Supreme Court ruling denounced as ‘dangerous and serious’ attack on women’s right to contraceptive care

“No employer is welcome into the exam room when I talk to patients about their contraception options, why should they be able to dictate the method from their corner office?” asked one physician.

SOURCECommon Dreams

Reproductive rights advocates vowed to continue their fight to protect women’s access to contraceptives in the U.S. on Wednesday after the Supreme Court ruled that employers can refuse to provide birth control coverage for workers on religious or moral grounds.

The 7-2 decision in Trump vs. Pennsylvania—in which Justices Ruth Bader Ginsberg and Sonia Sotomayor dissented—could leave 120,000 women without coverage for birth control, more than five decades after the birth control pill became legal nationwide.

Under the ruling, companies can be shielded from abiding by the Affordable Care Act provision which requires employers to cover preventative care for employees, including contraceptive care.  In the opinion for the majority of the court, Justice Clarence Thomas wrote that the Trump administration had “the statutory authority to craft that exemption, as well as the contemporaneously issued moral exemption.” 

Planned Parenthood Action tweeted that Wednesday’s ruling crystallizes the fact that right-wing attacks on reproductive rights are focused on more than access to legal and safe abortions, and that advocates must prepare to fight for full reproductive justice.

Former Planned Parenthood president Cecile Richards—now a leader of the women-focused mobilization group Supermajority—appeared on MSNBC shortly after the ruling was handed down, detailing the benefits that have been afforded to women in the U.S. under the Obamacare birth control provision.

“This is a bad decision for women’s health,” Richards said. “One of the biggest successes of the Affordable Care Act was the coverage for 63 million women in this country for birth control. And this decision essentially now takes away that commitment. We’ve had a record low of teenage pregnancy, a 30-year low for unintended pregnancy across the board. It’s a very popular benefit and it crosses party lines… So this is a real unfortunate development for the health and safety of women.”

Alexis McGill Johnson, current president and CEO of Planned Parenthood Action Fund, called the decision to further limit Americans’ access to basic healthcare “egregious,” particularly during the coronavirus pandemic.

“The dual public health crises of Covid-19 and systemic racism and violence are pushing people, our healthcare system, and our economy beyond their limits, and yet today, the Supreme Court has allowed the Trump administration to make essential healthcare even more difficult to access,” said McGill Johnson. “Restrictions like this target Black and Latinx people who are more likely to be low income and for whom basic healthcare has always remained out of reach, because of historic and continued underinvestment in access to affordable care.”

On Twitter, the Guttmacher Institute, which advocates for women’s reproductive rights, wrote that the ruling “could set a dangerous precedent for allowing religion to be used as justification for policies that encourage discrimination.”

Dr. Daniel Grossman, director of Advancing New Standards in Reproductive Health (ANSIRH), called the ruling “a dangerous and a serious violation on workers’ freedoms, privacy, and healthcare access.”

Richards expressed hope that the Supreme Court ruling would galvanize women ahead of the 2020 presidential election. 

“I think it only serves to reinforce that this administration has done everything they can to eliminate healthcare access, and particularly for women—we know during Trumpcare they tried to get rid of maternity benefits,” Richards told MSNBC. “I actually think this decision and women understanding that they just lost a benefit and….their boss can now determine whether they can get birth control, that’s going to energize women even more, and they’re already the most energized group of voters in the country.”

McGill Johnson vowed that the Supreme Court decision would not be the end of Planned Parenthood’s fight for access to reproductive freedom.

“This is not over,” said McGill Johnson. “We will do all we can to ensure those who need birth control and other sexual and reproductive healthcare can access it. And we will not stop until that is a reality for everyone, no matter who you work for, where you go to school, how much money you make, or the color of your skin. You have the right to make your own decisions about your body, your healthcare, and your future, and we will never back down from this fight.”


If you liked this article, please donate $5 to keep NationofChange online through November.