Women say they reported a Wisconsin sheriff who claimed he was never accused

Price County, Wisconsin, Sheriff Brian Schmidt denies the allegations through his attorney. The county says it has no records of the complaints, Wisconsin Watch reports.

0
SOURCENationofChange
Price County Courthouse.JPG
The Price County Courthouse in Phillips, Wisconsin Photo: Billertl / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0)

A sheriff in northern Wisconsin sued an election opponent for defamation and said in a court filing that he had never faced a misconduct accusation. Women now allege misconduct by him decades ago, and at least one says she complained at the time, according to an investigation by Wisconsin Watch. Price County Sheriff Brian Schmidt, through his attorney, denies the allegations.

The allegations are unproven. Wisconsin Watch, a nonprofit newsroom, said its months-long inquiry included interviews with more than 70 people and a review of hundreds of pages of court, agency and personnel documents.

Schmidt, a Republican, first won the office in 2009. In 2022 John Brylski, a retired detective, challenged him as a write-in candidate after posting allegations about Schmidt's past online. A month before that election, Schmidt sued Brylski for defamation, Wisconsin Watch reported. WXPR reported that Schmidt won with 94% of the vote and Brylski received about 6%.

In a court filing in that case, Schmidt said he “has never been disciplined in his position or accused of improper conduct,” according to Wisconsin Watch. The parties privately settled in July 2024 under an agreement that included a nondisclosure clause. The next day Brylski posted a statement saying that information he had circulated was not accurate. Wisconsin Watch reported that Brylski later disavowed that statement in a new lawsuit, claiming he was coerced. Schmidt had that case moved to federal court.

Tammy Hastings, who chairs the county Republican Party, told the state Department of Justice this year that Schmidt sexually assaulted her in 1990, when she was 19. She places the encounter in his squad car. She told Wisconsin Watch she filed three complaints with the sheriff's office in the 1990s and that nothing came of them. Schmidt's attorney, Robert Mihelich, said the complaints “were either never made or never made known to” Schmidt.

Mihelich acknowledged that Schmidt is the father of Hastings' child but said the encounter was consensual, citing the recording described below and noting that Hastings signed Schmidt's 2009 nomination papers. He said her past struggles with alcohol and her history of police contacts undermine her credibility. Hastings has acknowledged those struggles and said she stands by her account. She told Wisconsin Watch she never described the encounter as consensual. Wisconsin Watch reported that Mihelich provided a recording of conversations between Hastings and Schmidt in 2024, which each side interprets differently.

A second woman, Suzy Jo Petersen, said that in 1995, at age 14, she was kept in the back of his squad car for over 30 minutes after a stop. She said he touched her leg and told her she was pretty. Mihelich said her account is false. He said the encounter lasted 15 to 20 minutes, that another officer was present and that Petersen never got off her snowmobile. Petersen called that “a complete lie.”

Wisconsin Watch reported that 11 people it interviewed gave accounts that conflict with the attorney's version of the Petersen incident. Former county officials said the episode led to a disciplinary hearing before a closed county board committee. Lauri Millot, then the county's human resources administrator, said she drafted a formal complaint.

Former Sheriff Richard Heitkemper said the incident was part of his reason for removing Schmidt as the county's DARE officer in 1997. Schmidt's lawyer said the DARE role never produced a misconduct claim against him. Mihelich did not deny that a hearing took place. He disputed Heitkemper's account, pointing out that Heitkemper ran against Schmidt as a Democrat in 2010.

Much of what the women allege is not reflected in county records. The county told Wisconsin Watch it has no records of the complaints or of any hearing, and County Clerk Meredith Hueckman said in an email that the county would not speculate about what was done more than 30 years ago. Wisconsin Watch found that state law and county ordinances almost certainly required the county to keep such records. The outcome of the hearing is unknown, and Heitkemper recalled that the board took no disciplinary action.

Wisconsin Watch also described a third woman who, in a 2024 recorded interview, a transcript of which is in the court record, said Schmidt began a sexual relationship with her when she was under the age of consent. Mihelich denied any relationship and cited her criminal history. Wisconsin Watch did not name her, citing her status as an alleged assault victim.

It also obtained a 2000 complaint from an 18-year-old woman about a traffic stop. Mihelich said that complaint concerned the scope of a search, not sexual harassment. The woman later gave a sworn statement in the defamation case calling Schmidt's behavior “sexual harassment,” Wisconsin Watch reported.

Schmidt declined multiple requests for an interview, Wisconsin Watch said. His attorney said that “Much of what you have stated as allegations against Mr. Schmidt are false, misleading and fabricated,” according to the report.

Wisconsin Watch also reported that Hastings contacted the Department of Justice's Office of Crime Victim Services, which said it could not assist because no charges had been filed.

WXPR reported that Schmidt said he will not seek reelection and intends to retire when his term ends. Robert Hawn won the Republican primary for sheriff in August, according to unofficial results, and no Democrat ran. Schmidt will leave office at the end of the year, Wisconsin Watch reported. Support resources are listed at RAINN.org.

Get NationofChange in your inbox

Independent reporting every weekday. No paywall, no advertisers, no corporate owner. Free, and you can unsubscribe whenever you like.

Subscribe free

FALL FUNDRAISER

If you liked this article, please donate $5 to keep NationofChange online through November.

[give_form id="735829"]

COMMENTS