Israel’s standoff on Gaza displacement and hostage dynamics

The decision to bar Palestinians from returning to their homes raises significant concerns under international humanitarian law.


Israeli officials are set to convey a stern message to U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken. As reported first by Axios, Israel plans to condition the return of displaced Palestinians in northern Gaza on Hamas’s release of additional hostages. This move comes amid escalating tensions and international scrutiny over Israel’s actions in the region.

The decision to bar Palestinians from returning to their homes raises significant concerns under international humanitarian law. Observers have pointed out that denying a displaced population the right to return is a violation of these laws. “Such actions challenge the very principles of international humanitarian law,” an international legal expert commented. Approximately 130 hostages remain in Gaza, as per Israeli sources.

Mohammad Alsaafin, a senior producer at AJ+, highlighted the U.S.’s critical role in this situation. “Israel is essentially using U.S.-supplied weapons to perpetrate what could be classified as ethnic cleansing,” he wrote. U.S. law prohibits arms transfers to nations likely to commit war crimes, placing the Biden administration in a precarious position regarding its ongoing support for Israel.

Secretary Blinken’s arrival in Tel Aviv marks a pivotal moment in U.S.-Israeli relations. His visit, amidst Israel’s continued assault on Gaza, is seen as crucial for negotiating a path forward. The U.S. has been a staunch supporter of Israel, supplying significant military aid despite international calls for cease-fires and peace negotiations.

The U.S. State Department has recently criticized some Israeli ministers for advocating the permanent expulsion of Gazans. While maintaining that these views do not represent the Israeli government’s position, Axios’ reporting casts doubt on this claim. “The U.S. stance appears increasingly at odds with actions on the ground,” a diplomatic analyst noted.

The International Court of Justice is set to hold hearings on a case alleging genocide by Israel against South Africa. “Israel’s explicit description of forced displacement as a tactic just before these significant trials is a risky move,” commented HuffPost’s Akbar Shahid Ahmed on social media.

Gaza’s population has been severely affected, with about 90% displaced due to Israel’s military campaign. The northern part of the strip has seen over two-thirds of its structures destroyed. Israeli evacuation orders have pushed many Gazans into increasingly dire conditions, with shortages of food and basic necessities.

IDF spokesperson Daniel Hagari announced a shift in Israel’s military campaign, focusing on central and southern Gaza. “The fighting will continue throughout 2024,” he stated, signaling a prolonged period of conflict and uncertainty for the region.

Secretary Blinken’s tour in the Middle East, including meetings with leaders in Abu Dhabi and Saudi Arabia, aims to prevent the Gaza conflict from spilling over into Lebanon and other regions. His talks are critical in shaping the future of the Gaza Strip and the broader geopolitical landscape of the Middle East.

Secretary Blinken’s diplomatic efforts and Israel’s hardline stance on the return of displaced Gazans remain central to the unfolding narrative in the region.

In a recent statement, Blinken emphasized, “Palestinian civilians must be able to return home as soon as conditions allow.”


If you liked this article, please donate $5 to keep NationofChange online through November.

Previous articleWe can end mass atrocities in Gaza and beyond
Next articleSunsetting the War on Terror—or not
Alexis Sterling is a seasoned War and Human Rights Reporter with a passion for reporting the truth in some of the world's most tumultuous regions. With a background in journalism and a keen interest in international affairs, Alexis's reporting is grounded in a commitment to human rights and a deep understanding of the complexities of global conflicts. Her work seeks to give voice to the voiceless and bring to light the human stories behind the headlines. Alexis is dedicated to responsible and engaged journalism, constantly striving to inform and educate the public on critical issues of war and human rights across the globe.