New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch announced Monday that the NYPD's Strategic Response Group will be disbanded and replaced with what Mamdani called a civilian-led approach to protests. At least one advocacy group warns the plan could amount to the same officers under new names.
In its announcement, City Hall said the group's terrorism-related work, such as stationing heavily armed officers at critical infrastructure, will move to the NYPD's Intelligence and Counterterrorism Bureau. Protest response will be handled by three new pieces: a Community Dialogue and De-escalation Division inside the Mayor's Office of Community Safety, a 30-officer First Amendment Support Team, and a Patrol Support Division.
The civilian division will not have weapons or arrest powers, the mayor's office said. The 30 uniformed officers on the support team, based in the department's Community Affairs Bureau, will be trained in communication and de-escalation and will lead that work while the civilian division is built. The Patrol Support Division will sit within the Patrol Services Bureau, and its vetted officers will make arrests at protests in rare instances, if necessary.
"New Yorkers exercising their constitutional right to protest should not be met with the same police response as a terrorism threat," Mamdani said in the announcement. He had promised during his campaign to disband the unit, which was created in 2015.
The city also announced new limits on all officers during First Amendment activity. They include a formal ban on kettling, long guns and tear gas, an end to pepper spray as a general crowd-management tool, and a 90-decibel cap on long-range acoustic devices. amNY reported that some of these rules build on a 2023 legal settlement stemming from the NYPD's George Floyd protest policing, which already barred kettling.
Tisch said the changes will not weaken the department. "I would never support changes that diminish the NYPD's ability to protect New Yorkers," she said in a statement. amNY noted that this differs from what she told the City Council in March, when she described her talks with Mamdani as "not to disband" the unit.
The reaction split along familiar lines. NYCLU Executive Director Donna Lieberman, whose group has called for the unit's dissolution since 2021, said "the demise of the SRG is a victory for our First Amendment rights," according to amNY. The Legal Aid Society also welcomed the change but said it would require "vigilant oversight to ensure that the SRG's tactics are not repeated."
Loyda Colón, executive director of the Justice Committee, raised the sharpest concern. She warned that the overhaul could amount to "rebranding and reshuffling SRG officers and functions," amNY reported. Colón wants the new patrol division to publish its deployments regularly, and she questioned whether the civilian team might make the Office of Community Safety an arm of the police.
Some details back up the questions. The new plan does not end the NYPD's authority to make arrests at demonstrations. "Trained officers can be called upon to come make arrests, including for those engaging in civil disobedience," Mamdani said, according to amNY. City Hall has not given a staffing number for the Patrol Support Division, and it has not said which misconduct findings, if any, would automatically bar an officer, amNY reported. NBC New York reported that about 600 officers belonged to the SRG and will be reassigned by mid-February.
City Hall said vetting of officers will weigh complaints on file with the Civilian Complaint Review Board and internal police investigators. It also said the Patrol Support Division will spend most of its time on routine patrol support, including missing-person searches, the New York City Marathon and the Thanksgiving Day Parade. The restructuring will not change headcount and carries no added cost, the mayor's office said.
Police unions pushed back. Patrick Hendry, president of the Police Benevolent Association, said Mamdani was willing "to put our safety and police officers' safety at risk to appease his radical base," according to Fox News. Scott Munro, president of the Detectives' Endowment Association, argued, according to Fox News, that detectives will be pulled from criminal investigations to help police protests.
At a news conference, a reporter asked Mamdani about criticism that the plan does not go far enough, given that the new patrol unit could take the place of the old one in many situations. Mamdani said the city is "fundamentally transforming how our city both prepares for protests and responds to protests," according to a transcript from his office. He added that police will always be present when there is violence.
Critics have attacked the SRG's use of force for years, including during the 2020 protests after George Floyd's killing and in the demonstrations that followed an ICE-involved shooting in Marble Hill, NY1 reported. In testimony cited by NBC New York, the NYPD described the unit's officers as highly trained, well-vetted professionals who respond to citywide mobilizations and civil disorders.
Mamdani said the plan takes effect in 90 days, which NBC New York put at mid-February, when the roughly 600 SRG officers are to be reassigned. In the transcript, he said the civilian division will launch in 2028. NY1 reported that the overall transition will not be complete until the spring of 2027, and amNY reported that City Hall has set no firm completion date for the restructuring.
The City Council is the next test. Council Member Chi Ossé's CURB Act, which would write limits on protest policing into law, has 25 Council members and Public Advocate Jumaane Williams as sponsors and remains in the Public Safety Committee, according to amNY. Mamdani said the new rules accomplish the key changes the bill calls for and that he supports it. Lieberman urged Council Speaker Julie Menin to schedule a hearing and vote.
Get NationofChange in your inbox
Independent reporting every weekday. No paywall, no advertisers, no corporate owner. Free, and you can unsubscribe whenever you like.
Subscribe free



















COMMENTS