" (What get PAID to add troll crap to the sites?) or you are a comic book junkie or you are downright DELUDED.

"Not the Dems?" What MAYBE the GOP? YOUR party?
NEVER, freaks like YOU have been FODDER for the GOP for too long WAKE-UP worker. You do work, right?

joe baublis

June 03, 2012 9:03pm

I don't call it work. I prefer to describe myself as a service provide who is compensated by mutual consent of the beneficiary.

louis r

June 03, 2012 5:16pm

They voted for this freak, not thinking he would go after them. They say 39% of UNION people are pro-Walker. Now, there IS some degree of logic to reducing 90% salaries to RETIRED cops, firefighters, etc. Cost of living increases EVERY year?
Seems FAIR to reduce these "cushy" pensions, considering, huh? BUT, to get rid of collective bargaining, to get elected on a "jobs" platform and an "anti-Obamacare" ticket.. (suckers), then BE CAUGHT lying to congressional committees, supporting the monied interests (Koch conversation, or the wealthy SCUZZBALL woman billionaire), well THAT seems to suggest Sociopathy and downright GRIFT.
But the voters, VOTED this creep in. They got their heads bumped and NOW, over time they are getting convinced that he is the "best thing" since "white bread."

If he gets to keep his office, unions, progressives, liberals and working-class (including YOU "wanna be middle-class), are TOAST!!

Bring your jam and butter, fools. You SHOULD have been EDUCATING these "citizens" rather than "laughing" and whining at the "nutty" GOP.
Who are the nuts? You will see.
Blame the dummy voters. But, in REALITY Walker is sleaze, as are the others who got elected in 2010.
Conned you fools. Good talkers, sociopaths with agendas and BIG money backing them, masquerading as "everday people" with a grudge.
The Tea Party Express conjob, courtesy of the big money marketing and advertising PhDs.
You are DONE wortking class get used to it. Now let's get back to blaming Greece or China for this country's mismanagement.

bladtheimpailer

June 03, 2012 5:53pm

Louis R, Really want to know why the country is in so much financial trouble causing us all to be looking at what the other guy earns and setting us one against the other (divide and conquer). Go to You Tube, type in "The Secret of Oz" and take the time to watch it. You'll be amazed at what you will learn...

louis r

June 03, 2012 6:10pm

Here is one for you...http://www.marxist.com

Try this one: Richard D Wolff, http://www.rdwolff.com/articles/16

Try this: Real World Economics Review
Try this: http://lawanddisorder.org

Try: rtnews.org,

Try: Press TV, and LISTEN to those programs!!

There are TOO many sources to discuss. I will look at your "You Tube CLIP" to "teach" me something about "how the world works."
You are kidding, right?

We are TOAST as a nation. Lost in a Disneyland shuffle. Have NO CLUE how to solve these "issues" we have ignored for so long. Much of our confusion based on ideology, i.e., GREED, RACISM,HATE. and ignorance.

Done, as a nation. This is merely "window-dressing" folks. You know, throw some make-up on the face, fluff up the pillows, everybody smiles and tells "dying dad" "It will get better, hang in there tough guy."

BS, is what GOT the country into this mess. NO MORE BS, folks.
Otherwise THIS "experiment" is done in another fifty.

Richard Townsend

June 04, 2012 7:34am

Professor Wolff makes a good point, we have never been allowed to have a discussion on Capitalism, even questioning this system brings on charges of blasphemy. Strange for a government that micromanages everything to the point of how much water should be allowed to fill a toilet. But no real discussion of a financial system that has forced the average American to endure eleven major recessions and two devastating depressions over the past eighty years. I have a few years under my belt and it has always amazed me how fast things improve when the public is driven to take a hard look at their Capitalist economic system ! Considering the past record of the Capitalist, Professor Wolff should consider a bullet proof vest. John Kennedy paid the ultimate price for just mentioning the abolishment of the Federal Reserve ! An important point for all Americans to consider: DEMOCRACY IS NOT SYNONYMOUS WITH CAPITALISM !

dwdallam

June 03, 2012 3:58pm

The way I see it, if the people of WI vote to keep Walker, then they shouldn't cry when he jams a big red, white and blue dick up their asses. If the people want Walker and his policies, then they should have him--and the consequences that follow.

What's interesting is that police and firemen who supported walker were all ok with union busting--until it came to their homes. Fuck you. I hope you get what you deserve, hypocrites.

joe baublis

June 03, 2012 8:57pm

It's only been a year. Why not give him till the end of his term and then judge the results. At least he balanced the budget. Isn't that a good thing? I believe the WI unemployment rate is also going down. That's good, right? And although union workers may be upset, isn't the real question what the People of the State think?

louis r

June 03, 2012 5:57pm

You and me brother. Two of us see this. Anymore out there? As usual the police and firefighters (oh and TP nurses), who most often VOTE GOP (TP this go round), and the other "middle-class"government workers, happy to blame those who HELP employ them (lower-class, poor, minority, old. etc),NEVER saw this coming...That is why they are mad.
It was OK when they blamed "those" people.
You are RIGHT, these "working people" FORGET what class consciousness is BECAUSE they have been taught that"we work" and the others do not.
You are right, I HOPE Walker winds BIG TIME and destroys these old "cushy" jobs and pensions, then we will not IDOLIZE the usual "first responderS" who frankly, are not respondingt for NEED to "help the sick or downtroddden"but the help their OWN pocketbooks and families.
Who does NOT know that?
Yeah these fools VOTED GOP/TP...NOW they cry. Thought it was a joke, huh fools?
You will SEE!! and you will ose to THAT BIG money. Go back and watch some crap on TV while you eat that crap, talk crap and play with little "Jonnie's crap," so HE can grow up to be just as worthless.

Riconui

June 03, 2012 12:47pm

If there is a failure in the Democratic/progressive movement, and there has been quite a bit in the ranks of the elected Dems and at the party level, it comes back ultimately to the rank and file. When has the Democratic base (such as it is) been able or willing to hold their elected reps feet to the fire? Why is it that Dems have the numbers in registration but something like a third of them don't vote? Why is it that Dems as a group cannot seem to be bothered with knowing their issues when there is no election pending? Elect 'em and forget 'em seems to be the operative terms in most instances. When was the last time you stayed quiet when some limbaugh spouting jackass went on with their demented platitudes. Speak up, show up (at the polls) At it's most fundamental level, politics is the conversation we are having, not the assholes that are occupying the seats of power. Problem is, conservatives are not interested in conversation, they want power and they want it all and they want it right now. Dems are content to go on believing that republicators are reasonable and what's happening in American politics is just a difference of opinion and once everyone's thought are clear, we'll all compromise and we can go back to our daily mucking about. Wrong! If you want to win an argument with a conservative, you need to so paddle their candidates at the polls that it leaves no doubt that there is no compromise with bullshit and inanity, there is no compromise with institutionalizing poverty and misery, there is no compromise with abject war mongering or attempts to gut the public school system and the list goes on. We live in an occupied territory. It is time for a counter occupation, occupy everywhere!

steveh

June 03, 2012 12:32pm

It's perfectly understandable that the movement to remove Walker is backsliding. To make a prediction, it's a preview of the national elections in November. After all, what are people's choices? We have been forced by the media and our own fears to choose between a Republican and a Democrat and the leaders of both parties have consistently demonstrated that they will only support Big Business. So why should progressives participate when the shaft they'll get just comes wrapped in a slightly different package? At least the Repugnicans don't try to feign loyalty to the People unlike the two-faced Democrats. Still, both choices suck mud.

BozoAdult

June 03, 2012 1:09pm

But in not removing Walker we damage the unions. Unions are the only balance to the new corporate power in a Citizens United world.

joe baublis

June 03, 2012 8:52pm

Oh man, I'm totally on the other side. I don't want to be a united world, I want our States to re-assert their constitutional sovereignty.

belleville

June 03, 2012 10:43am

I hope Walker gets thrown out big time. He is a Crook, Liar, Thief, and a 1% backer. I hope he gets less than 20% of the vote. This is the First step in getting our country back from these money grubbing Republicans. These bastards have no compassion for the rest of the country. All they care about is money, money, money. Win Wisconsin and then get the Republicans out of Congress. The Democratic Party is the Party of the people. God Bless the 99%.

Jeffrey Hill

June 03, 2012 10:26am

The Walker recall is about the billionaire Kochroaches, et. al. buying government to transform a One Man, One Vote democratic republic into a One Dollar, One Vote fascist plutocracy.

joe baublis

June 03, 2012 8:48pm

Fascist plutocracy? That's a good one. I don't see fascism in America because we've been a melting pot for so long that it would be impossible to develop a pure race. However, we may develop into a single party totalitarian government. We're not immune. And it's entirely possible that the right to vote will be rescinded at the Federal level. I've read that international creditors used national debt as a means to restrict personal liberties - like voting.

Cedar Cat

June 03, 2012 10:19am

Wow, did you get that from Fox News?

Did you see the video of Walker promising to bust the unions and make WI a "right to work" state to a multi-millionaire supporter?

This was never about any budget issues, but about enriching the corporate masters, who pay the bills and are funding massive TV advertising, through the Koch foundations and the Chamber of Commerce.

joe baublis

June 03, 2012 8:13pm

I also saw data indicating that rust belt region governments are largely controlled by unions and those states have dramatically higher debts and higher unemployment rates. Whereas right to work states had lower debts, and lower unemployment.

Here's a link to the unions insurance scam :

http://townhall.com/columnists/kyleolson/2011/02/23/insurance_scam_drivi...

Richard Townsend

June 04, 2012 7:58am

. . . creates an environment for working people where they are essentially endentured servants with no chance for a secure life for themselves or their families. Boss Hogg is still alive and well in these states ! This promotes a working environment where working people turn on each other to please their masters and protect their jobs for yet another week. Employers hiring a private police force and private detectives to monitor free behavior and invoking scare campaigns when there's the slightest chance that their slaves may be considering union representation. I've been there before. This sounds more like a Fascist dictatorship than a so-called Democracy !

joe baublis

June 03, 2012 10:05am

This is hogwash. Walker discovered that the State employees unions - essentially - had rigged up a secret health care system and concealed it under the guise of s0-called "collective bargaining". The scam was revealed, and it was found to have been the primary cause of Wisconsin's $3 billion debt. When the unions were forced to provide competitive free-market health care the State saved the debt within months and developed a surplus.
As such, the recall effort must be viewed as a scam to defraud the People of Wisconsin out of their tax dollars.

louis r

June 03, 2012 6:26pm

See, YOU are the problem. YOU are an example of MANY in this country. You work (maybe) raise a family( maybe), then you "relax" by watching the news on TV or listening to your FAVORITE "pundit." Well, we can see WHOO you FOLLOW.
YES follow. THAT is YOUR problem "easily led."
You got a computer LOOK UP your comments, LOOK UP the subject in which you speak. NOT on YOUR "favorite right-wing" site (the problem) but on OTHERS to get a LARGER perspective.
What...too lazy? Or is it arrogant? Or both?

Oh yeah YOU "know" it all already. My faulrt. I am the idiot. You are the "wise one."

Shit.

joe baublis

June 03, 2012 8:15pm

I'm sensing that you have negative emotions. Please be peaceful and calm down.

Louie

June 03, 2012 11:53am

Joe, go watch Fox News...although...how can I put it... studies show that it makes people stupid, and you've already reached that life-goal you had set yourself.

joe baublis

June 03, 2012 8:32pm

Fox is too boring anymore. I prefer the History Channel "Ancient Aliens". Those stone monuments at Puma Punku are totally weird. How could cave people have possibly carved diorite 20,000 years ago? I did read one of the studies claiming that conservatives are less intelligent than liberals. I also read about the European social scientist who admitted to having fudged his data for 20 years in efforts to promote his liberal social theories. And as I recall, there were also some reports of conspiracy fraud in the United Nations to promote the global warming theory. Instead of Fox, I suggest Kerry Cassidy's "projectcamelot" site is pretty interesting , especially the "whistle blowers". Alex Jones and Michael Savage are fun too because they expose dastardly corruption in the government.

pitch1934

June 03, 2012 11:07am

Joe, post a link to your story for proof. Otherwise, shut the hel;l; up. You don't know what you are talking about. Walker is on record (off-the record) that his aim was to destroy the public unions. He did not campaing on the m atter you mentioned andhe did not campaing on destroyinbg collective bargaining in WI. His aim, as recorded is to make WI a right-to-work state. Which means the employer gets to work ytou when, for how long he/she wishes and there is no guarantee of hors. Wake the fuck up!

joe baublis

June 03, 2012 8:12pm

Here's a link. This is old news.

http://townhall.com/columnists/kyleolson/2011/02/23/insurance_scam_drivi...

joe baublis

June 03, 2012 8:36pm

And on the issue of your employer, I suggest that you employ yourself. That's what Amercia is about. You sell your own service or product to the highest bidder. If you want to be an employee, that's fine, but that's your choice.

TheodoreRooseve...

June 05, 2012 10:03pm

Amen!