
Oregon's highest court heard arguments on Nov. 3 in a case that could determine whether the electric utility PacifiCorp must pay more than $1 billion in awards over wildfires that struck the state during Labor Day weekend in 2020, according to OPB. OPB said the court is likely to rule in writing within months.
At issue is whether to reinstate a 2023 jury verdict that found PacifiCorp at fault for four fires. OPB reports that more than $1 billion has been awarded so far to about 200 survivors, and about two thousand more claims could be affected. Reuters, via the trade outlet Claims Journal, put the awards at $1.25 billion for 201 plaintiffs and said over a thousand others still await trial. The outlets differ on how many claims remain, and the awards have been set aside since the Court of Appeals ruled.
The Oregon Court of Appeals threw out the liability verdict and the resulting judgments on April 8. Reuters reported that the court cited evidence about "particular issues concerning particular wildfires" and suggested the trial judge reconsider whether the case should be a class action. Damages trials for additional survivors remain on hold while the Supreme Court decides, OPB reported.
The dispute centers on one sentence in the instructions the trial judge gave jurors: "You may assume that the evidence at trial applies to all class members." PacifiCorp attorney Theodore Boutrous told the justices the instruction invited jurors to treat evidence about one fire as applying to everyone. Attorney Nicholas Rosinia, representing survivors, argued the evidence was enough to prove PacifiCorp's responsibility for each of the four fires.
Many justices appeared skeptical that the instruction confused jurors, OPB reported, pointing to separate verdict forms for each fire. Justice Bronson James also noted that PacifiCorp had asked for changes to the instructions during the trial. Boutrous said the utility objects to both the instruction and the class-action format.
Plaintiffs allege that PacifiCorp's equipment and its failure to shut off power during a windstorm sparked four fires. Across Oregon, the Labor Day 2020 fires destroyed more than 3,000 buildings and killed 11 people, according to OPB, and Reuters said claimants say the four fires damaged more than 2,000 properties. A jury found the utility grossly negligent in 2023, OPB reported; PacifiCorp has denied negligence.
PacifiCorp told Inside Climate News that it has spent $2.2 billion since 2020 settling over 4,500 claims it considers reasonable, roughly 90 percent of the claims against it. Reuters separately reported about $2.3 billion in settlements with claimants outside the class through June 30; the outlets do not explain the difference.
The case sits within a wider argument over who should bear wildfire costs. In a two-part series, Inside Climate News reported that U.S. utilities have faced over $18 billion in wildfire liabilities during the past decade, with costs often passed on to customers. A California Public Utilities Commission report published Nov. 1 found that customers of PG&E, Edison and San Diego Gas & Electric together paid over $35 billion in wildfire-related costs from 2020 through 2026, which Inside Climate News said consisted mostly of mitigation work.
Several states have responded by limiting utility liability. Wyoming, Idaho and Montana passed laws in 2025 shielding utilities that follow approved mitigation plans, and Utah has had a similar law since 2020, Inside Climate News reported. Critics say such laws weaken safety incentives, while supporters say they help stabilize utilities. In California, a bill to change liability rules failed to get a second vote, the outlet reported. Survivor advocate Joy Chen objected to the governor's original proposal, saying it would have undermined survivors' ability to recover.
Reuters reported that Berkshire Hathaway's chief executive, Greg Abel, has warned that big wildfire payouts threaten the "regulatory compact" under which utilities accept oversight in return for reasonable profits.
Inside Climate News also reported that Southern California Edison, which does not accept that its equipment started the 2025 Eaton Fire, is arguing in court that Los Angeles County and others share responsibility for how the fire spread. The county did not respond to the outlet's request for comment, though it has sued Edison, alleging the company failed to shut off power lines during a red flag warning.
A separate Inside Climate News report examined whether litigation is discouraging prescribed burns, the deliberate fires used to reduce fuel. The Forest Service said it conducts thousands of such burns each year and that more than 99.9 percent stay within their planned area. The outlet's analysis of federal data found no sign of a recent decline: acreage rose in 2023 and 2024 before dropping back toward earlier levels amid staffing cuts. Practitioners such as Sean Hendrix of the Oregon Prescribed Fire Council said insurance for burn contractors is getting harder to keep.
California and Oregon have launched small funds that would pay up to $2 million and $1 million, respectively, for damage from an escaped burn if proper procedure was followed. No claims had been filed as of November 2026.
Next, the Oregon Supreme Court will issue its written ruling, which could reinstate the judgments or return the case to the trial court. Further damages trials stay paused until then.
Get NationofChange in your inbox
Independent reporting every weekday. No paywall, no advertisers, no corporate owner. Free, and you can unsubscribe whenever you like.
Subscribe free


















COMMENTS