Native Americans are exempt from Medicaid work rules, but proof varies

Federal rules set no standard way for states to confirm who qualifies, and tribal health leaders fear people will fall through the cracks. CMS has also offered states an optional pause on denials through June 30, 2027.

0
SOURCENationofChange
An empty clinic waiting room with black chairs facing a wall-mounted television
A clinic waiting room. Photo: Harrison Keely / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 4.0)

American Indians and Alaska Natives are exempt from Medicaid's new work requirement, but tribal health leaders warn many could still lose coverage because states have no shared method for confirming who qualifies, KFF Health News reported this month.

The requirement comes from the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, which Congress passed last year. Under the law's text, the people excluded include Indians and Urban Indians as defined in federal Indian health law, California Indians, and anyone found eligible as an Indian for Indian Health Service care. States decide who falls in that group, following standards set by the federal health secretary. The exemption leaves out some Indigenous people, such as Native Hawaiians, KFF Health News reported.

CMS issued an interim final rule on June 1 that lists American Indians and Alaska Natives among the exempt groups. It covers adults ages 19 to 64 in 43 states and the District of Columbia, who must show 80 hours a month of work, school or similar activity. States must generally begin by Jan. 1, 2027.

According to KFF Health News, the rule tells states to check data they already hold before asking Native enrollees for more records. It does not set a standard process for proving tribal status, so states can ask for more proof than federal rules require.

KFF Health News asked 14 states how they will apply the exemption and got different answers. Six states (Arizona, Colorado, Montana, Nevada, New Mexico and Washington) will let people mark their tribal status on Medicaid applications. Arizona then checks that against records of Indian Health Service or tribal clinic visits. South Dakota matches enrollees against its Indian Health Service claims. North Carolina wants one of three things: an enrollment card, a census record from the tribe, or confirmation from a tribal program.

North Carolina has verified 3,400 Native enrollees as exempt, and they will be exempted automatically, state health department spokesperson Summer Tonizzo told KFF Health News. The state does not know how many more could qualify through tribal citizenship. Most states did not say how many exempt enrollees they have found, and several said they do not track tribal affiliation because ethnicity questions on applications are optional.

A.C. Locklear, who leads the National Indian Health Board, said 30-plus states are rebuilding their processes independently, with little coordination. "There's still going to be folks that fall through the cracks," said Locklear, a Lumbee citizen. A tribal advisory group to CMS recommended in July that the agency require states to accept self-attestation as standard proof. KFF Health News said CMS did not reply when asked if more guidance is coming.

Native people who live far from their tribes may face the most trouble. About 87% of Native people live outside tribal statistical areas, according to 2020 Census data cited by KFF Health News. Liz Malerba of the United South and Eastern Tribes said a Navajo citizen in Connecticut might struggle to be identified by a state with little contact with that nation.

The stakes extend beyond individual patients. A December KFF analysis found that 35% of American Indian and Alaska Native people under 65 have coverage through Medicaid or the Children's Health Insurance Program. The same analysis says Medicaid supplied $1.3 billion of the almost $1.8 billion the Indian Health Service collected from outside payers in fiscal year 2025 (KFF). Congress has historically failed to fully fund the agency, according to CBS News.

Native leaders point to the Medicaid unwinding that followed the pandemic. The National Council of Urban Indian Health put the loss at 850,000-plus Native Americans as of May 2024, and KFF Health News reported the losses were often for paperwork reasons. In Montana, which saw one of the sharpest enrollment drops then, checks began in July. A state health department spokesperson, Jon Ebelt, said self-declared tribal status needs no extra proof.

Early results from Nebraska, which started in May, show how paperwork can drive losses among all enrollees, not only Native people. The Associated Press reported that 533 people were denied continued coverage in July and August renewals, mostly because they did not show they were working or exempt. Only 43 of them lost coverage for failing the requirement itself.

CMS told state Medicaid directors on Nov. 13 that states may suspend denials and disenrollments for people who do not show they meet the requirement or qualify for an exclusion, the agency's letter states. This "hold harmless" period runs through June 30, 2027, and states may use less of it. The Jan. 1 start date does not change, and states must still assess whether people qualify. States that want the option from Jan. 1 are asked to notify CMS by Dec. 11. Daniel Brillman, a CMS deputy administrator, signed the letter.

CMS said states are making progress but face challenges, the AP reported. Kathy Hempstead of the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation told the AP she expects fewer people to lose coverage from administrative failures, though it is unclear which states will opt in. Locklear cautioned that states will have settled on their own processes if CMS waits until December for more detailed guidance on the exemption. Democrats who take control of Congress in January have said they want to roll the requirements back, according to the AP.

Under that option, the deadline for states to put the requirement fully into effect moves to June 30. States that decline it must begin on Jan. 1. Locklear cautioned that states will have settled on their own processes if CMS waits until December for more detailed guidance on the exemption. Democrats who take control of Congress in January have said they want to roll the requirements back, according to the AP.

Get NationofChange in your inbox

Independent reporting every weekday. No paywall, no advertisers, no corporate owner. Free, and you can unsubscribe whenever you like.

Subscribe free

FALL FUNDRAISER

If you liked this article, please donate $5 to keep NationofChange online through November.

[give_form id="735829"]

COMMENTS