The Senate voted 70-27 on Monday to end debate on a substitute version of a sweeping energy permitting bill, with 21 Democratic-caucus members joining 49 Republicans. On Wednesday, the Senate floor log shows, the Senate adopted the substitute 69-27, then voted 65-31 to end debate on the bill itself. Neither was a vote on final passage.
The bill, the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, would speed approval of energy, mining and infrastructure projects. Its sponsors say it would lower power costs, and oil, gas and clean energy trade groups back it. Environmental groups say it would weaken legal protections.
The Monday vote was a procedural step known as cloture, which needs 60 votes. Of the 21 Democratic-caucus members who voted yes, 20 are Democrats and one, Angus King of Maine, is an independent. Those voting yes included Minority Leader Chuck Schumer and Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse of Rhode Island, one of the bill's four lead sponsors, according to the Senate roll call. Twenty-four Democrats and independent Bernie Sanders voted no. Republican Sens. Josh Hawley of Missouri and Mike Rounds of South Dakota also voted no.
Wednesday's tally was different. According to the Senate floor log, Democratic Sens. Richard Blumenthal, Andy Kim, Jon Ossoff, Gary Peters and Jeanne Shaheen, who had voted yes on Monday, voted no on Wednesday. Hawley and Rounds again voted no. In all, 29 members of the Democratic caucus (28 Democrats and Sanders) voted against ending debate, the log shows.
The bill's four sponsors are two Republicans (Capito of West Virginia and Lee of Utah) and two Democrats (Heinrich and Whitehouse). Heinrich said, as reported by OPB that “Americans can’t afford to wait for lower electricity prices.” Capito called the bill “a win for America” and said the country will “have no choice but to increase our national energy production.”
Whitehouse described the bill as “the floor, not the ceiling” of “our climate and environmental aspirations,” according to the same report. He also said a provision would end federal buyouts of offshore wind leases; the report says the administration has spent nearly $4 billion on such settlements. President Donald Trump, who supports the bill, told reporters, “I will not approve wind turbines” because they are “a major loser.”
On transmission, The Hill reported that the bill would direct the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission to set timelines for utilities to upgrade power lines. The outlet said new lines now take 10 years or longer to build and could take five or six years under the bill. Rob Gramlich, president of the consulting firm Grid Strategies, said its technology-neutral provisions would “enable many tens of gigawatts of clean energy to be connected,” according to Inside Climate News.
The bill also changes how courts handle challenges. The Congressional Research Service, summarizing the bill as introduced, says it would set a 150-day statute of limitations for claims under the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) and generally bar vacatur or injunctions unless certain criteria are met.
Earthjustice, an environmental law group that opposes parts of the bill, says in its analysis that it would cut the time allowed to sue over certain decisions under NEPA, the Clean Water Act, the Endangered Species Act and the National Historic Preservation Act. The group says challengers now have up to six years; the bill would allow 150 days.
Earthjustice also says courts could still order agencies to redo flawed NEPA analyses, but could not cancel permits or halt construction in the meantime. It says the bill would also exempt pipeline expansions within existing rights-of-way from NEPA review. The group separately highlights transmission and clean-energy provisions that it views as positive, including stronger federal backstop siting power at FERC.
Critics see a broader risk. Sen. Jeff Merkley, an Oregon Democrat, said the bill “accelerates the extraction and burning of fossil fuels,” according to The Hill. Advocacy groups opposed to it include the Sierra Club, NRDC and the Southern Environmental Law Center, the outlet reported. Nearly half of the Senate Democratic caucus opposes the bill, the outlet said.
After Wednesday's vote, Oil Change International's executive director, Elizabeth Bast, called it “a giveaway to Big Oil and Big Tech” in a joint statement with other groups. They said the bill was negotiated without a hearing or markup. Bast urged the House to reject it. Supporters say the bill's changes are needed to build faster, and Heinrich said the final text reflects feedback from tribal leaders.
Food & Water Watch policy director Jim Walsh used the vote to call on Schumer to give up his leadership post. Schumer's backing of the bill is “all the reason needed” for him to step down, Walsh said in a Nov. 18 statement, adding, “He is not fit to lead the Senate.” None of the reports reviewed included a response from Schumer.
Supporters also dispute that the bill favors fossil fuels. Sen. Kevin Cramer, a North Dakota Republican, said “This is fuel neutral,” according to The Hill. Rep. Vicente Gonzalez, a Texas Democrat, said it is “not a bad deal” and that the time to act is now. Industry groups such as the American Petroleum Institute and American Clean Power Association back it, OPB reported.
The Solar Energy Industries Association led a letter from 300 solar and storage companies urging quick passage, PV Tech reported. Its chief executive, Tim Pawlenty, said, “You can’t lower energy costs if you can’t build the energy projects”.
The Hill reported that Rhodium Group estimates the bill would lower household electricity bills by between $50 and $78 a month by 2040. Oil Change International and its allies dispute that the bill would help, saying it would not stop bills from rising.
The Hill reported Monday that the procedural vote sets up a final Senate vote before the Thanksgiving recess; the Senate floor log for Wednesday lists no time for it. If it passes, the bill goes to the House, where Democratic Reps. Jared Huffman of California and Adelita Grijalva of Arizona oppose it and Energy and Commerce Committee Chair Brett Guthrie has called for changes. The Hill reported that Trump is expected to sign it if it reaches him.
Get NationofChange in your inbox
Independent reporting every weekday. No paywall, no advertisers, no corporate owner. Free, and you can unsubscribe whenever you like.
Subscribe free


















COMMENTS