GOP’s ‘fiscal sanity’ plan under fire for targeting Social Security and Medicare amidst 2024 electoral battle

This 180-page document proposes significant reforms to these cornerstone programs, stirring a debate that resonates deeply with American seniors and their advocates.


The Republican Study Committee (RSC) has unveiled a contentious budget proposal for fiscal year 2025, dubbed “Fiscal Sanity to Save America,” which has ignited a firestorm of criticism from Social Security and Medicare defenders. This 180-page document proposes significant reforms to these cornerstone programs, stirring a debate that resonates deeply with American seniors and their advocates.

Central to the RSC’s plan are sections dedicated to “Saving Medicare” and “Preventing Biden’s Cuts to Social Security.” The proposed measures include advocating for premium support for Medicare Advantage plans, a move that would see a greater role for private health insurance providers in administering Medicare benefits. Additionally, the plan suggests recalibrating Social Security benefits, tying the retirement age to life expectancy, and reducing benefits for younger workers with higher income levels, including a phase-out of auxiliary benefits.

Nancy Altman, president of Social Security Works, was quick to lambast the RSC’s budget, highlighting its potential impact on beneficiaries. “This budget would raise the retirement age… It would make annual cost-of-living increases stingier, so that benefits erode over time,” Altman stated, pointing to the detrimental effects on seniors’ financial security.

The political implications of the RSC’s proposal have not gone unnoticed, with Biden campaign communications director Michael Tyler linking the plan to former President Donald Trump’s agenda. “Donald Trump’s MAGA allies in Congress made it clear today: A vote for Trump is a vote to make the MAGA 2025 agenda of cutting Social Security, ripping away access to IVF, and banning abortion nationwide a hellish reality,” Tyler remarked, emphasizing the stakes of the upcoming election.

The RSC’s budget document, incorporating 285 bills and initiatives from 192 members, extends beyond Social Security and Medicare to encompass various proposals that would affect reproductive rights and healthcare privatization. Critics argue that the plan reflects a broader GOP strategy to dismantle the social safety net in favor of privatization and reduced government spending on social welfare programs.

Amidst the backdrop of an impending electoral battle, the RSC’s budget proposal has become a lightning rod for controversy, symbolizing the deep ideological divide between Republicans and Democrats on the future of America’s social welfare system.

As Nancy Altman’s said: “Everyone who cares about the future of these vital earned benefits should vote accordingly in November.”


If you liked this article, please donate $5 to keep NationofChange online through November.

Previous articleApologists for Israel’s mass murder in Gaza fall back on ‘antisemitism’ claims
Next articleIf America were a Trumpian autocracy
Alexis Sterling is a seasoned War and Human Rights Reporter with a passion for reporting the truth in some of the world's most tumultuous regions. With a background in journalism and a keen interest in international affairs, Alexis's reporting is grounded in a commitment to human rights and a deep understanding of the complexities of global conflicts. Her work seeks to give voice to the voiceless and bring to light the human stories behind the headlines. Alexis is dedicated to responsible and engaged journalism, constantly striving to inform and educate the public on critical issues of war and human rights across the globe.