
About 86% of the U.S. properties at high risk of flooding had no National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) coverage as of April 2026, according to a report published Oct. 1 by the Government Accountability Office. The program's authorization is set to expire Dec. 11.
West Virginia is a stark example. The GAO report said less than 2% of the state's properties had flood insurance as of December 2025, Mountain State Spotlight reported, even though 34% were at high flood risk by the GAO's measure. Only Louisiana, at 45%, had a higher share of high-risk properties, according to the GAO's analysis of First Street data from January 2024.
The state has seen deadly flooding in recent years. Mountain State Spotlight reported that two people have died in West Virginia floods this year and 14 last year, and that the state's mapping center lists 22 counties as being at high risk.
Part of the gap comes from how the law works. Owners with federally backed mortgages must buy flood insurance only if their property lies in a Special Flood Hazard Area mapped by the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA). The GAO estimated that 43% of properties inside those areas had insurance, compared with 2% outside them.
The maps do not capture every source of flooding, the GAO said, especially heavy rainfall, which Mountain State Spotlight said causes most West Virginia floods. Using First Street data, the GAO report put the number of high-risk properties outside the mapped zones at roughly 13 million. The GAO also said some consumers underestimate their risk, overestimate federal disaster aid, or assume homeowners policies cover floods, which most exclude.
Cost is another barrier. FEMA began applying risk-based pricing in October 2021, and the GAO has linked it to the loss of NFIP policies nationwide. Mountain State Spotlight cited a June 2025 letter to FEMA shared by Sen. Shelley Moore Capito, a West Virginia Republican who opposed the change. It said the new rates would raise annual premiums for West Virginia homeowners by about 176%, using August 2023 FEMA data, and that about 600 households had left the program.
NFIP policies in the state fell by more than 41% from 2009 to 2025, and the state's median income is 26% below the national median.
Nationally, the NFIP covered 4.5 million policies in 2026, down from 5.5 million in 2010, the GAO said, while private insurers wrote 14% of all flood policies in 2025. The Congressional Research Service reported that FEMA estimates about 4% of homeowners have flood insurance.
The GAO identified four steps that each need Congress to act: count all flood sources, including heavy rain, when deciding who must buy coverage; make property-level risk information public; require lenders to give buyers a flood insurance quote before closing; and raise NFIP coverage limits. The ABA Banking Journal noted that the limits have not changed since 1994. The GAO also repeated earlier advice to replace broad premium subsidies with targeted help and to remove barriers to private insurance.
GAO senior analyst Nathan Gottfried said at a briefing that many of the program's challenges were "structural and required congressional action to fix," according to the Louisiana Illuminator. He said the property-level data recommendation came from interviews showing owners, agents and lenders lack easy access to it, and that consumers who know their risk are "more likely to purchase the coverage," he said.
The program also carries financial strain. The NFIP is allowed to borrow from the Treasury when premiums fall short, and the Congressional Research Service said it owes the Treasury $22.525 billion, after Congress cancelled $16 billion of its debt in 2017. At a May 2025 Senate hearing, Robert Gordon of the American Property Casualty Insurance Association said the NFIP "underprices its coverage," as quoted by the research service. He said private insurers could not take on its business without much higher prices.
A May 2026 FEMA Review Council report proposed a voluntary program to shift some NFIP policies to private insurers. The research service said that approach could leave the NFIP with the riskiest properties and less revenue, and that legislation would be needed for reform.
Risk Rating 2.0, FEMA's pricing method, remains contested. Congress capped annual increases at 18% for primary residences, the research service said, and the GAO reported that NFIP policies fell 5% from October 2021 to October 2025. The Louisiana Illuminator reported that Louisiana is the lead plaintiff in a 2023 lawsuit to block the method, which critics say does not credit flood-protection work, and that the Justice Department moved in July to dismiss the case.
Mountain State Spotlight reported that Capito, Sen. Jim Justice, Rep. Riley Moore and Rep. Carol Miller, all West Virginia Republicans, did not respond when asked whether they would back the GAO's recommendations. The outlet said Congress has not acted on them so far.
Congress has passed 36 short-term NFIP extensions since the end of fiscal 2017, the Congressional Research Service said. The current one expires Dec. 11, 2026. Without another extension, the program could not issue new or renewal policies, according to the National Association of Realtors, though existing ones would stay in effect.
Get NationofChange in your inbox
Independent reporting every weekday. No paywall, no advertisers, no corporate owner. Free, and you can unsubscribe whenever you like.
Subscribe free


















COMMENTS